As many doctors are moving ahead with the latest advances of modern medicine—from powerful obesity drugs to breakthrough cancer treatments—pediatricians are being forced to turn back, fighting to maintain advances in children's health that were hard-won decades ago.
With anti-vaccine advocate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as health secretary, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) has spent a considerable amount of time and resources in the past year fiercely defending lifesaving vaccinations—safe, routine shots that have saved the lives of millions of children over decades and thwarted untold suffering and disability.
But just this week, The New York Times reported that Ken Paxton, the attorney general of Texas, has opened aggressive investigations against pediatricians simply because they vaccinated their patients. Paxton falsely claims vaccines are part of a "multi-level, multi-industry scheme." But critics say his anti-vaccine campaign appears more aimed at currying favor with Kennedy, President Trump, and their supporters as Paxton runs for the US Senate.
Meanwhile, the AAP this week had to renew another decades-old stance for children's health—one against unpasteurized dairy, aka raw milk. Since the early 20th century, dairy producers in the US have briefly heated milk to kill the array of dangerous pathogens that naturally dwell in and around cattle and can easily migrate into milk. The simple intervention of pasteurization contributed to a sharp, "remarkable" drop in infant deaths and illnesses.
But, much like vaccines, a flood of misinformation has eroded trust and understanding of this public health triumph. And again, Kennedy has been among the advocates working to reverse this health victory.
In recent years, state laws have been loosening on raw milk, despite a federal ban on interstate commerce. At least 27 states now allow raw milk sales. In turn, outbreaks from raw milk have increased over the past two decades, the AAP highlights. Nearly half the illnesses in these outbreaks are in children—who are particularly vulnerable to foodborne pathogens.
Last week, ProPublica reported the heart-wrenching story of a 17-month-old girl in California, who nearly died after acquiring E. coli O157:H7 from drinking raw goat milk. She developed a life-threatening complication called hemolytic uremic syndrome that destroys red blood cells and damages blood vessels in the kidneys, which can lead to kidney failure and death. She required intensive care, and although she survived, she will have lasting effects from the ordeal. Her speech and motor development were halted, and she faces long-term kidney problems, requiring monitoring by a nephrologist every six months.
Prior to the girl's infection, her mother was unaware of the dangers of unpasteurized dairy and trusted information on social media, which falsely claimed that raw milk has health benefits over pasteurized milk. Such myths have persisted despite experts pointing out for years that they are unfounded or plainly false. The girl's mother now strongly regrets ever giving her daughter the raw milk and has tried to raise awareness of the risk—only to get barred from online groups for speaking out.
In the AAP's policy renewal this week, pediatricians review all the reasons health experts have, for decades, endorsed consuming only pasteurized dairy products.
"The AAP also endorses a ban on the sale or distribution of unpasteurized milk and milk products throughout the United States," the AAP wrote. "This recommendation is based on the multiplicity of data regarding the burden of illness associated with consumption of unpasteurized milk and milk products, especially among pregnant people, fetuses and neonates, and infants and young children, as well as the strong scientific evidence that pasteurization does not alter the nutritional value of milk."
(Score: 3, Insightful) by ikanreed on Saturday October 10, @01:28PM (3 children)
I've noticed grocery stores selling raw milk directly beside pasteurized milk with the only labeling difference being fine print "low temperature pasteurized"
This shit isn't just going to kill the kind of people who are dumb enough to believe it. Some kids whose parents aren't even aware an ideological battle is happening are going to die of salmonella
(Score: 3, Interesting) by hopdevil on Saturday October 10, @03:13PM
Are you talking about https://www.madebycow.com.au/ [madebycow.com.au] ?
(Score: 3, Informative) by khallow on Saturday October 10, @08:26PM (1 child)
Low temperature pasteurization is still pasteurization. This study [nih.gov] describes it as:
Reading around, it appears that LTLT pasteurization is legally considered pasteurization in the US, but I can't find a direct link to such authorization.
(Score: 1, Interesting) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday October 11, @05:30AM
To add to this, there is UV pasteurisation, which sprays droplets of milk down a tube filled with strong UV light. The UV light kills everything more effectively than heating the milk, therefore reducing the energy required per litre of milk.
(Score: 4, Interesting) by BsAtHome on Saturday October 10, @01:31PM (3 children)
I due time, the country will be available for colonization:
(Score: 5, Funny) by epitaxial on Saturday October 10, @02:09PM (2 children)
Hopefully the next country to colonize us has healthcare.
(Score: 2) by krishnoid on Saturday October 10, @04:04PM
If we do it right [nih.gov], maybe it doesn't even have to be a country to improve health outcomes.
(Score: 2) by Gaaark on Saturday October 10, @05:05PM
Oh we do... we do.
Yes.
And Corner Gas. Oh yes.
--- Please remind me if I haven't been civil to you: I'm channeling MDC. I have always been here. ---Gaaark 2.0 --
(Score: 1, Troll) by Thesis on Saturday October 10, @05:00PM (6 children)
I do not give a sh*t what folks want to do or consume. This is more about freedom and knowledge. Currently, the freedoms have become less in the US in the last 60yrs (yes, I'm old). Insurance companies, doctors, and hospitals force vaccinations upon everyone. Don't want them, fine, you are excluded from healthcare in the majority of the US, among other things (some jobs). I am not anti-vax , but I am very much pro-freedom. Some vaccines have excellent research behind them, and some do not. The drug companies push products hard and pay incentives.
https://openpaymentsdata.cms.gov/ [cms.gov]
Let folks ask questions, do thier own research and decide on thier own what they want. I feel the same way toward milk. As long as folks know what they are getting, let them do as they wish. No more nanny state crap. Darwin will sort things out.
(Score: 5, Interesting) by krishnoid on Saturday October 10, @05:14PM (1 child)
So survival of the fittest selects against ... education via social media? That kind of sounds right.
Helpful hint: look for citations, then check them. I never thought I'd have to say that, but apparently I'm in the minority.
(Score: 3, Informative) by krishnoid on Saturday October 10, @06:10PM
And at least as a courtesy, I should follow my own advice [nih.gov].
(Score: 4, Informative) by Gaaark on Saturday October 10, @10:42PM
Except, you drink milk straight from the cow and get sick, no one but you gets hurt (I DO know people who drink it that way and are fine).
Enough people don't get vaccinated and a lot of people can get hurt.
It's like going around coughing in other peoples' faces.... they may wear a mask around you, but they could still get what you have.
--- Please remind me if I haven't been civil to you: I'm channeling MDC. I have always been here. ---Gaaark 2.0 --
(Score: 4, Touché) by epitaxial on Sunday October 11, @02:13AM
Name the vaccines with bad research.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday October 11, @09:07PM
I partially agree. I think vaccines on a population level are important, to keep rates of sickness and death low, and the herd immunity type thing.
But raw milk? Let it be sold, who cares. Put labels on the side. Like methylated spirits or kerosene. The risk is with the consumer.
(Score: 2) by Dr Spin on Monday October 12, @04:28PM
It is a good thing that Americans have the "Right to remain dead".
(We certainly don't want them returning as zombies!)
Warning: Opening your mouth may invalidate your brain!
(Score: 4, Interesting) by looorg on Saturday October 10, @05:52PM (2 children)
I don't recall ever seeing any real research that would indicate that raw, or unpasteurized, milk would cure or help in any regard. No hidden health benefits. There was some reports a long time ago that children that grew up on farms and drank raw milk became healthier. But that had more to do with the lifestyle of growing up out in the countryside and having an active life then drinking raw milk. It's not curing allergies or lactose intolerance or whatever issue the usual claims are. There is just no proof of that.
Raw milk is fatter, it contains some more enzymes that are not altered by the boiling. But unless raw milk is your only source of essential enzymes and such then there is no point. Normal milk is enhanced after pasteurization with vitamins and such. So unless you are living after some kind of stone-age-diet where sucking down raw cow milk is your main source of enzymes, vitamins and minerals. There is no point.
If you are cooking or baking with it then well you are boiling it anyway, or at least heating it well above the level to kill most bacteria. Then you are doing it for the higher fat content then from normal milk. So why you bought it then I don't quite understand as it added no benefit. Even tho said benefits are completely imaginary.
If you are drinking it raw you are more likely to drink ecoli or campylobacter. Both which are basically poop or lower intestine related -- so enjoy your explosive and horrific diarrhea. If you are an adult you are probably and usually fine drinking small amounts of it. But children, old people or sick people. Not a good thing.
So unless your goal is the cull the weak or you want to breed a race of lactose tolerant supermen (aka Scandinavians) you are just out of luck.
I had unpasteurized milk. I don't think it was better for me. It certainly didn't taste better. I don't think I got any extra goodies. But that might be more of an opinion. I prefer mine pasteurized and from the box.
(Score: 2) by krishnoid on Saturday October 10, @06:12PM (1 child)
Whoops, I should have checked your post before adding the citation above [nih.gov].
(Score: 3, Insightful) by looorg on Saturday October 10, @06:38PM
You added a link to an actual report. That is good. I just recalled mine from memory. From growing up on a farm, not that we had cows but the farm next to ours did.
After all if any of these claims had any validity and it cured all those things we would be injecting people with raw milk to cure allergies and boost their tolerance to lactose. The benefit of that would be massive. We would have raw milk pills. School and kindergarten children would get raw milk boxes every day and with every meal. But it doesn't work. So we don't do it.
As far as I know the only benefit of raw milk is the higher fat content. That is really the main reason, beyond idiocy, that people buy it here. They bake with it. It's the milk ingredient in some local recipes of cheesecake. Beyond that I don't know what it should be used for in any kind of meaningful way. It certainly doesn't taste better.
(Score: 2, Insightful) by VLM on Saturday October 10, @06:08PM (4 children)
So the authoritarians who made America fat and sick, are super butthurt that someone isn't blindly obeying them, and the professional liar class is mad about it too, and oh god no it's Trump derangement syndrome.
I wonder if these people are self-aware about how they look to the normal population. I'd suspect... no.
(Score: 3, Touché) by khallow on Saturday October 10, @06:39PM
Hmmm
You wouldn't be referring to authoritarians like Ken Paxton, would you?
(Score: 5, Insightful) by istartedi on Saturday October 10, @10:24PM
Sometimes the authoritarians tell you to eat crickets and buy climate indulgences to redeem your carbon spewing sinful soul. Sometimes they tell you to take vaccines and wear seat belts.
This is why accepting or rejecting ideas only on the basis of who fronts them is not a good idea. You can even question the thesis in the previous sentence if you like. I'd be disappointed if you didn't.
Appended to the end of comments you post. Max: 120 chars.
(Score: 3, Insightful) by epitaxial on Sunday October 11, @02:16AM (1 child)
Who specifically?
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday October 11, @03:59PM
It never replies to questions. It is worthless to debate it.
(Score: 1, Flamebait) by DadaDoofy on Sunday October 11, @11:29AM (3 children)
I find it amusing that the same people who are fine with handing out free heroin have their panties in a major twist over people drinking raw milk. It's pretty obvious this is more about protecting their Big Dairy donors than any feigned concern about public health.
(Score: 0, Insightful) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday October 11, @06:39PM (2 children)
Once again, raw milk frequently contains dangerous pathogens that cause illness. These pathogens disproportionately cause young children to become dangerously ill. There is clear evidence for this, no matter how much RFK Jr. and those like him stupidly deny the data. It greatly endangers the health of young children to give them raw milk to drink.
Why are you defending child abuse, sicko?
(Score: 0, Troll) by DadaDoofy on Sunday October 11, @08:08PM (1 child)
The democrat governor of Minnesota just signed a bill that allows women to murder their babies up until the instant they are born. The democrats in the chamber stood up and cheered. And you're accusing me of being a "child-abusing sicko"? LOL
(Score: 0, Insightful) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday October 11, @08:36PM
Giving young children raw milk when there's a high risk that it contains dangerous pathogens is reckless endangerment. Doing so can reasonably be considered child abuse. Because a Democrat in Minnesota signed an abortion bill into law that you don't like, that makes it okay to give raw milk that often contains dangerous pathogens to young children?
Once again, why are you tacitly defending child abuse, sicko?