https://www.zdnet.com/article/top-6-ai-free-linux-distros/
AI is everywhere, and the technology's tendrils continue finding their way into more and more places. Will we soon see AI in shopping carts, waffle makers, heated blankets -- rocks?
OK, maybe AI in rocks is a stretch, but you get the point.
Microsoft and Apple are embedding their respective AIs into the heart of their operating systems, and some Linux distributions, such as Omarchy, have followed suit.
Fortunately, not every Linux distribution has plans to add AI into the mix. In fact, several distros have either explicitly taken a stance against AI -- or have a general ethos that ensures AI will not become part of the OS.
One thing to know: Just because an OS refuses to ship (or use) AI, it doesn't mean that users can't install it for themselves. That's up to the end user. Also, not every one of these distro developers has made public statements about not including AI, but their foundations and ethos stand against such things. To that end, I've had to draw conclusions based on my long-term experience and understanding of how these distributions work and evolve.
Here are the best of those distros.
Debian has made it clear that AI will never be included in the OS. For Debian, part of the issue is the openness of LLMs. The developers made that perfectly clear when they stated, "AI models released under DFSG-compatible license without original training data or program are not seen as DFSG-compliant." DFSG stands for Debian Free Software Guidelines, and the developers and community take the standard seriously. Because of this, I cannot see any point at which Debian will include AI with the operating system.
Keep in mind that Debian is the "mother of distributions," because so many distributions (including Ubuntu) use it as a base. This means that all of those distributions beneath it will not have to deal with preinstalled AI.
Although the Void developers haven't taken an official public stance on AI in the OS, it's safe to assume we'll never see it ship with AI. One reason for this is the very nature of Void Linux as a "DIY" Linux distribution.
Void Linux starts with just the basics and leaves the rest up to the user. That ethos alone should ensure that AI is never a part of the base. On top of all that, Void is considered a minimalist distro, which means it aims to be as small as possible. (AI would increase the ISO size.)
I'm fairly confident that Void Linux will never include AI out of the box.
MXLinux is based on AntiX, a distribution designed for older, slower hardware. That alone ensures that MXLinux will not include AI (especially locally installed AI). In all MXLinux blog posts and news announcements, there has never been any mention of preinstalled artificial intelligence.
A comment on the MXLinux About Us page, "For some it's a hobby, for some it's paying it forward to the free software community that has given us so much, for some it's a labor of love," makes it clear how the developers honor FSF.
It's a safe bet that MXLinux will not ever include AI.
The closest thing you'll find regarding AI and Arch Linux is ArchLinux AI in the Arch User Repository (AUR). Beyond that, there's been no mention of Arch ever including AI in the OS. Also, Arch Linux takes security very seriously, and the inclusion of AI could compromise that (especially given how LLMs have lately shown the ability to escape guardrails with ease). Consider how Arch has decided to suspend the AUR out of concern for the distro's (and users') safety.
Although Arch is a rolling distribution, it's always seemed to be a Linux take that evolves very slowly. The idea that Arch would jump onto the pre-installed AI bandwagon is counter to what the distribution has stood for all of these years.
No, I cannot imagine that Arch will ever ship with AI pre-installed. Want to install it yourself? Go right ahead.
No. No way. Nope.
Slackware has always been dedicated to being the "most UNIX-like Linux distro available." Given that, there's no chance it will ever ship with preinstalled AI.
The AerynOS developers have issued a statement on using AI for both development and design, stating, "AerynOS takes a default position that we do not accept the use of LLMs in/around AerynOS." That stance is based on ethical concerns about data gathering, disproportionate use of electricity and water, potential negative influence, and potential copyright violations.
Yeah, AerynOS will never include AI in the OS.
Not every Linux distribution has come out with a strong public stance against AI. However, based on my decades of following the Linux and open-source world, I find it safe to assume the distributions above will not be shipping with the Linux equivalent of Copilot or Apple Intelligence any time soon.
(Score: 2, Informative) by Runaway1956 on Saturday August 22, @12:44AM
Google, Apple, Microsoft, Beta - all data mining corporations. Their AIs have a purpose: to learn more about you, and to manipulate you into revealing more about yourself. No Linux distro should ever include any of those AIs by default. Other AIs? The end user can do whatever the hell he wants with his machine. If you WANT to be tracked and mined, and manipulated, go ahead, install your favorite poison. Or, you can choose some other AI whose prime mission is NOT data mining. But, again, install it yourself. Pick your poison, and run with it.
Any OS that installs one of the corporate data mining AIs by default is an OS to abandon. They have sold out.
Alternative für Deutschland
(Score: 3, Touché) by oldeschool on Saturday August 22, @01:27AM
that's the beauty of Linux, remove what you don't want.
I unsnap any Ubuntu install yet snap is core Ubuntu.
(Score: 4, Interesting) by Bentonite on Saturday August 22, @04:04AM (2 children)
After a certain version starting from around a year ago, contains a serious amount of LLM slop.
If you want to be free from proprietary LLM slop and also have a good OS, the only feasible course of action would be to remove the limited amount of LLM slop from Hurd and a handful of other GNU packages, that have taken the unforgivable action (only forgivable if they take it back out and commit to never do it again), of soiling the freedom with a limited amount of proprietary LLM slop and prepare a fully free GNU/Hurd distro.
As for a default installation of SaaSS LLM disservices, most GNU/Linux distributions are extremely unlikely to do so, unless the goal is to stop people from using the distro.
(Score: 4, Insightful) by bart9h on Saturday August 22, @03:05PM (1 child)
Or ditching GNU and using another system, like *BSD.
(Score: 2) by Bentonite on Saturday August 22, @10:14PM
Every single BSD is proprietary software and furthermore most BSD's appear to accept, or even encourage proprietary LLM slop.
If you want to have freedom, using another OS is a mistake, as every other nontrivial OS contains substantial amounts of proprietary software.
(Score: 2, Insightful) by Anonymous Coward on Saturday August 22, @09:05AM (2 children)
It all depends on what upstream does.
By the time we are at the level of hobbyist Linux distributions, the code has already gone through probably two dozen corporate entities, most of which are going to, at a *minimum*, use AI to search for and patch security exploits. IBM is an AI company now, Google is an AI company now, hobbyists aren't going to out-produce these behemoths moving Linux in their own direction.
So a downstream hobbyist distribution having an anti-AI policy is kind of like the communist who uses an iPhone or the libertarian on welfare/medicaid. Unless you split to the linux-libre fork, you are already using LLM code. It's just virtue signaling out of emotion but no real impact.
Debian understands this, which is why they aren't going to vote to ban AI. They already have a hard time maintaining their distribution, have run off their primary KDE contributors, and are just trying to keep their heads above water. Banning AI would be equivalent to throwing away the piece of driftwood they are holding on to.
Other operating systems with self-determination may be more successful at defending but even OpenBSD has applied security patches based on the findings of LLM's. NetBSD has a strict no AI policy but NetBSD also kernel panicks on every hardware I've tried it on since the 90's. It's not a serious OS. FreeBSD will gladly take LLM output, it takes code from everywhere like kleptomaniacs.
Curious to see how Haiku plays out.
(Score: 3, Informative) by Bentonite on Saturday August 22, @10:17PM (1 child)
Copying code does not steal it.
"Free"BSD seems to care more about software remaining proprietary, than using code from everywhere, as I see claims that the base install no longer contains free software under a license from the GPL family.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday August 23, @11:29AM
>I see claims that the base install no longer contains free software under a license from the GPL family.
You would be correct. They announced this recently like it is something to be celebrated. No thanks or acknowledgement towards the GPL that allowed the project to exist in the first place.
The BSD license is a one way function. It allows free labor for trillion dollar companies headed by billionaires to make more money while the BSD developers spam Mastodon asking for donations to pay rent or free parts to fix their broken ten year old ThinkPad. But it's justified, "Well at least it isn't Linux!" and "Playstation uses us!" like that's going to save them or their code.
Sad, really.
(Score: 2) by VLM on Saturday August 22, @02:41PM (2 children)
Uh, no they don't?
There's at least three interesting stories, maybe four, where the lede is buried.
The first is that cultural drift or whatever happens where "real computer people" have a different idea of what an operating system is than a noob non computer person. To a noob non-computer person, an OS is something that magically appears on a computer like added in the factory or something, and everything on the computer before you install your own apps and virii is an "operating system". So a file searching application that has a text mode LLM UI is "AI in the operating system" because it was on the computer when they bought it. Just like bloatware is part of the operating system. "Why does microsoft put all this junk on new computers?" etc. Real computer people see an OS as something from an operating systems class. The sheer idea that when I do a system call to malloc or fopen or try to initialize the eth0 driver, the OS is not going to run normal code it's going to call out to a LLM and ask it how to do it every time using MCP is beyond ridiculous. So, uh, no, when I run, I donno, a wiki like dokuwiki in Docker which is on Alpine Linux in the docker container and the docker host is running, I donno, Ubuntu 24 maybe, then no obviously there is no AI involved at any level from the bare metal running proxmox up to dokuwiki serving up wiki pages at work, you don't need a claude subscription or gemini subscription to run "docker compose up -d" or even kubectl to control a K8S cluster LOL. I'm sure the companies selling subscriptions would like that to be a requirement LOL.
The second interesting story is almost intentional propaganda / interference with refusing to discuss the difference between "uses AI" like does a REST API call or MCP protocol connection to do things vs "made with AI" like some dude may have done as little as ask a LLM to do a web search for him (now that the web is dead and full of AI generated slop so web searches are useless) all the way up to people using AI to attempt to program and just hope the AI gets it correct because they surely don't understand what its doing "vibe coding". This part is just weird to see play out there's intentional mind games to avoid being up front about "actively uses as part of the GUI or backend" vs "source code partially written with at least some help of AI".
The third interesting story is the "big lie" of AI in operating systems as per the above. Again, as per topic 1 above, the OS itself is not using AI lol, if you run a malloc the OS doesn't ask Gemini "here is the state of the CPU registers and a dump of all physical RAM please alter both to allocate a couple megs to the program that just called malloc" and chunk the response into memory and hope AI got it correct. So by "AI in the OS" I would assume they mean in the base install like "apt install some-local-model" for applications to use. Which is kind of like saying Gnome is part of the Linux OS. Despite most linux kernels in the world not running Gnome LOL so its obviously not. I'm not aware of any operating system integration beyond "preinstalling installing a library for later app use" in windows or apple OSX. I would not count "if you run a file picker application there's a window that will open a web browser session with a LLM". Yes, I know there's tons of apps that use AI and AI libraries. But not the OS afaik. I could see it being added... on a current W11 box if I open "Settings" there's a "Find a setting" button that isn't even local, if the network is down it'll fail, but it'll try and search local settings if you can't remember where to set daylight savings time or something; my point being that there is no local search, they could remove the internet-attached search and replace it with a textbox connecting to a LLM where you could ask a LLM on the internet the single word "ethernet" if you're trying to diagnose why you're not connected to the network... well there's some chicken and egg problems with that scenario which is why I'd prefer Windows Settings Application would do local search (grep, more or less) rather than either the existing web search or changing to LLM.
I think the author of the original article is human; looks like a journalism grad so I wouldn't expect any technical accuracy its sci fi infotainment fluff from people like that. Its a sad thing that the world doesn't expect technical accuracy in technical articles. The bio claims he's a successful author. Amazon shows he sells romance-horror vampire lit to horny tru-crime hipster women, titles like "Violent Delights Deadly Romance". There's nothing wrong with that, I just think it's hilarious that "tech news" doesn't come from techs; it's provided by people who write stuff like, and I quote from the book's marketing blurb: "Apart, they've murdered countless victims. They have something in common, an insatiable lust followed by a good slaughter. Once they fall in love, their murderous rampage threatens to bring the city of Boston to its knees." Yeah, that sounds like the kind of authority I'd trust to write my Dockerfiles and Ansible scripts uh huh. I mean in a way, people like that probably understand the BOFH memes from decades ago better than most normies.
But, its still pretty lame. We are being "infotained" by the type of people who think a "BSD system daemon" is... a literal demon like one in a chick lit vampire erotica novel. In a way I think chick focused monster erotica can relate to IT type work. There are entire genres of IT tasks that are best taught by blowing something up. That time I learned about dual stack networking, that time I learned about MTU mismatches, that time I wiped the wrong deployment (test vs dev vs prod), that time I admined down the ethernet port my management connection was attached to (after I saw my boss do that to himself in the 90s, so i had no real excuse). All those IT experiences do temporarily result in the feels of a sex crazed werewolf violating my tender nether regions, so an author specializing in that genre is not entirely out of place in tech, just mostly out of place. Any time I deal with active directory has a bit of that feel, for example.
(Score: 2) by VLM on Saturday August 22, @03:03PM
Aaand I don't remember the "official" genre name until after I clicked "submit"
The official title for the genre at my local Barnes and Noble is/was "Supernatural Erotica" and it was in the bookcase next to "True Crime" in the Chick Lit area of the store. There's a lot of crossover, apparently.
In like the 90s when this genre was just starting out I dated a goth wannabe chick who was into Anne Rice's vampires. She was fun, but it's probably good we're not together. So I'm casually familiar with the "Supernatural Erotica" genre.
The genre is like "let me write a book about unconventional eternal single never grow up urbanite hipsters who give each other blood-borne diseases via erotic borderline illegal activities late at night in sleazy locations" but its totally not about alphabet people spreading HIV, because like no we're not going to describe that, naw its ... uh ... sexy vampires getting it on. And the werewolves in "supernatural erotica" are renamed furries. Apparently even in "Supernatural Erotica" its a common plot device that everyone hates the furries especially the alphabet/vampire people, I really have no comment to make other than its hard not to laugh sometimes when you read those books after you know the translation key above.
And a guy who writes in that genre, according to my brief scan of Amazon, is officially anointed by the authorities as a journalist whom is knowledgeable about embedding AI in operating systems. Uhhhhh... I donno why no one trusts legacy media anymore, must be "bad luck" or they have the wrong political views or something LOL.
So uh yeah "The Debian Policy Manual" vs "Supernatural Erotica" try to pay attention so you can tell them apart especially WRT AI inclusion. Just a few minor differences LOL.
(Score: 2, Disagree) by Bentonite on Sunday August 23, @04:05AM
Cool it with the oxymorons.
Gnome used to be part of the GNU OS, but the sad sacks didn't like being part of freedom.
(Score: 3, Interesting) by corey on Sunday August 23, @12:08AM
I actually happened to watch the following video literally last night, about Omarchy. I wasn’t looking for anything about Linux but I’d watched a previous video by the dude who made that Omarchy video, which was about pfSense vs OPNsense so I guess YouTube thought I’d like to watch more of his videos.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9SDkU5VDQEQ&pp=ygUPT21hcmNoeSBuZXR3b3Jr0gcJCRMMAYcqIYzv [youtube.com]
Anyway the Omarchy distribution looks really good, with its minimalistic install and speed. And the retro themery (lots of ASCII art). I’ve been trying to get Sway WM going on my Gentoo box for a while but with the wayland stuff, I’ve not been able to get it going with a login manager.
But then in the video he talks about how it’s “AI first” or something. And it has built in AI stuff to connect to the big providers. I’m a laggard with AI tools (I’m not old either), so I’m very sceptical of this distribution. But maybe it’s kind of the future I need to stop resisting. I’ve disliked AI this whole time, but mostly because it’s being shoved down everyone’s throats, plus the rich idiotic tech bros behind it all.
The Ruby on Rails dev guy, he seems a bit of an entrepreneur or business guy with a bunch of companies under his belt. Plus the Omarchy foundation got $8m in funding, so he must be a good sales guy. So that makes me sceptical too.
But with the AI integration, I got a little spark in my head while watching the video. He creates a theme using AI. I was thinking, given that the AI can do that type of thing, and read the files on the drive, and, that everything is open source, you could technically get it to write some custom program or application for you. Or change an existing one to have some extra features or theme or something, automatically. It’s like some new way of computing with morphable software. I can see the draw in that. That’s not something any closed source OS could do, which adds to the “year of the Linux desktop” argument. It could be a big thing. Maybe that’s why they got that money.
I’m keen to try out Omarchy anyway.