Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 12 submissions in the queue.
posted by mrcoolbp on Friday August 21, @02:07PM   Printer-friendly
from the we're-leading-the-way dept.

Rob, the Administrator over at Linux.org has announced:

I set up an IRC server this week. irc.linux.org, port 6697, TLS.

Main channel is #linux.org.

NickServ and ChanServ are both running, so you can lock down your nickname and register your own channels:

/msg NickServ REGISTER
/msg ChanServ REGISTER #yourchannel

Once a channel is registered it stays yours, ops and all, even if you're the only one who ever shows up.

If you haven't touched IRC in fifteen years, nothing has changed,. apt install hexchat or apt install irssi, connect, join, type.

Channels are open for the taking. Distro channels, project channels, whatever you want to run. Grab them before somebody else does.


Original Submission

This discussion was created by mrcoolbp (68) for logged-in users only, but now has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
(1)
  • (Score: 2, Interesting) by PiMuNu on Friday August 21, @02:18PM (20 children)

    by PiMuNu (3823) on Friday August 21, @02:18PM (#1451941)

    What's the space like for IRC these days? Do people use it much? It seems a nice Instant Messenger with well known protocol etc, but the walled gardens like WhatsApp are more widespread... or am I just missing the point completely?

    • (Score: 5, Interesting) by canopic jug on Friday August 21, @02:29PM (12 children)

      by canopic jug (3949) Subscriber Badge on Friday August 21, @02:29PM (#1451946) Journal

      What's the space like for IRC these days?

      I gather IRC is much more decentralized these days, really ever since the implosion of FreeNode and what with Libera falling on its face. People and projects have realized the seriousness of what they have long known: that they can and should be running their own IRC servers. Netsplit now lists over 500 separate IRC networks [netsplit.de] at this time. Among others, it has stats for SoylentNews' IRC network [netsplit.de], if you are curious about that.

      It is trivial to stand up an IRC server or two to form your own network. Ergo is one option there. However, the real work comes once the IRC network is up and running and you need to spend time and effort organizing the community and curating the channels.

      --
      Money is not free speech. Elections should not be auctions.
      • (Score: 2, Disagree) by Bentonite on Saturday August 22, @04:11AM (11 children)

        by Bentonite (56146) on Saturday August 22, @04:11AM (#1451985)

        Libera hasn't fallen? It's the free replacement of hijacked freenode, that is operating the same.

        If I remember correctly, Netsplit listed more active irc networks previously.

        All of the work is setting up the ircd - once that's done, it doesn't take time and effort to add whatever channels you want and join them.

        • (Score: 2) by canopic jug on Saturday August 22, @06:21AM (10 children)

          by canopic jug (3949) Subscriber Badge on Saturday August 22, @06:21AM (#1451990) Journal

          [...] it doesn't take time and effort to add whatever channels you want and join them.

          Quite right. Adding channels and joining them is also trivial. Yet, however easy setting up an IRC daemon and adding and joining channels may be, there is a lot of work organizing the community that forms around the channels and in moderating the chatter. That applies especially if your IRC network is important enough to attract astroturfers from big tech and other griefers.

          --
          Money is not free speech. Elections should not be auctions.
          • (Score: 1, Troll) by Bentonite on Sunday August 23, @04:13AM (9 children)

            by Bentonite (56146) on Sunday August 23, @04:13AM (#1452063)

            I have never seen "astroturfers from big tech" or anything similar on irc.

            After all, how connecting to an irc network and then joining a channel requires the slightest bit of ability to use a computer, gatekeeps degenerates out without any work required..

            You do not have to waste time jannying, stopping fun from happening, when you instead can allow free speech - after all, irc has a feature called /ignore if someone is posting messages that you don't like.

            • (Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday August 23, @07:13AM

              by Anonymous Coward on Sunday August 23, @07:13AM (#1452068)

              waste time jannying, stopping fun from happening,

              If you don't follow the rules on IRC you can be kicked, and your username blocked permanently.

            • (Score: 3, Insightful) by canopic jug on Sunday August 23, @08:48AM (7 children)

              by canopic jug (3949) Subscriber Badge on Sunday August 23, @08:48AM (#1452071) Journal

              I have never seen "astroturfers from big tech" or anything similar on irc.

              Then some teams are doing excellent work curating the channels you frequent. As mentioned, processing the astroturfers and other griefers requires a lot of coordination by the community that forms around the channels moderation of the chatter. So if their efforts are invisible you, they are doing excellent jobs.

              --
              Money is not free speech. Elections should not be auctions.
              • (Score: 1, Spam) by Bentonite on Sunday August 23, @09:14AM (6 children)

                by Bentonite (56146) on Sunday August 23, @09:14AM (#1452074)

                Most of the channels that I'm in don't have jannies.

                I suspect what's happening is a lot of coordination to prevent fun from happening.

                • (Score: 2) by janrinok on Sunday August 23, @11:54AM (2 children)

                  by janrinok (52) Subscriber Badge on Sunday August 23, @11:54AM (#1452082) Journal

                  If by 'fun' you mean abusing other community members because you don't like their politics you might be part right. There is no need for coordination, there are only 2 people who seem to enjoy doing it.

                  • (Score: 2) by Bentonite on Monday August 24, @01:15AM (1 child)

                    by Bentonite (56146) on Monday August 24, @01:15AM (#1452140)

                    Why did it take me until now to realize that, merely disagreeing with some of the "politics" that other people are commenting about and wanting to explain how you agree and disagree with fun comments (that are fun because those contribute good points and useful information), is now considered abuse?

                    Of course, it's alright for those who don't like such fun (how dare you don't agree with absolutely everything) to intentionally insult and ban, but they aren't the abusers?

                    • (Score: 2) by janrinok on Monday August 24, @05:50AM

                      by janrinok (52) Subscriber Badge on Monday August 24, @05:50AM (#1452162) Journal

                      You can disagree with anyone's politics here. You should not attack the person because of them. Disagree with the policies, the actions of those who are in government, and criticise the results of them.

                      You can have fun in a discussion, there is plenty of banter going around and 'Funny' moderations exist in many places. We all enjoy a good laugh, and a well-crafted witty remark is appreciated. Who has ever been banned for having a joke?

                • (Score: 2, Informative) by day of the dalek on Sunday August 23, @09:57PM (2 children)

                  by day of the dalek (45994) Subscriber Badge on Sunday August 23, @09:57PM (#1452123) Journal

                  IRC without restrictions has never worked. Never.

                  The oldest IRC network is EFnet, which means Eris Free Network. That name is literally because eris.berkeley.edu was unrestricted and opened up the IRC network to all sorts of abuse where anyone could connect a server. So that server got booted and blacklisted, meaning that you can't just randomly connect your ircd to existing networks. EFnet grew into a large IRC network while eris.berkeley.edu became irrelevant because people didn't like the chaos of a completely unrestricted server.

                  Other networks like Dalnet and Undernet came along and were major competitors to EFnet and embraced services like ChanServ and NickServ, allowing users to register their channels and nicks. EFnet resisted that, staying unrestricted where nobody "owned" a channel or a nick. Except being completely unrestricted just didn't work.

                  This invited all sorts of abuse, where people would take over other people's channels, and that led to retaliation to try to get the channel back. Not having a ChanServ opens the door to that type of abuse. But it wasn't confined to individual channels and actually spilled over to the point of affecting EFnet's stability. When someone wanted to take a channel back, they'd hit EFnet servers with massive DDOS attacks to knock them online. If someone is was holding a channel and someone else wanted to take it back, they'd start packeting the servers to knock them offline, which would also mean that anyone who was connected to those servers also dropped offline. The attackers would try to cause a netsplit and then take over the channel when the servers reconnected. This became so severe that EFnet couldn't keep its servers online, and the universities and ISPs that hosted EFnet servers were taking their servers offline because running a server wasn't worth the trouble of DDOS attacks.

                  Even EFnet decided it wasn't worth the trouble to remain nearly unrestricted. Therefore, EFnet added CHANFIX to restore the ops in channels that had been taken over. Large IRC networks generally don't get involved in policing individual channels, but opers do step in to k:line malicious bots or to prevent channel disputes from affecting network stability.

                  Every successful channel I know of enforces rules, and people who commit abuse are likely to get kickbanned. Bots like Eggdrop were created to assist in enforcing channel rules. They can be scripted with TCL to add on lots of extra functionality. But their primary functions include things like giving ops to people who are supposed to have ops and otherwise maintain order. If troublemakers decide to start evading bans or persistently trolling a channel, ops might well set long-term or permanent bans on channel bots to automatically kickban them. Individual channels set their own rules, but I've never seen a successful channel of any significant size that didn't enforce rules to prevent abuse.

                  Anyone who remembers what EFnet was like ~25 years ago knows that the abuse can become a massive problem when there aren't rules or when people aren't enforcing the rules. EFnet was home to a lot of large hobbyist and tech channels. They absolutely enforced rules and developed a lot of tools to prevent abuse. They're not stopping people from having fun, but they are preventing trolls and script kiddies from ruining the experience for everyone else. So your idea of IRC being an unregulated free speech paradise has never been reality for networks and channels of any significant size. IRC networks like EFnet tried it, and it turns out that it wasn't fun at all.

                  --
                  Just say no to Alternative für Deutschland and all other Nazis
                  • (Score: 2) by Bentonite on Monday August 24, @01:44AM (1 child)

                    by Bentonite (56146) on Monday August 24, @01:44AM (#1452146)

                    Hijacking a channel to change the topic to spam and nick take overs and making channels unusable by flooding them with spam obviously isn't free speech.

                    But those issues have been automated away as you mentioned - there is no need for a human to sit there anymore, unless there's some unwritten rule that fun discussions that add contributions to the channel (free speech) is not allowed (in that case, you will see real abuse being dished out and ops being abused, to stop fun).

                    But now thinking about it, there is a current IRC network where anyone can connect a server; https://piss.network/ [piss.network] (there's even eris.berkeley.edu.pl connected) and therefore nick and channel topic takeovers are possible, but there doesn't seem to be any of such problems, as it appears almost all of the sort that cause such problems have either grown up, or lack the skill to work out how to connect an irc server (in the past, you needed to learn how to use a computer to connect online, which forced such sort to learn enough to cause problems, but now it seems such sort go and join discord instead).

                    • (Score: 2) by janrinok on Monday August 24, @05:55AM

                      by janrinok (52) Subscriber Badge on Monday August 24, @05:55AM (#1452163) Journal

                      Hijacking a channel to change the topic to spam and nick take overs and making channels unusable by flooding them with spam obviously isn't free speech.

                      I whole-heartedly agree! But that also applies to many means of public discussion.

    • (Score: 5, Interesting) by VLM on Friday August 21, @02:56PM (1 child)

      by VLM (445) on Friday August 21, @02:56PM (#1451947)

      or am I just missing the point completely?

      Its a single move in a decades old drama.

      IIRC the linux.org people used to hang out on #linuxdotcom (yeah, I know, dot org vs dot com...) on the linuxfoundation.org (network or standalone server?) and it died out a decade or two ago and they moved to freenode network which had some drama leading to liberachat.

      IIRC the freenode / libera chat thing was a dotcom guy successfully took over freenode, sort of a revolution from within, completely destroying freenode when everyone resigned and everyone left except him. Ever heard of Mt Gox bitcoin exchange? Yeah... that guy. Big time into centralized corporate VPN services. My theory is he was hoping for some marketing synergy, not what ended up happening.

      Anyway, yeah now at least one dude with access to DNS set up at least one IRC server at linux.org. Maybe 25 years too late. I honestly don't recall linux.org ever having their own IRC.

      I'd vaguely describe linux.org as like stackexchange but vastly less toxic and now its more active than stack exchange is which is pretty funny. It has a lot of stuff but its really about the web forums. I just checked and the 8 year old thread about writing QT applications in C++ without using the GUI QTCreator is STILL up. The general vibe of the webforum is someone makes an effortpost like "why I love the SED stream editor CLI tool" and the posters embrace and extend and are generally pretty nice. Its interesting to visit once in awhile but not active enough to visit every day or even every month. linux.org is also unorganized. Does this belong where it is in "Home Forums Linux.org News, Tutorials and Articles Linux Original Content Linux Articles" I would have looked for it in "Home Forums General Linux Forums Linux Networking" where it "belongs" but whatever. Or does it belong in the "server linux" section because it is, after all, an IRC server. Or does it belong in "linux news" because there historically have been decades of IRC drama? Or "site announcements" because its an official IRC server? I lurk at the forums but don't post there, its kind of an effort / reward ratio issue because its just a little disorganized and empty but not active enough to still be worth looking once in awhile.

      So that's some probably biased background on decades of drama leading up to standing up their own IRC server.

      • (Score: 2, Informative) by VLM on Friday August 21, @03:01PM

        by VLM (445) on Friday August 21, @03:01PM (#1451948)

        not active enough to still be worth looking once in awhile

        Obvious intention was cross out the not. I'd encourage visiting every month or quarter or so. It's got enough content to not forget about but not enough content to visit daily. It's alright. Not every site has to be super busy.

    • (Score: 4, Informative) by looorg on Friday August 21, @05:06PM (4 children)

      by looorg (578) on Friday August 21, @05:06PM (#1451951)

      I thought it was more of a statement to use IRC these days. We are old. We don't care about your new wizbang Discord server, which is just IRC with a shitty UI as far as I am concerned. It removes a lot of the less desirable people/users as the level to entry is a tiny bit higher then Discord.

      • (Score: 2) by crm114 on Friday August 21, @07:51PM (3 children)

        by crm114 (8238) Subscriber Badge on Friday August 21, @07:51PM (#1451963)

        Yeah.

        IRC + a sever that logs; no repudiation.

        Old school. See Robert Mueller for a reference.

        • (Score: 5, Insightful) by dwilson on Friday August 21, @11:12PM (2 children)

          by dwilson (2599) on Friday August 21, @11:12PM (#1451976) Journal

          I've often though that Discord brings absolutely nothing to the table that couldn't have been done years earlier with a mumble (or teamspeak, ventrilo, whatever) client bolted on to an IRC client and some clever glue to make it all work, UI-wise. And associated glue server-side regarding shared accounts, etc.

          There are FOSS Discord-equivalent alternatives out there, but they are so over-engineered as to be almost unusable. I looked in to one once, last year, (Revolt / Stoat) and I couldn't even fathom the ridiculous software stack needed to build the various bits and bobs, nevermind actually deploy the finished binaries anywhere.

          The modern world, software-wise, is madness. I don't like it. I should go find a cloud to yell at.

          --
          - D
          • (Score: 2) by gnuman on Saturday August 22, @10:53AM (1 child)

            by gnuman (5013) on Saturday August 22, @10:53AM (#1451998)

            Discord brings absolutely nothing to the table

            It does. It's a web application. It's more convenient to use.

            • (Score: 3, Touché) by canopic jug on Saturday August 22, @06:26PM

              by canopic jug (3949) Subscriber Badge on Saturday August 22, @06:26PM (#1452036) Journal

              There are, or at least were, web clients for IRC, too.

              --
              Money is not free speech. Elections should not be auctions.
(1)