Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by martyb on Friday September 23 2016, @04:27PM   Printer-friendly
from the teaching-to-the-test-yields-a-fail dept.

El Reg reports

The NRDC [Natural Resources Defense Council] reckons TV makers are configuring sets to perform well on government tests, while in the living room they become energy hogs.

Its specific claims are:

  • The TVs perform well on the US Department of Energy-mandated energy use test--but that's based on a clip that doesn't match real-world video content. ([To El Reg,] that seems like a slip-up by the DoE);
  • TVs from Samsung, LG, and Vizio are designed to disable energy-saving features if the user changes their screen settings, but there's little or no warning about this. This, the NRDC says, can as much as double the power consumption; and
  • UHD TVs turn into energy hogs when they're playing high dynamic range (HDR) content, but HDR isn't included in the DoE's test (again, surely that means the DoE needs to update its tests?).

The NRDC says European testing seemed to match another observation it made: that during the DOE test loop, some TVs seemed to exhibit "inexplicable and sustained drops in energy use". It suggests that software is specifically detecting the test loop and adjusting the TV's performance to suit.

One assumes that "a clip" refers to the standard video loop used in the tests.


Original Submission

 
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 2) by bob_super on Friday September 23 2016, @06:56PM

    by bob_super (1357) on Friday September 23 2016, @06:56PM (#405659)

    The problem is the multiplication of modes, which provide multiple valid test points. But the most common ones should be enough to agree to test. It's not like the power draw is currently the biggest item on the marketing list (in the US)
      - Off
      - Standby
      - analog-input HD and native resolution
      - HDMI-input max-resolution
      - Ethernet/Wifi streaming - Max resolution
    There. You have your typical and relevant numbers. Which the customer will ignore anyway

    Starting Score:    1  point
    Karma-Bonus Modifier   +1  

    Total Score:   2  
  • (Score: 2) by jmorris on Friday September 23 2016, @07:22PM

    by jmorris (4844) on Friday September 23 2016, @07:22PM (#405670)

    That is the simplistic thinking responsible for this article. Switch on/off some of the advanced processing and power consumption is going to change. You want to take 24 frame movie content and have software/dsp magic make it into 240frames with motion compensation? Power consumption goes up. You want fancy tricks to increase contrast? That means more DSP magic that sucks energy. The vendor enables the tv's camera to spy on you and send marketing data, like what percentage of the time you are actually looking at the screen, how many people are in the room not looking at the screen, etc., back to the mothership? More signal processing.

    In a sane world an appliance like a TV would list power consumption in the 'as shipped' configuration, the 'as displayed in the store mode' consumption, power consumption in 'max power saving' mode and finally for 'full performance mode.' Assuming there are more than 1% of customers who consider it a purchasing decision bit of information in the first place, which there probably isn't.

    • (Score: 3, Interesting) by bob_super on Friday September 23 2016, @09:16PM

      by bob_super (1357) on Friday September 23 2016, @09:16PM (#405720)

      The other solution, since companies optimize like crazy these days, is to force them to put on the box the power consumption corresponding to 80% the AC fuse size.
      The obvious reaction will be to say: wait, then they'll put a smaller fuse!
      Sure, but when that fuse blows up the first year in half of their product under warranty, making news and bad reviews pop everywhere, they'll have to raise it to keep alive, or reduce the power consumption.
      Mission F___ing accomplished