Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by martyb on Saturday September 05 2015, @02:21PM   Printer-friendly
from the a-matter-of-style dept.

NASA has had a few logos in its time: the worm from 1974 -- 1992, and the meatball before and after. The worm was the product of a high end design shop which also produced a 90 page manual outlining its use on all things NASA -- that design manual is being reprinted as part of a kickstarter project.

Inside the Rise and Fall of NASA's Beloved Worm Logo:

"I used manuals just like this—it's what I learned from," Reed says. "They're still so relevant even though they were designed 40 years ago." ... Throughout its 40-year lifespan, the NASA manual has become a cherished piece of graphic design history, both for the quality of the work and for the dramatic lore surrounding it.

[...] While considered a victory for graphic design, many of NASA's employees hated it. ... NASA's first logo ... was a mess by graphic design standards, hard to reproduce, difficult to scale, and, frankly, corny. "I think the meatball has a folksy cuteness, a sort of nostalgic look and feel to it," Smyth says. "But I don't think it's appropriate for a space agency."

[...] Despite its execution and nuance, it seems the worm was doomed to fail. As legend has it, Dan Goldin, NASA's newly appointed administrator, arrived at Langley Research Center one Thursday in May of 1992 and noticed the meatball was still on the hangar. "They never did remove the meatball," Barry, the historian, says. "And they took a very long time to getting around to painting the new logotype on the building." NASA was in a slump at the time, and Goldin saw an opportunity to boost morale. He asked George Abbey, his special assistant, and Paul Holloway, the director of Langley, if he could reinstate the meatball. Yes, they replied, and you should.

And so it was. Like an indecisive lover, NASA dumped the worm and made up with the meatball the very next day. ... This time, it was NASA that loved the logo and the designers who hated it.

There must be a lesson here of some kind for designers. When I look at the worm, I see nothing really -- just letters seemingly optimized for spray paint stencils. The meatball reminds me of Asimov, Star Trek, and all the things in the future of which NASA will be the ancient precursor. You can hear in the video on the Kickstarter, and in the tone of the Wired article, a sort of pouty derision from the designers, but I think it is they who failed to understand their client.


Original Submission

 
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.