Google's basic mathematical skills appear a little fragile, after the company revealed its promise of ten years of support for new Chromebooks will only last for eight years.
The web giant's calculation problem appeared in a support document titled "What the Googlebook announcement means for your ChromeOS devices."
Googlebooks are the big G's replacement for Chromebooks, the web-centric computers it launched in 2011 and which run ChromeOS. Chromebooks have won plenty of admirers in the education sector, especially schools which see them as a fine way to get decent and well-priced computers into kids' hands without having to take on the burden of managing a full OS.
The newer Googlebook range uses more powerful processors than their predecessors, plus a new OS called Googlebook OS that bakes in Google's Gemini AI – a product the Chocolate Factory is very keen to see succeed as the great AI land grab continues.
Google has so far launched Googlebooks only for consumers. None of the web giant's five current Googlebook hardware partners designed their first models for the education market or other fleet buyers.
Those five, and many other OEMs, continue to crank out Chromebooks.
Google's support policy for Chromebooks includes ten years of updates. However the support document states that if you buy a Chromebook today, updates will end in 2034 – eight years into the future, not a decade.
"For qualifying devices purchased today whose 10-year support lifecycle extends beyond 2034, Google is committed to supporting your transition to Googlebook OS, with many devices offering direct migration paths," the support page explains.
But those migration paths don't exist yet.
"Many newer commercial Chromebook models will be capable of upgrading to Googlebook OS. Details on migration paths and device eligibility will be shared at a later date," the document explains.
Whenever the migration paths arrive, they will come with a requirement to acquire a new license for Googlebook OS management tools – existing ChromeOS licenses won't make the trip.
While Google has unilaterally changed a policy, it's hard to imagine many Chromebooks currently in service or acquired in the next year or two will still be in service come 2034. So the shorter support period is largely moot. But Google's intention to make continued use of Chromebooks unattractive is clear.
(Score: 5, Insightful) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday October 06, @03:01PM (2 children)
Intel has been doing this a lot lately, too. Chips that were supposed to have 15 years of supply availability are going last-time-buy around year 12. The sales reps have well practiced lines about "challenging supply chain and global demand issues" which pretty much translate to "yeah, we're breaking our word - what are you gonna do about it?" Same thing about price inflation... yes, we usually lower our prices on older product lines as newer ones come out, but... not anymore, actually we're raising them now.
Blame whatever you want to blame for all this - I'm sure it's Jimmy Carter's fault, somehow - this is the world we have been moving toward for almost 47 years now, boiling the frogs slowly until they don't jump out even in fatal temperatures. I'd say current water temp is a balmy 43C (109.4F) - if we don't reverse the trend soon, it's gonna hurt... more.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 2) by driverless on Wednesday October 07, @04:44AM (1 child)
Does it matter for Intel? Is anyone still buying ten-year-old CPUs off them?
Where it really does matter is embedded, and most of the vendors there tend to take their product longevity guarantees pretty seriously. Even when they do finally discontinue them other vendors will keep them going, I'm thinking 8051 and derivatives, or older STM32s.
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Wednesday October 07, @11:36AM
> Is anyone still buying ten-year-old CPUs off them?
Not after they quit selling them.
There's a LOT of industry that would prefer for CPUs and other components to remain available for 20+ years, if they could get them. They'd even pay significant premiums to not have to re-design and re-certify the re-designs.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 3, Insightful) by OrugTor on Tuesday October 06, @04:19PM (10 children)
So there won't be many functioning Chromebooks in 8 years' time? Are these devices so bad that models bought in "the next year or two" will die within six years? Let's imagine that plenty of Chromebooks will survive end of support. What will Google do about it? Brick the lot of them? Maybe. "Do evil".
(Score: 2) by epitaxial on Tuesday October 06, @04:46PM
Technically you can install linux on them but it's hot garbage and half the hardware barely works. Some models you physically have to pry open the case to flip a jumper in order to flash a real bootloader. Their internal storage is tiny so there's no reason to keep ChromeOS or whatever they call it now around.
(Score: 5, Informative) by VLM on Tuesday October 06, @04:48PM (8 children)
I have a lot of experience using chromebooks as thats been my main "daily driver" laptop since early 2016 so I can answer your questions.
WRT software they'll all function but are un-upgradable. I used my old Acer for like "half a decade" after support ended because 99% of the time I'm connected via LAN or VPN to my compute cluster. Why would I install a virus on the server I maintain just to pown ancient chromebooks LOL?
WRT hardware yeah they'll all be dead. Keyboards are OK but not amazing and lithium batteries aren't designed to run forever.
They just stop updating. You can open the case, remove a shorting screw (or several other options) upload a new BIOS and treat it literally like a laptop. I used https://docs.mrchromebox.tech/ [mrchromebox.tech] Given that I owned an Acer CB3-431-C0AK you could follow along with me. It ain't rocket science but it is somewhat harder than installing linux on a generic desktop.
"It worked for me" but the keyboard was getting "meh" after 8 years, 9 years, and the battery started swelling, luckily I had a spare but that was degrading in capacity probably because it hadn't been used in years, so it was "F it" and trashed it.
According to Amazon orders page, in early 2016 I bought an Acer chromebook with 1080HD screen and 4 GB ram and a 32G flash and I used it daily driver until I bought a Lenovo 1080HC screen 4 GB ram but 64 G flash about "meh two years ago". Then I installed linux on the old Acer which worked well until the hardware died and I never used it, ever. The new Lenovo chromebook is in a laptop bag next to me leaning up against my office desk right now. Works REALLY well.
Shocking that my daily driver laptop has had the same specs since 2016 which is one decade.
The decade old Acer had a, I believe four core, Intel (de)celeron N3160 and the Lenovo has a WTF SoC "MediaTek Kompanio 520" which boils down to 2 real cores and 6 shit cores ARM64. So yeah I have my first ARM laptop. Works really well. The core thing is bizarre its got 2 real cores and 6 shit cores. Still the CPU draws all of 4 watts less than a raspberry pi so I'm happy. Of course a Raspi has 8 GB ram and my chromebook has only 4 GB.
Speaking of Pi there's no law you can only put one processor in a laptop bag LOL I used to carry around a Pi-Zero 2W, whatever the model number it was the small one with wifi, and the wifi could be coerced into being an access point and it had MORE than enough horsepower to program arduinos and the like over its USB. Tiny little thing. It is funny that I can plug a brand new Raspi into my chromebook's USB-c port and yes it costs about half as much as my chromebook but its got twice the RAM lol.
You know, you can install Docker on a Raspberry pi, run the pi off the laptop power supply, and linuxserver.io offer tons of development images (or used to anyway) for ARM64 docker. A pi is a surprisingly good dev platform. Its been possible to install Docker on a Pi for IIRC over a decade now but "the internet" is in noob mode and constantly "discovers the new feature" that you can install docker on a pi, pretty much continuously for a decade now. I assure you its old old old tech and works pretty well after the first decade, so don't believe any nonsense you'll hear about running docker on pi being "new" lol its not. And it makes a perfect "coprocessor" for a chromebook.
(Score: 3, Interesting) by VLM on Tuesday October 06, @05:04PM (1 child)
Sometimes you use something for so long you forget about it.
The biggest problem with using a chromebook to connect to KASM/Selkies/rdesktop/apache guacamole is chromebooks don't have function keys although theres usually numerous workarounds.
So if you're running Wordstar with macros in the function keys on dosemu because you're retrocomputing you'll have fun finding ways to send function keystrokes using virtual on screen keyboards or who knows what. Or if you're playing an emulated game and it wants you to hit a F key well its going to get interesting.
Its not been a showstopper although its added to the quaint charm.
Another point I failed to add is the decade old Acer did well with OnShape CAD and FreeCAD over selkies and I have not tried the ARM lenovo with Onshape but it works well enough with FreeCAD. Oh and kicad is not a challenge at all compared to freecad so it runs flawlessly IIRC. I don't do CAD all day long so there may be issues "only" having a 1080 display etc.
I find the touchpad almost unusable because a lot of "real" software assumes a right mouse button (and center) exist and the touchpad is hopeless at emulating extra buttons. So my laptop bag has a $3 optical USB mouse, no big deal.
Now I think I mentioned everything I know about using a chromebook for software development. In summary, its pretty good.
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday October 06, @05:47PM
>don't have function keys although theres usually numerous workarounds.
I was worried about this when I bought my 60% keyboard, in practice I have remapped ` onto fn1-esc, ~ onto fn2-esc, and fn2 converts the numbers and neighbors to f1-f12 - and it hasn't been an issue for many years now. I also prefer having end instead of ins under my del key... Occasionally I'll hit some special case, but it has never ever been an "oh my God, I need to get that full keyboard out and connect it" crisis. I still forget that my function knob does volume control.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 4, Insightful) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday October 06, @05:33PM (2 children)
>WRT software they'll all function but are un-upgradable.
So, no new security patches?
Apple effectively bricked the iPad 1 by making the iOS upgrade mandatory to receive new app updates, most apps were somehow cloud connected and refused to operate without being updated to the latest, and the new OS ground the performance of the iPad 1 processor down from "pretty snappy" to "dismal, at best."
> "F it" and trashed it.
The ultimate design goal of all consumer products producers. As fast as you can get away with it.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 2) by VLM on Tuesday October 06, @08:25PM (1 child)
Not locked down TPM'd to heck and back official chrome patches, no. You get your last chrome update and then a nag notification about no longer supported.
The specs for my "new" chromebook are almost identical to my old so its merely a matter of motivation not a technical limitation.
You CAN convert it from a locked down zero maintenance chromebook to a unlocked low powered UEFI laptop which runs linux terribly well, very easily, and "apt-get update" works etc.
The problem I ran into is my entire workflow along with several clients is essentially 100% browser based so use my new chromebook for everything, and the old one with linux on it doesn't boot as fast and I have to manually update it so it just doesn't seem worth it so I didn't use it and physically it was wearing out after a decade of use, so when enough of it broke I tossed it.
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday October 06, @08:36PM
> physically it was wearing out after a decade of use, so when enough of it broke I tossed it.
Yeah, back in the "netbook" days (20-ish years ago), I preferred the nettop devices where I could swap out monitor and keyboard as desired instead of trashing the whole widget when one part of it got tired, or just too small and annoying. My wife was running a ~8 year old PC when I gave her a nettop and she was thrilled with the performance upgrade. I believe those eventually died with power supply issues, which is a shame because they were such relatively power-efficient little things to start with.
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday October 06, @05:42PM (2 children)
>Why would I install a virus on the server I maintain just to pown ancient chromebooks LOL?
You wouldn't, but there's a smorgasboard of architectures on this exploit's capabilities list: https://www.securityweek.com/linux-backdoor-abuses-stun-protocol-exploits-dozens-of-flaws/ [securityweek.com]
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
(Score: 2) by VLM on Tuesday October 06, @09:13PM (1 child)
Yeah I think thats the "some people don't get it" part where I'm using it to connect over a VPN to Apache Guacamole to a windows VM running rdesktop and SSH to an ubuntu VM for CLI, but I'll get security lectured about the chromebook along the lines of surely I'm clicking on internet sites without an ad blocker. And no matter how much I say I don't, people insist I do, but I don't. I also connect to my proxmox clusters web ui and Rancher for RKE Kubernetes because whatever I just like watching the event log scroll on Rancher, even though you can do anything Rancher does, probably easier and faster, with kubectl.
Amusingly, one of the development docker images I use has chrome so I can use old chrome on my old chromebook to connect over a VPN to a K8S cluster to run a new chrome in a docker container and it renders back to me and is reasonably snappy although I'd not want to watch videos on it. So if you're in VSCode in the docker client and click a website it opens the website in it's chrome.
(Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday October 06, @10:24PM
I got 'pwned by Stoned virus about a year after it spread widely around me, all it takes is putting a floppy in an infected PC to infect the floppy, then put that floppy in your PC and boot from it - now you've got Stoned on your hard drive too. It was relatively easy to clean and then that never happened again.
People got all religious about virus scanners, I never saw the point, haven't run one on our personal systems, ever. I did also get 'pwned by happy99.exe as an e-mail attachment from a friend who I thought was sending me pictures of their 1999 car... that one took a tiny bit more effort to clean than stoned, but it was much easier to research how to clean it due to internet being available.
Over the decades, I have watched people put 100x as much effort into virus scanners and similar "security software" as I have put into cleaning up the messes of myself, my wife and our two sons now in their 20s...
🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]