Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by hubie on Wednesday November 04, @02:28AM   Printer-friendly

'Meta's smart glasses have increasingly been implicated in disturbing invasions of privacy.'

US Senators Ron Wyden (D-Or) and and Edward Markey (D-Ma) are investigating "serious privacy and safety risks" around Meta's AI smart glasses. "Meta's smart glasses have increasingly been implicated in disturbing invasions of users' and bystanders' privacy," the pair wrote in a letter to Mark Zuckerberg, adding that Meta launched the product even after identifying risks to bystander privacy.

The senators highlighted multiple incidents of Meta's glasses being used in "disturbing" invasions of privacy. It cited both 404 Media and BBC articles about men secretly filming women with Meta's "pervert glasses" while harassing them, then posting the recordings to social media. It also noted that according to other reports and a lawsuit, Meta's AI contractors said they reviewed footage captured by the eyewear showing people undressing and engaging in sexual activity.

The senators requested that Meta respond to specific questions about accidental camera activation and recording-indicator tampering. They also want to know if the glasses blur faces and license plates for certain AI interactions, like Meta does on Facebook and Instagram. It asked Meta to explain the circumstances that imagery is made accessible to employees or contracts, or when it's used to train AI models. Finally, citing Meta's own documents, it asked the company whether it conducted detailed human rights due diligence and safety testing on its glasses before releasing them. It requested those responses by Thanksgiving (November 26, 2026).

The list of complaints about Meta's glasses is long. On top of the ones cited by Wyden and Markey, users have said that the glasses were recording their conversations without consent following a firmware update. They've also been spotted on ICE agents during raids, and the New York City Police's counterterrorism unit reportedly raised surveillance concerns about the devices in January this year. Earlier in October, California Governor Gavin Newsom vetoed a bill that would have banned people from using wearables to secretly record others in private areas of business.

However, Wyden and Markey seem more determined to hold the social media giant's feet to the fire. "Meta's professed commitment to privacy and preventing intimate image abuse rings hollow if the company cannot demonstrate meaningful steps to prevent its own products and practices from facilitating those harms," the senators told Zuckerberg.


Original Submission

This discussion was created by hubie (1068) for logged-in users only. Log in and try again!
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
(1)
  • (Score: 3, Informative) by krishnoid on Wednesday November 04, @06:36AM (2 children)

    by krishnoid (1156) on Wednesday November 04, @06:36AM (#1458525)

    Meta's AI contractors said they reviewed footage captured by the eyewear showing people undressing and engaging in sexual activity.

    Well, here we go again [cnbc.com] with Facebook.

    • (Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday November 04, @12:14PM (1 child)

      by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday November 04, @12:14PM (#1458534)

      Shocking that Facebook is hiring workers in a third world country.

      • (Score: 3, Informative) by krishnoid on Wednesday November 04, @04:23PM

        by krishnoid (1156) on Wednesday November 04, @04:23PM (#1458559)

        Hey now, they're Americans too:

        Following an earlier report that uncovered shocking working conditions at the vendor’s Phoenix facility, The Verge spoke with 12 current and former Cognizant content moderators in Tampa, Florida.

  • (Score: 5, Insightful) by Snotnose on Wednesday November 04, @01:02PM (1 child)

    by Snotnose (1623) on Wednesday November 04, @01:02PM (#1458537)

    And the car makers, and the TV makers, and the data brokers, etc etc etc.

    What we need to do is flat out outlaw the collecting of this information in the first place. Which will never happen until we get the billionaire's money out of our elections.

    --
    Being the dumbest idiot in the land and president of the US should be 2 different people.
    • (Score: 2, Touché) by Anonymous Coward on Thursday November 05, @01:14AM

      by Anonymous Coward on Thursday November 05, @01:14AM (#1458595)

      I dunno if billionaire money is as big a problem as they say. Musk spent half a billion, yet couldn't get a Republican elected in Texas.

      In Texas.

  • (Score: 3, Disagree) by Username on Wednesday November 04, @02:40PM (20 children)

    by Username (4557) on Wednesday November 04, @02:40PM (#1458551)

    I see zero difference between this and a gopro or other body cams. If you don't want it to record, turn it off. If you don't want it to stream, disconnect it.

    • (Score: 5, Interesting) by aafcac on Wednesday November 04, @03:21PM (18 children)

      by aafcac (17646) on Wednesday November 04, @03:21PM (#1458554)

      The difference is visibility. The glasses don't stand out as much and you don't typically know when they're capturing images and video.

      In general though we do need to admit that cameras are fundamentally different from just being seen by other people in terms of accuracy and memory.

      • (Score: 3, Interesting) by OrugTor on Wednesday November 04, @04:39PM (3 children)

        by OrugTor (5147) Subscriber Badge on Wednesday November 04, @04:39PM (#1458562)

        The glasses are not the villain. People who do bad things with them are the villains. Focus on stopping villains. By the way, if I want to record someone without their knowledge I'll use a phone that I appear to be texting on.
        The case of the man harassing a woman while recording is easily analyzed. It's staged in a public place - no expectation of privacy. It's harassment - already illegal. It's a case for the police, not polititians looking to whack Zuck with billions in fines.

        • (Score: 2) by DannyB on Wednesday November 04, @05:08PM

          by DannyB (5839) Subscriber Badge on Wednesday November 04, @05:08PM (#1458563) Journal

          polititians looking to whack Zuck with billions in fines

          You misspelled bribes campaign contributions.

          --
          Missionaries want to heal us and save our souls.
          Shoe salesmen want to heel us and save our soles.
        • (Score: 2) by Tork on Wednesday November 04, @07:19PM (1 child)

          by Tork (3914) Subscriber Badge on Wednesday November 04, @07:19PM (#1458568) Journal

          By the way, if I want to record someone without their knowledge I'll use a phone that I appear to be texting on.

          You have tells with that you don't have with glasses.

          --
          🏳️‍🌈 Proud Ally 🏳️‍🌈 - Give us ribbiti or make us croak! 🐸
      • (Score: 1, Troll) by Username on Wednesday November 04, @05:42PM (10 children)

        by Username (4557) on Wednesday November 04, @05:42PM (#1458565)

        There is no expectation of privacy in public. If I want to take a photo of people on the street I can. If you feel bad about your appearance, wear something presentable. If you don't want people recording your bad behavior, then just be a decent person while in a public space.

        • (Score: 5, Informative) by aafcac on Wednesday November 04, @10:47PM (9 children)

          by aafcac (17646) on Wednesday November 04, @10:47PM (#1458585)

          Just the usual bullshit excuse for psychopaths. People seeing you is one thing, recording it is completely different. We don't need to allow people to engage in surreptitiously recording of other people.

          • (Score: 4, Informative) by Tork on Thursday November 05, @12:59AM (3 children)

            by Tork (3914) Subscriber Badge on Thursday November 05, @12:59AM (#1458593) Journal
            The thing about glasses is people have them on when they go into non-public places, like bathrooms.
            --
            🏳️‍🌈 Proud Ally 🏳️‍🌈 - Give us ribbiti or make us croak! 🐸
            • (Score: 2) by aafcac on Thursday November 05, @01:54AM (1 child)

              by aafcac (17646) on Thursday November 05, @01:54AM (#1458598)

              To an extent yes, but surreptitious recording in public areas isn't automatically acceptable, nor should it be.

              • (Score: 2) by dmc on Thursday November 05, @03:41AM

                by dmc (188) on Thursday November 05, @03:41AM (#1458602)

                the devil is in the details of the laws relevant to the jurisdiction you are in. An interesting dynamic of how people behave differently if they Truly Believe that God or an All Seeing (Five)Eye(s) or Mafia or Illuminati or Big Brother is watching and recording for all time their every move. Kompromat, Neil Stepehenson's Gargoyles, cough cough.

                What kind of faith in the NSA do you have? (if the U.S. is your legal jurisdiction)

                The bit about 'recording indicator tampering' makes me think of the scene from the Stone/Snowden movie with the girlfriend and the webcam, and Snowden's stories of 'LOVINT', and then the bust out laughing news story several years later about FBI head Comey's admitting that _He_ does the black tape over the webcam lens 'trick'. Can you imagine if the illuminati actually taught people that they are not blocked by God from _painting black enamel over the recording indicator light_. Next thing you know scotus will make it legal to 3d print a bumpstock instead of improvising something simpler and cheaper that doesn't require a 3d printer that they figured out from looking at blurred stillframes on MythBusters, oh wait... Or maybe the solution is to try to pretend like you have a religious reason to walk around in a full hood and mask.

                Live Naked. It's a Brave New World out there kids. The quicker you learn to be helpless from the silent CIA without making them torture you first the happier you will be.

            • (Score: 2) by dmc on Thursday November 05, @04:31AM

              by dmc (188) on Thursday November 05, @04:31AM (#1458607)

              The people with criminal intent also have other form factor cameras available to them. Absolutely nothing about the fact that the camera looks like glasses is relevant, IMHO, to criminal acts we are debating concern about over here. If your solution is based on that, it is only going to perpetuate a false illusion of privacy/security. My solution is not sharing a bathroom or having complete line of sight privacy in the relevant subset of the larger bathroom (urinal, stall). Or not caring because after gitmotorture and snowden and trump, the idea of someone surreptitiously getting a photo of my penis that I can optionally falsely claim is inauthentic and was generated by ai really doesn't concern me. Even without that ai bit. I just hope skynet kills me before I have to live through another 6 years of potus trump gitmo psychological torture.

          • (Score: 2) by dmc on Thursday November 05, @03:27AM (4 children)

            by dmc (188) on Thursday November 05, @03:27AM (#1458601)

            Some people have better neurological wetware memory capabilities than others, including 'photographic memory'. Those people also are on a spectrum of artistic capabilities. There is no doubt a subset of humans that can use canvas and oil paints to accomplish the same feat of mad-magazine-x-ray-glasses-to-see-woments-nipples-under-their-clothing as rich kids can do today with a variety of cyber devices, many small and not obvious, in combination with various elements of 'ai' amounting to 'deepfakery'. Now, if the freaks that can do it without the cyber try to pass it off fraudulently or harrassingly or libelously or slanderously, guess what- they can be sued or prosecuted for those _long existing crimes_. Doing it 'on a computer' or 'with ai' doesn't change the perfectly reasonable laws/safeguards that were in place before.

            Personally I think it's the true psychopaths that are speaking the most loudly against technologies that will allow people to cyber-enhance their memory and artistic rendering capabilities to the point where they are not disadvantaged wrt those individuals whose natural abilities gave them a prior tactical advantage in a machiavellian and political world society. I personally suspect that a vast amount of bullying/horriffic-human-rights-violations will be prevented going forward due to this disruptive new empowerment of individuals with 'cyborgesque' technology. Vis-a-vis we already have seen the epoch with gitmo/abu-ghraib torture photos coming to Light, and a damned lot of Rodney King style exposing of what was in prior decades vastly efficiently covered up by amazingly corrupt authorities.

            It's the "{guns,hammers,etc} don't kill people, people kill people thing". But sure, call your debate opponents psychopaths. Whatever.

            • (Score: 3, Informative) by aafcac on Thursday November 05, @03:38PM (3 children)

              by aafcac (17646) on Thursday November 05, @03:38PM (#1458646)

              That's a crap argument, those abilities come at a massive cost, are much less reliable than people think and are rather rare. And no, there is no subset of humans that can accomplish what these glasses can. Even the best artists of all time can't, they might be able to replicate one moment in time, but it's not 100% accurate and it's still dependent upon them paying attention at the right moment.

              Just because there are even worse things that could be created doesn't justify allowing it. Part of why we've got Flock is that the courts were extremely slow to recognize that fundamentally cameras and video recorders are not the same thing as people just looking with their eyes. In other areas like what you can see n other people's windows has exceptions that exclude the use of equipment, what's going on outside hasn't gotten that protection, even though it should. If you watch somebody long enough they'll do something embarrassing.

              • (Score: 2) by dmc on Thursday November 05, @06:10PM (2 children)

                by dmc (188) on Thursday November 05, @06:10PM (#1458655)

                "We don't need to allow people to engage in surreptitiously recording of other people."

                The words I'd like to focus my argument on there are "need" and "allow". I don't have any idea what jurisdiiction/laws you are subject to in your home area, but I am arguing from a U.S.A. context here.

                I.e. it's not hard to imagine a kind of parallel argument of that form along the lines of

                "We don't need to allow journalists to be free from threat of imprisonment (or torture at gitmo) for withholding identification of their sources when their reporting exposes government corruption and crimes".

                I agree, that there are many jurisdictions and government frameworks that will evaluate their own 'needs' of what to 'allow' differently. I personally, and wish my countryfolk would agree or be persuaded by good arguments, think "we need to not violate important aspects of Liberty and checks and balances on government power". The technological ability to cyborgesquely enhance the average citizen's tactical abilities with non-visible audio/video recording devices, is something that, particularly after the iconic videos we have seen in the past decade of the Black Lives Matter 'movement'(I tend to see it as inextricably intertwined with precisely the advent of inexpensive audio/video recording technology in the hands of the masses capturing a statistically significant portion of the viscious police corruption and murders that previously had been successfully hidden from a gaslighted public)... Well, I think and hope you get my point enough to at least respectfully disagree with my argument without simply writing it off as 'crap'.

                Honestly our 2nd amendment 'right to bear arms' is a big factor in my thinking because I believe that *used* to be a kind of check and balance between the powers of the individual and the state. In the modern world of the kinds of tactical domination weapons the US and other governments have and use to control people (think microwave heat/pain canons replacing cruder earlier water based weapons from iconic '60s and '70s "wild protests"), that a right to buy handguns or even AR15/AK47's is not a realistic check on totalitarian government tendencies. Personally I think that the ability to surreptitiously record in *cough* public space *cough* is a functionally better check against government power these days than owning a dozen guns and thousands of rounds of ammunition.

                Bottom line- "you'll get my secret camera I got for $20 from amazon 10 years ago when you pry it out of my cold dead hands" (to evoke that famous political dude that played Moses in the blockbuster movie a hundred years ago or whatever). Because I don't believe it is or should be your or anybody else's right to decide when to "allow" me to have access to that kind of technology when *I* feel I "need" it.

                • (Score: 3, Touché) by aafcac on Thursday November 05, @11:33PM (1 child)

                  by aafcac (17646) on Thursday November 05, @11:33PM (#1458669)

                  It's a crap argument to make. Being able to secretly record people is not an essential liberty or something that has any value in society. If somebody is doing something bad enough to warrant the filming, then they're doing something bad enough that you're justified in showing that you're recording it. And there's often times restrictions on those sorts of filming versus just normal filming for a reason.
                  All those videos that you're referring to were done out in the open. The person doing the recording was standing there visibly filming. Allowing for the filming to be done using hidden cameras hasn't been the barrier to getting that stuff down on film. And presumably the 1st amendment would apply to anybody doing such a thing as part of an actual bit of citizen journalism.

                  As far as the 2nd amendment goes, putting it back to where it was during the 19th century would probably solve most of that stuff, not that the originalists would hear of it as they're not being bribed to do so.

                  As far as that camera goes, good luck if you get caught with it though. Which is kind of the issue. Those cameras have zero value for lawful use. If you can't be seen recording things, then you're clearly doing things that are illegal or aren't socially acceptable.

                  Your whole posts kind of reinforce the point that I'm making, you haven't expressed a reason why these cameras should be allowed outside of law enforcement or professional journalism. And citing that POS Charlton Heston isn't exactly a compelling argument. He was old and probably senile by the point that he was making those statements.

                  • (Score: 2) by dmc on Friday November 06, @12:55AM

                    by dmc (188) on Friday November 06, @12:55AM (#1458679)

                    "It's a crap argument to make."

                    Time and history will tell and be the judge of that.

                    "Being able to secretly record people is not an essential liberty or something that has any value in society."

                    I say it is as long as you have no criminal intent while doing it, and commit no crimes with the data afterword.

                    "If somebody is doing something bad enough to warrant the filming, then they're doing something bad enough that you're justified in showing that you're recording it."

                    This debate is about choosing not to show that you are recording, not about being in a position where you 'need' justification to show that you are recording.

                    "All those videos that you're referring to were done out in the open."

                    I'm skeptical, though my memory is wetware and limited. Anyone who lived through the same recent history as I have, should not need persuading that in at least some of those situations, the amateur journalist doing the filming had clear rational reasons to consider if not opt to not advertise the fact they were recording.

                    "Allowing for the filming to be done using hidden cameras hasn't been the barrier to getting that stuff down on film."

                    'that stuff'... There is a *lot* of 'stuff' going on in the world. I don't know if there is a way to wager on this on a prediction market, but I for one will not be surprised if covert recording of future 'stuff' makes big news at points during the next decade or two. Maybe I'm a crap thinker like you say and wrong. Honestly I hope you are right about that, but I don't think you are.

                    "As far as that camera goes, good luck if you get caught with it though. Which is kind of the issue. Those cameras have zero value for lawful use. If you can't be seen recording things, then you're clearly doing things that are illegal or aren't socially acceptable."

                    Again, without criminal intent or subsequent crime, the act itself is 'lawful'. And certainly many in society might find it not acceptable, but I'd be quite surprised if not even a few did, given the kinds of arguments I have laid out here.

                    "you haven't expressed a reason why these cameras should be allowed outside of law enforcement or professional journalism."

                    You haven't been listening to what I have been saying. Or maybe my brain is damaged. Again, it would be nice if you were absolutely right, and all my fears and concerns and rationalizations here were completely unfounded. That would be a better case scenario. I on the other hand am the kind of person who watched the Tyre Nichols murder videos closely several times. We need a defense against that kind of casual civic corruption. Lawful use of covert recording makes sense to me. But I hear what you are saying. You are probably in the democratic majority. But it doesn't make you right.

                    Gitmo is an abomination. I will make it a point of considering your broad assertions while watching HBO's Ghost's of Abu Ghraib again. I vaguely recall there may have been some covert recording involved in some of those videos, though I do clearly recall that many of them were done surprisingly uncovertly.

      • (Score: 2) by dmc on Thursday November 05, @04:18AM (2 children)

        by dmc (188) on Thursday November 05, @04:18AM (#1458604)

        "The difference is visibility. The glasses don't stand out as much[...]"

        Your perspective might be different if 5 and 10 years ago you had educationally searched amazon for 'tinyest camera' or 'spy camera'. There is nothing going on here that was not entirely predictable many years ago. That the powers that be (from relevant in the know people in government and industry) didn't openly and honestly address the issue years ago is what _I_ think the focus should be on. Society is basically as stupid as the CIA and NSA wanted them to be. And not because of noble intentions.

        Your fundamentalist comment reminds of maybe a tv show I saw documenting a historical controversy when literally photography itself was born as a 'disruptive' almost 'magically-powerful' new technology. No small number of people back in those days apparently had issues with how being 'photographed' could literally threaten the security of 'their soul'. Yes it's fundamentally different, but that controversy sailed over a century ago.

        • (Score: 2) by aafcac on Thursday November 05, @11:38PM (1 child)

          by aafcac (17646) on Thursday November 05, @11:38PM (#1458670)

          This is just uneducated prattle. If you don't honestly see a difference between now when you've got AI enabled cameras capturing people from hundreds of different locations as they go about their lives and hundreds of cameras in various stores on top of that from the photography of even 50 years ago, then you're just not a serious person.

          You act like I didn't also object to when the CIA and NSA were doing those things as well. But it turns out that there's not really much that can be done about that when all of the politicians are in the tank and the courts are as well. It takes rather a lot of effort in order to work that out.

          • (Score: 2) by dmc on Friday November 06, @01:07AM

            by dmc (188) on Friday November 06, @01:07AM (#1458682)

            "when all of the politicians are in the tank and the courts are as well."

            Another bold broad assertion that I am quite skeptical of. But perhaps you could clarify precisely what you mean by 'tank' here.

            Sure, of course there are differences. And I consider myself a serious enough if not overly serious person. But sometimes when things are as widespreadly bad as they are, it helps to hold onto a bit of levity or humor. I'm quite the fan of the intellectual political stand-up comedy of the late great Bill Hicks.

            Another obvious standard debate point that seems outside your worldview is the old "if you outlaw guns, only the outlaws will have guns". It really sounds like you are advocating for a law that would make contraband any camera under a certain physical size, or based on some other unspecified critieria. That sounds pretty clearly not the right kind of solution. Not terribly relevant, but it reminds me of the thing where in order to sortof more 'lawfully' 3d-print a 'liberator' you need to leave a cavity and insert a chunk of metal so that it can be more easily detected my metal detectors.

    • (Score: 1, Insightful) by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday November 04, @03:51PM

      by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday November 04, @03:51PM (#1458556)

      Stupid on purpose. sheesh.

(1)