Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by cmn32480 on Saturday December 10 2016, @08:01PM   Printer-friendly
from the before-we-knew-it-was-poison dept.

One of the great mysteries of the Victorian Age was the disappearance of the Franklin Expedition to discover the Northwest Passage. The belief is that their ships became locked in ice and the crews had to abandon them. In the 1980s, three bodies were found and examination of the bodies showed signs of elevated levels of lead. Because of this, most people believed that the crew was poisoned by the solder used in the tin cans of their provisions and that they fell to delirium and cannibalism as a result of the lead poisoning. When it was later pointed out that the food the expedition carried was not acidic enough to leech the lead out of the solder, attention was turned to the water pipes used to distribute drinking water on their ships.

In 2014 and 2016, two of the expedition ships were found. Despite the passage of time, they found the storerooms to have been well organized and not showing signs of a crew experiencing the hallucinations or delirium symptoms of lead poisoning. The remains of one of the crewmen, John Hartnell, still contained intact finger and toenails, analysis of which is able to reveal the week-by-week changes in his body. These results were reported in the Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports and they show that Hartnell had a severe zinc deficiency, not lead poisoning. A severe zinc deficiency would have suppressed his immune system and made him vulnerable to other more likely diseases such as pneumonia and tuberculosis. Hartnell did show relatively high levels of lead in his nails, but that was only in his last few weeks of life. They propose that Hartnell's dying body probably broke down and released long-stored lead from his bones into his blood and nails.

"The lead theory is pretty much dismantled by this point," says Ron Martin, an analytical chemist at Western University in London, Canada. In 2013, he analysed bone fragments from several crewmembers including Hartnell, and concluded that they had experienced consistent lead exposure throughout their lives, with no spike during the expedition.


Original Submission

This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 3, Interesting) by goodie on Saturday December 10 2016, @10:45PM

    by goodie (1877) on Saturday December 10 2016, @10:45PM (#439819) Journal

    I ask because one thing sailors will often say it's that it's pretty rare to contract certain diseases due to the lack of exposure to sick people. Of course once one gets it, everybody pretty much will as well. But that's why I would not expect tuberculosis, an infectious disease, to appear out of nowhere on this type of expedition. Of course I am no expert so that might just be me being stupid :D

    • (Score: 3, Interesting) by Francis on Saturday December 10 2016, @11:21PM

      by Francis (5544) on Saturday December 10 2016, @11:21PM (#439826)

      It can take a long time for tuberculosis to show up after exposure. If somebody is contracted with it today, you might not notice it for months. And in the early stages, you'd just notice that they had a cough, it's not until later on that the signs would be more clear.

      Modern screening catches it much earlier, but that requires either X-rays, blood work or a skin test, none of which were available during the 19th century.

    • (Score: 3, Interesting) by JoeMerchant on Sunday December 11 2016, @02:29AM

      by JoeMerchant (3937) on Sunday December 11 2016, @02:29AM (#439864)

      Think about the rats... they may not carry TB, but they do carry all kinds of things that can jump to humans - starting with fleas.

      --
      🌻🌻 [google.com]
  • (Score: 3, Interesting) by Reziac on Sunday December 11 2016, @03:41PM

    by Reziac (2489) on Sunday December 11 2016, @03:41PM (#439984) Homepage

    ...takes years to manifest. Six to seven years in dogs. Canned meat would have contained plenty. Severe deficiency in this corpse probably more indicates something wrong with the guy's metabolism.

    --
    And there is no Alkibiades to come back and save us from ourselves.