Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by martyb on Monday September 12 2016, @11:56AM   Printer-friendly
from the avoided-Betteridge's-Law-of-Headlines dept.

I've been an Android user since Froyo, over several devices. I'm beginning to think that there must be a better way.

First, although I liked Android, especially the part that was Open Source, I'll suggest that the whole Android ecosystem represents a dead end.

At a minimum, it seems like madness to rely on two or more layers of outside partners to deliver software patches and updates. It's just not reasonable or safe for end users to wait for months or years until device makers and wireless carriers deliver patches from Google - if they ever do.

That there's no way a user can update their system without their cooperation is just not acceptable today.

Second, even if an update or patch does arrive, it brings with it the likelihood that some feature or application that you have been using will be hobbled, eliminated, or just plain be made unusable by Google. Services provided by Google are subject to changes that, depending on your circumstances, make them significantly less usable. (Gmail being a prime example) Standalone apps like Reader or MyTracks may just stop working one day if Google loses interest.

Finally, there's the Play store, and the millions of apps available to users. I think that most people would agree that trying to find a usable app for a specific purpose is an exercise in frustration.

[Continues...]

The current system pretty much requires you to guess on a search term to find an app, then wade through dozens or hundreds of possible results.

App ratings are filled with obvious astroturf, or one word disses - neither of these help you tell if an app actually works. Without someone actually moderating the ratings system it is pretty much of no value.

There's no practical way to tell if an app is a finished product, or an abandoned half-baked pastime. Our only option, even with paid apps, is to install it and find out if it works.

There is speculation that Google may be preparing to abandon Android, but will a new Google OS really be any better for end users?

The problem is that Android has more or less become the only game in town, so what alternative will we see emerge?

Obvious notes:

a) Cyanogenmod - been there, done that. Not a realistic option for the vast majority of end users. And honestly, I just don't have the time and inclination to root and install it these days.
b) iPhone - actually owned a Powerbook for three years as my primary machine. Gave it my best go, but just don't like the way Apple machines do things. YMMV.
c) BlackBerry - actually really loved the BlackBerry, except that it REALLY didn't play well with Google contacts, and they refuse to support either Linux, or individual end users.
c) Linux - yup. Guess I'm spoiled. Stuff generally doesn't break, and if I need a specific tool or function — someone, somewhere has almost always created it.


Original Submission

 
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 3, Insightful) by bradley13 on Monday September 12 2016, @12:15PM

    by bradley13 (3053) on Monday September 12 2016, @12:15PM (#400655) Homepage Journal

    Some points, like problems with the search function in the App Store, seem a bit petty.

    But the really important points are on the mark. Since the 1980s, we have had open-architecture computers, where those so inclined could replace individual hardware components. While operating systems have generally come pre-installed, it has generally been possible to replace them. And certainly, we have had the choice of what programs to install on our computers.

    The current Android and iOS systems have eliminated all of this, by coming to the masses as replacements for mobile phones. The hardward is not user-modifiable. The operating system is baked into the hardward. While we can choose to install additional apps, just try to uninstall the ones that come pre-delivered. Eliminate Google apps from an Android phone? Apple apps from an iPhone? Not possible.

    So, those points are valid and true. Unfortunately, the masses don't care. So, no, perhaps unfortunately, Android is not a dead end.

    --
    Everyone is somebody else's weirdo.
    Starting Score:    1  point
    Moderation   +1  
       Insightful=1, Total=1
    Extra 'Insightful' Modifier   0  
    Karma-Bonus Modifier   +1  

    Total Score:   3  
  • (Score: 3, Informative) by everdred on Monday September 12 2016, @07:07PM

    by everdred (110) on Monday September 12 2016, @07:07PM (#400878) Journal

    > The operating system is baked into the hardward.

    While there are limitations like closed drivers, that doesn't seem to have stopped community ROMs from appearing for many Android devices. The OS is very much not baked-in.

    > Eliminate Google apps from an Android phone? (...) Not possible.

    This is totally possible, and Android doesn't get enough credit for it. Go to Settings > Apps > Gmail and you'll find a handy "Disable" button. Same for Google Maps, same for Google Play Music, same for anything you can think of. Disable an app, even a system app, and it will not run again, and basically no longer exists. (Though if it was pre-loaded into the ROM, it will still take up some system space.)

    Android doesn't get credit for this, because it's not something they go out of their way to make widely known. However, it's something anyone commenting about Android on SoylentNews should make it their business to know.