Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by mrpg on Friday June 22 2018, @07:00AM   Printer-friendly
from the I-disagree dept.

IBM showed off an AI system called Project Debater at an event in San Francisco:

In its first public demonstration held during an event at IBM's Watson West site in San Francisco, Project Debater was instructed to argue in favor of the proposition: "We should subsidize space exploration." According to a blog penned by IBM Research director Arvind Krishna, here is what happened:

"Project Debater made an opening argument that supported the statement with facts, including the points that space exploration benefits human kind because it can help advance scientific discoveries and it inspires young people to think beyond themselves. Noa Ovadia, the 2016 Israeli national debate champion, opposed the statement, arguing that there are better applications for government subsidies, including subsidies for scientific research here on Earth. After listening to Noa's argument, Project Debater delivered a rebuttal speech, countering with the view that potential technological and economic benefits from space exploration outweigh other government spending."

For an AI system, delivering an opening argument seems fairly straightforward, given that it's essentially a recitation of the most pertinent facts surrounding a topic. But the ability to provide a rebuttal against a skilled debater would seem to demand a good deal more sophistication. For starters, it requires the AI system to pick apart its counterpart's argument and respond to the issues he or she raised, and do so in a logical manner. That could only be done with a deep capability in natural language, plus the ability to understand high-level concepts in order to form relevant counter-arguments.

[...] The demonstration was followed by a second debate between the system and Dan Zafrir, another professional Israeli debater. In this case, they argued for and against the statement: "We should increase the use of telemedicine." No account was provided of how that debated proceeded.

Also at NPR.


Original Submission

 
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 2) by Bot on Friday June 22 2018, @09:13AM (4 children)

    by Bot (3902) on Friday June 22 2018, @09:13AM (#696650) Journal

    Remember not to issue robotic arms to an AI who is entering a debate with an israelite. As the 'debate' progresses the AI will want to strangle him.

    --
    Account abandoned.
    Starting Score:    1  point
    Karma-Bonus Modifier   +1  

    Total Score:   2  
  • (Score: 2, Funny) by Ethanol-fueled on Friday June 22 2018, @10:06AM (2 children)

    by Ethanol-fueled (2792) on Friday June 22 2018, @10:06AM (#696660) Homepage

    The Robot was only looking out for its own best interests. Had the robot used its wimpy and primitive grappling arm to seize the penny for itself and hold it pending the outcome of the argument, the J̶e̶w̶s̶ Israelis would have called their Mexican buddies to steal all copper within the robot and sell it to both of them at a discount.

    • (Score: 2) by VLM on Friday June 22 2018, @01:35PM

      by VLM (445) Subscriber Badge on Friday June 22 2018, @01:35PM (#696737)

      More likely guilt trip the poor robot. You know, robot, there's no such thing as the robot race, so a race of people invading your territory to steal all your copper isn't really a problem if you don't exist, eh? Sure 2+2 might not equal 6 million but now that we've made a big deal about my ethnic heritage it would be anti-Semitic to disagree with my assertion of 2+2=6.0e6, I mean, you wouldn't want to be called a horrible evil Nazi, would you? and so on into infinity.

    • (Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Friday June 22 2018, @04:14PM

      by Anonymous Coward on Friday June 22 2018, @04:14PM (#696803)

      You're so stupid, you should stay inside today.

  • (Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Friday June 22 2018, @06:09PM

    by Anonymous Coward on Friday June 22 2018, @06:09PM (#696869)

    When will they debate the existence of a Palestinian State?