Nordic countries were early adopters of digital payments. Now, electronic banking is seen as a potential threat to national security:
In 2018 a former deputy governor of Sweden's central bank predicted that by 2025 the country would probably be cashless.
Seven years on, that prediction has turned out to be pretty much true. Just one in 10 purchases are made with cash, and card is the most common form of payment, followed by the Swedish mobile payment system Swish, launched by six banks in 2012 and now ubiquitous. Other mobile phone payment services are also growing quickly.
In fact, according to the central bank's annual payments report, published this month, Sweden and Norway have the lowest amount of cash in circulation, as a percentage of GDP, in the world.
But in the context of today, with war in Europe, unpredictability in the US and the fear of Russian hybrid attacks almost a part of daily life in Sweden, life without cash is not proving the utopia that perhaps it once promised to be.
Such is the perceived severity of the situation that the authorities are trying to encourage citizens to keep and use cash in the name of civil defence. In November, the defence ministry sent every home a brochure entitled If Crisis or War Comes, advising people to use cash regularly and keep a minimum of a week's supply in various denominations to "strengthen preparedness".
[...] Sweden is not the only Nordic country backpedalling on plans for a cashless society. Last year Norway, which has a popular equivalent to Swish called Vipps MobilePay, brought in legislation that means retailers can be fined or sanctioned if they will not accept cash. The government has also recommended that citizens "keep some cash on hand due to the vulnerabilities of digital payment solutions to cyber-attacks".
Norway's former justice and emergencies minister Emilie Mehl put it in clear terms: "If no one pays with cash and no one accepts cash, cash will no longer be a real emergency solution once the crisis is upon us."
Ultimately, when it comes to emergency planning, the world's two most cashless societies are still banking on cash.
(Score: 4, Funny) by EJ on Tuesday April 01 2025, @04:53PM (1 child)
I'm going to be ready when the nukes fall. I have a nice collection of all different brands of bottle caps.
(Score: 3, Insightful) by Mojibake Tengu on Tuesday April 01 2025, @05:32PM
You may desire increasing Fortune Finder perk to rank 4 too.
The kinder you are, the easier it is for wicked people to morally coerce you.
(Score: 2, Interesting) by Anonymous Coward on Tuesday April 01 2025, @05:19PM (9 children)
Last time I was in Switzerland, early 2000s, the restaurants we ate at would not accept credit/debit cards. The explanation from my host was that the restaurants didn't want to pay the card fees. Basically, I had to get Swiss Francs from an ATM, where I had to pay the fee(s).
In the intervening ~20 years, cards have made inroads, but according to https://fortune.com/europe/2025/03/25/cash-no-longer-switzerland-top-payment-method-snb-debit-card-dwindling/ [fortune.com]
I poked around for a table of countries and cash holdings but didn't find anything, maybe someone else has better google-fu?
(Score: 3, Interesting) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday April 01 2025, @05:28PM (8 children)
Last time I was in Switzerland, 1997 IIRC, they had just changed the currency and I had bought some at my US airport before departing and the Thomas Cook desk gave me the old bills. When I got there I met a friend and we went to a kiosk to buy some train tickets, but my friend only had "new money" in his wallet and the kiosk hadn't been changed over yet, so we used my "old money" to get the train tickets.
> the restaurants didn't want to pay the card fees
Around here (Florida) it is becoming common for restaurants to put separate cash / credit prices on the bill, generally with 2 or 3% higher price for credit.
> seeking to enshrine the existence of cash in the constitution
While the US demonstrates the difference between a copy of the constitution and toilet paper: none. There's a tRump joke in there somewhere.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 2) by krishnoid on Tuesday April 01 2025, @08:47PM (7 children)
But it's the constitution! They *have* to honor it [schlockmercenary.com]!
(Score: 2, Funny) by khallow on Tuesday April 01 2025, @11:32PM (6 children)
(Score: 3, Interesting) by JoeMerchant on Wednesday April 02 2025, @01:50AM (5 children)
That strip reminds me of the "separation agreement" I was handed by a company on greased skids to hell... already laid off all staff, no future remuneration likely or promised, they hand me an "agreement" "we are asking all former employees to sign" which basically was a list of things for the employees to promise not to do against the company such as sue the company, or say bad things about the company, but the absolute kicker was: "former employees agree to never reveal the existence of this agreement to anyone."
I walked out with it telling the CEO & VP "I will be consulting with my advisors about whether or not I should sign." It was tempting to light it on fire and drop it in a trash can by the door, but they weren't such horrible people that I felt like "burning bridges" that literally.
First, having given me nothing of value in return, it's not an agreement.
Second, if they are holding something saying I agree to never reveal the existence of the agreement - what the hell is that for?
All I could figure was that it was a test to sort our the pliable employees for possible re-hire if the investors decided that there were enough pliable employees to make it worth investing...
There was a slight temptation to "leak" the agreement to someone who might make fun of them in public, but that was un-necessary - they staggered the company back to life on a lot of volunteer labor for about a year before they were sued out of existence by a competitor for things they didn't do. Karma is a bitch, this is the management team that waited until the day before what was supposed to be a paid Christmas break to lay off everyone - including the kicker that what was going to be a paid mandatory vacation period as it was in all years prior will now be unpaid starting immediately.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 1) by khallow on Wednesday April 02 2025, @06:01PM (4 children)
Even a one-sided agreement like that is an agreement - because the signer would have agreed to it. Mind you, it might not hold up in court though if they get abusive enough or misrepresented the contract. But that's not a risky play, since anyone dumb or gullible enough to sign this isn't likely to file a competent lawsuit over the agreement.
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Wednesday April 02 2025, @08:29PM (2 children)
Sorry, agreeing to disagree is indeed an agreement, and I suppose "agreeing" to that thing with signature lines on it between the company and employees certainly is an "agreement" - but it's being presented as a contract - and on the face of it it is unenforceable:
https://www.upcounsel.com/without-consideration [upcounsel.com]
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 1) by khallow on Wednesday April 02 2025, @10:20PM (1 child)
The first thing to note here is that even if the contract is one-sided, it can be (but won't necessarily be) enforced.
My bet is that if this were contested in court, they would have tried a couple of tricks: first, claiming some sort of consideration was given - maybe there's money somewhere in there or maybe the contract stipulated that the employer would do certain things with some alleged benefit for the worker. They would also likely claim that they had explained the terms of the agreement fully rather than what they really did: dump it on someone in shock from getting laid off without a word about what schemes were in the contract.
(Score: 3, Informative) by JoeMerchant on Wednesday April 02 2025, @10:55PM
They explicitly stated verbally that there was no money, and none was mentioned in the agreetract.
They did verbally allege it was for "both parties' benefit" but I didn't see anything of value to me in writing. There was the unstated implied threat: no signature, no rehire in the future.
All in all, it was a good place to leave - they had work for me as long as the war in Afghanistan was going on, after that was over all their sales team could drum up were empty promises.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 2) by aafcac on Wednesday April 02 2025, @08:32PM
Legally, it's not an enforceable contract if both parties aren't getting something out of it. Although that something doesn't need to be large.
(Score: 3, Interesting) by Mojibake Tengu on Tuesday April 01 2025, @05:47PM (13 children)
For some couple of years, Russia has declared a gold standard fixation at 5000RUB/1gAu and by gold they mean real gold delivery for your Roubles, not just some Londonese paper saying "gold" written on it.
That scared everyone in the West. And is the core reason why no one unprivileged is allowed to transact with Russians.
The kinder you are, the easier it is for wicked people to morally coerce you.
(Score: 3, Informative) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday April 01 2025, @05:55PM (7 children)
Yes, but what happens when you have 5 Billion Roubles and you turn around and demand the 1000kg of gold?
At current exchange rate 5000 RUB = US$60, while "real gold" is running around $100 per gram. It would seem that world markets do not have free access to delivery of this Russian exchange promise.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 2) by Mojibake Tengu on Tuesday April 01 2025, @07:48PM (2 children)
A famous AI tells,
It seems your concept of world markets differs from real world markets of others.
The kinder you are, the easier it is for wicked people to morally coerce you.
(Score: 1, Informative) by Anonymous Coward on Tuesday April 01 2025, @08:03PM
From https://www.gold.org/goldhub/data/gold-reserves-by-country [gold.org]
Country Tonnes of Au
United States of America 8,133.46
Germany 3,351.53
Italy 2,451.84
France 2,437.00
>> Russia not in chart 2,335.85 data from parent post
China 2,279.56
Switzerland 1,039.94
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday April 01 2025, @10:17PM
It's not that Russia doesn't have a lot of gold, although it should be noted that 5 billion Roubles is only US ~$59 million.
So, you take your ~US$60M, convert it to ~5 billion Roubles, then demand 1 metric ton of gold from the Russian treasury, or whatever facility 'makes good' on this promise. Sure, it's only 1 of over 2000 metric tons in holding, somewhere (alleged), but... once you have that metric ton in hand, assuming you can leave the country with it for less than some 40% export tariff or similar, you should be able to sell 1 metric ton of gold on the world markets for around US$100 million at today's value.
Therein lies my assertion that "world markets" are not freely accessible from this internal Russian promise to redeem Roubles for gold at the stated rate of 1g per 5000 Roubles. If free trade were available, the Russian store of gold would quickly deplete from people making +67% ROI on their hard currency -> Roubles -> gold -> hard currency exchanges.
The rough value of Russia's gold stores is US$2.3T, while the "asking price" at current exchange rates is only ~US$1.4T.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 2) by turgid on Tuesday April 01 2025, @08:28PM (3 children)
Don't worry, Muskolini will grab an asteroid full of gold and the People's Christian Democratic Republic of America will be much richer. Putin will be jealous. Roscosmos will be after and even bigger asteroid. Soon planet Earth will have its own Deimos and Phobos.
I refuse to engage in a battle of wits with an unarmed opponent [wikipedia.org].
(Score: 3, Insightful) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday April 01 2025, @10:27PM (2 children)
Psyche is reputed to mass 2.28700 × 10^16 metric tons, if even 0.00001% of that can be recovered as gold on the surface of the Earth, that's 2 Billion metric tons of gold.
You'd think a South African would know what happens to value of diamonds when cheap diamonds flood the market in abundance, very similar can happen with gold.
Personally, I'd just like for copper to be available in ridiculous abundance, the price of good wire is getting ridiculous lately. With Psyche gold laying around we could probably formulate a mostly gold alloy that makes even better conductive wire than pure copper.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 1) by khallow on Tuesday April 01 2025, @11:36PM (1 child)
And stick it in buildings and cars. Steel core aluminum still better for power lines due to better mass, strength, and rigidity numbers.
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Wednesday April 02 2025, @12:27AM
It's basically down to the difference of insulated vs non-insulated applications. Certainly gold wouldn't be structurally desirable for long distance transmission wires, but it might make an excellent plated-skin for those wires, both as a low resistance shell with good high frequency conductivity, and as a shield from oxidation and other weathering.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 3, Insightful) by khallow on Tuesday April 01 2025, @07:29PM (4 children)
And Russian "special military operations" don't cause a million casualties. If Russia had a real gold standard rather than merely a "declared" gold standard, then they would run out of gold (or in the theoretical case where they're somehow making/obtaining enormous quantities of gold - inflate gold to become a much less valuable metal).
What's supposed to be scary about this? It's not a credible threat because gold is not that strategic a resource even if everything worked as advertised. You can't eat it. You can't bomb with it. Even as an economic resource, it would just stabilize Russian currency - it wouldn't do anything more than that for Russia's economy or its demographics problems.
(Score: 3, Informative) by c0lo on Tuesday April 01 2025, @09:28PM
Just imagine how many RAM stick connectors Russia can gold-plate with its reserve!!1!!
https://www.youtube.com/@ProfSteveKeen https://soylentnews.org/~MichaelDavidCrawford
(Score: 2) by EEMac on Wednesday April 02 2025, @12:21AM (1 child)
>> That scared everyone in the West. And is the core reason why no one unprivileged is allowed to transact with Russians.
> What's supposed to be scary about this?
It means Russia's currency is backed by something solid, and the US dollar is not.
(Score: 2, Insightful) by khallow on Wednesday April 02 2025, @05:40PM
And that something solid is merely a promise to pay in gold. It's no more solid than the US dollar is. Given the discrepancy between the promised amount and the actual valuation of the Ruble - which is lower [soylentnews.org], I think the market doesn't agree with you that it is backed by something more solid.
Think of it this way. Russia was run by kleptocracies for centuries - right to the present. How do we know this gold they supposedly have on hand actually exists? Who confirmed it with serious inventorying and testing of the whole stockpile?
This monetary policy is by the same people who turned a quick two week regime change in Ukraine into a bloody three year slog because they stole and sold off the supplies for winning a war.
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Wednesday April 02 2025, @12:33AM
The reputed Russian gold reserve is worth roughly US$1.4T on the open market today, their declared federal budget is on the order of US$310B, so in theory the gold could float those declared expenses for about four and a half years.
The thing that doesn't ring true for me is the declared rate of 5000 Roubles per gram. Current free market price is about US$100 per gram, and at Google reported exchange rates US$100 is around 8450 Roubles, so that 5000 Rouble per gram gold is a pretty steep discount as compared to the currency exchange rate.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 5, Informative) by istartedi on Tuesday April 01 2025, @09:02PM
The first time I observed the importance of cash for something like an "emergency" was on the 4th of July. DC's Metro system was relatively new. Fare cards and the machines that loaded them were unfamiliar first generation technology. They became a huge bottleneck, holding back the transit demand caused when 500k+ people want to get in and out of a city. The transit authority went to "throw cash in a bucket", with attendants. This system was in use on that day for a number of years. A combination of better technology and reports of corruption on the part of the bucket crews brought it to an end.
The next noteworthy time I witnessed cash's importance as a fail-over was during a "public safety power shut off" in California. Most gas stations didn't work. One did locally, probably using backup generators to run the pumps but their electronic payment systems were off line. Same deal, cash only. One poor sucker waited the whole line and found out the hard way. IIRC, somebody spotted him a $20. Makes you feel good--it didn't become Lord of the Flies. It usually doesn't. People are usually nice.
Anyway. Always have some cash on hand for emergencies, and use cash once in a while. Let merchants know that you carry it. It might not be as convenient; but you're doing your part to keep the backup system in order.
Appended to the end of comments you post. Max: 120 chars.
(Score: 5, Interesting) by looorg on Tuesday April 01 2025, @09:59PM
I should note that I don't use SWISH. I hate the system. I refuse to use it on general principle. Basically a few, regional/local, banking giants have now been given, or have taken, access to money and tied to it is also their own identification scheme called BankID. It's so stupid I can't even begin to describe it. But well people have had about a decade now to get used to it. So I guess they don't understand anymore how utterly horrible it is. Boiled frogs or something.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BankID [wikipedia.org]
It has become a sort of self-fulfilling-prophecy. They introduced the system. It got adopted. People kind of liked it. It was neat. You could just have your phone. No need for a wallets etc. Then they started to remove all the old systems. Like sending in bills via normal snail mail, it's still there but the amount of people using it is now quite minor. It used to be free. Now they charge you about $3 to pay bills that way. Then they jacked up the fee if you wanted to pay your bill over the counter in the banks, then they limited to certain days and hours. I don't even know how much it is anymore, I stopped that when they wanted like $15 to process a single bill at the counter of the bank. They drove the people onto the Internet to pay their bills and then they took it a step further and drove them onto their phones.
Now they want to turn back somehow? The banks have no interest in that. All those old things required people, bank offices, systems and machines. People. Things that cost money. Cutting into their profits. In their new system the customer takes all the investments, all the risk and does almost all the work. You enter all the billing information, you have to get the equipment. If there is an error it was probably your own fault. All the the risk if pushed to you, away from them. Good luck trying to get that cat back in the bag again.
Most of the big banks here shouldn't even be called banks anymore. They are just loan institutions and investment offices. They don't want to do cash transactions. There is no profit in that. Also customers are annoying so most of them closed or downsized their previous grand offices to very small offices. It's rare to have a large banking office with vaults or security boxes or counters etc anymore. They are now more like little store fronts where they peddle their house-loans and want you to invest in the stock market.
MSB: In case of Crisis.
https://www.msb.se/en/advice-for-individuals/the-brochure-in-case-of-crisis-or-war/ [www.msb.se]
Basically it's an updated version of a similar brochure (I linked to the english version, I didn't check but I assume it's largely the same as the one in Swedish) they handed out during the Cold War. Basic tips of what you should do if shit hits the fan. It's not that the tips are bad. They are perhaps just a bit unrealistic for large segments of the urban population living in their small flats in the cities. They don't have the room to store food and water and things like that. They don't know how to make fire to boil water etc. It's going to be a shit show in the cities for certain if that thing ever becomes a reality. People out in the boonies? They already know how to take care of themselves.
A lot of the things as noted in their suggestions goes against a lot of modern living such as the cash thing, as most people now pay with their phones and SWISH. When the power goes the system follows soon after and then when people can't charge their phones or the telecom equipment runs out of power it's all dead town. At least they practice this every month or so when the system crashes and is unreachable for a few hours until they manage to restart it. The system is basically a patchwork system that has been built upon now for over a decade that is in turn just something they slapped together on top of the old working system.
Other weird suggestions in the brochure as noted then is to now have a few hundred to a thousand dollars or so, in SEK, around for buying. It's just that a lot of the stores don't know how to deal with cash anymore. They don't accept it. They don't have the system for it. The cashiers are clueless and probably don't know what to do either. They logistics systems tied to the cash registers won't allow it. So it's funny/sad when the system goes down and everyone just stands around looking like the stone age arrived.
Add to this that they have also removed a lot of the ATM system. They removed a lot of the snail mail services to. So there is not really anywhere to get easy access to cash or to send letters to pay bills that way. Mail service here now is every other day, they want to cut that down to like one day per week -- every other week it's mail on mon/wed/fri and the next it's tues/thur. So things could take a lot of extra days to get delivered. Postage is like just shy of $2 for a letter. My local bank only does cash transactions one day per week in the morning. You basically have to twist their arm to do it at other times. There are basically no post offices around anymore either. Packages etc are usually handled by supermarkets or smaller convenient stores if they are not delivered to your door.
The suggestion is also to keep a few weeks or months of medicine. Except the system won't allow you to have that much drugs or hand out that much drugs. This isn't tied to Swish or BankID tho but it's a similar system for handing out medicine. So it's a lot of things in it that one wonders if they are written by people living in reality or things that just look good on paper. At least it's a paper brochure you got in the mail so you can light it on fire and keep warm for a few seconds.
The stores as noted loved BankID and Swish. Since they don't have to handle cash anymore, that costs money and take time. Skatteverket (IRS) loves it to since it becomes harder to do illegal cash transactions, ie all transactions they don't get their cut on. Also it cuts out on card fees to VISA or Mastercard. It works when it works, it sucks when it doesn't.
They also have not quite figured out how people will pay their bills when the war comes. Except the old old system is still around and works. People just forgot how to use it. How to pay bills without the Internet and/or a phone. So that will be fun. I guess you might have other priorities then. But bills still want to be paid.
By not being part of the system it sometimes suck. It makes some things harder. As some business and now even some services basically require that you have these systems on your phone or computer. I had to track down a friend. Give him cash. For him to pay a few things for me. It was annoying. But it helps me weed out the annoying stores and scammers. Basically I have become the crazy old coot that doesn't want to keep with the times. Not by doing anything. Just by not accepting their new identification and payment scheme. It's weird.
They are talking about legislation again where it would basically be illegal to refuse to handle cash. I wish the government would also just start a post/bank again for the public where you can do normal transactions without being tied into this shitshow. I would leave the other banks, close down my personal and business accounts in an instant and switch over.
Anyhow. I don't see how they are banking on cash. Most stores won't have anything in them. Just-in-time-logistics will break down. There will be nothing in the stores. Many stores can't even handle cash anymore. If the chaos comes I guess there will be rampant looting. It's when we'll see how many meals are between civilization and chaos. Is it three or so?
(Score: 2) by VLM on Tuesday April 01 2025, @10:27PM (2 children)
Paper money is important because the annoyance of handling it provides fake support for worthless middlemen.
If we went virtual all those middlemen skimming a couple percent here and there could be replaced by a tiny shell script charging approx 0%, and those people donate a lot of election funds, so ...
(Score: 1) by khallow on Tuesday April 01 2025, @11:37PM (1 child)
Who would still skim 2-3%. We call that "credit cards".
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Wednesday April 02 2025, @01:22AM
Credit cards started out with pretty legit processing costs, which are now approaching 0.01% but why would they give up that profit center? Looks like I paid less than $40 per share for Visa in 2013... that hasn't been a bad performer.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 1, Troll) by VLM on Tuesday April 01 2025, @10:29PM
... tend to be the poster children of "what not to do" so this may not be the kind of advertising they're looking for LOL.
(Score: 2, Disagree) by driverless on Wednesday April 02 2025, @02:19AM (2 children)
A cashless society works perfectly fine, we more or less have one here, I'd be surprised if I've used cash once in the last ten years. And it's really convenient, I don't have to fiddle with a pocket full of shrapnel every time I get a coffee or similar.
The problem in this case is that it's not bogeyman-proof. However, it is remarkably resilient, when Clownstrike hit here things were out for a couple of hours, sometimes up to a day, and then went back to business as usual. Requiring an entire nation to maintain a pre-medieval payment system on the off chance that a bogeyman strikes seems like a huge misallocation of resources, better to do a bit more work on failure modes and mitigation strategies.
(Score: 1, Touché) by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday April 02 2025, @02:58AM (1 child)
> maintain a pre-medieval payment system on the off chance that a bogeyman strikes
It wasn't that long ago that a severe ice storm here cut power to the whole area, and it was almost two weeks before everyone had their lights (computers, phone chargers, etc) back on. Cash worked pretty well for those that had it.
(Score: 3, Informative) by driverless on Wednesday April 02 2025, @03:14AM
We had a major natural disaster here about to years ago, no power, water, food, fuel, bridges out, etc. Everyone pitched in and helped everyone else out, some stuff was done with barter or IOUs, and by the time more important services like food and water were restored, so was the electronic payment system. AFAIK the presence or absence of cash made no difference. Thus my comment about infrastructure resilience being a more important focus than the use of coloured bits of paper.