SoylentNews is people
SoylentNews
Submitted on behalf of user "crutchy" #179, who writes:
"I don't seem to be able to use the 'Submit Story' feature at the moment... I just thought I'd flag a little saga currently unfolding near where I live. An open cut coal mine that supplies coal to a nearby 1600MW power station in Victoria, Australia, has been on fire for over a week. This could threaten electricity generation in the area and might have been deliberately set.
What might be more interesting is the lack of news media attention to it."
[Ed. Note] we're working on fixing article submission, thanks for getting this to us via alternate means.
This discussion has been archived.
No new comments can be posted.
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
Can anyone remember when the times were not hard, and money not scarce?
(Score: 3, Interesting) by kwerle on Monday February 17 2014, @05:58PM
The reason it isn't covered is because it isn't generally newsworthy. Certainly I don't think it has any place on this site.
Then again, what kind of news is this site for? Maybe its audience is people who are interested in possible local crimes and eco-econo issues.
If that's the case, I should bail. If this is meant to replace news for nerds, then the editors need to screen this kind of thing out.
(Score: 5, Informative) by mattie_p on Monday February 17 2014, @06:10PM
I'd ask you to stick around a little longer, if you can. We're working to screen the best articles that have been submitted, and if there is news that YOU would like to see I'd ask that you collaborate with us in submitting it. Thanks for reading.
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Monday February 17 2014, @06:43PM
It's not that I want to see more news. I want to see less non-news.
If there's no news, I wanna see nothing. That's something that /. failed at a lot.
(Score: 5, Informative) by mattie_p on Monday February 17 2014, @07:26PM
Please feel free to submit great articles that you want to see. We want this to be community driven, and you are part of the community. Right now I simply don't have time to go find awesome articles. I and the other editors need you to do that for us, to make this a place where nerds of all kinds want to come to in order to get some facts on what is relevant in their lives, and see what others think on those topics.
(Score: 2, Informative) by Nerdfest on Monday February 17 2014, @07:59PM
That said, this is news to me, as are large scale environmental issues in general. They affect all of us and cross well over into the science arena these days because global warming.
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Tuesday February 18 2014, @03:43AM
Fair enough. Gimme an amazing filter. Or at least an adequate one.
(Score: -1, Troll) by crutchy on Monday February 17 2014, @08:36PM
"If there's no news, I wanna see nothing"
you're an idiot
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Tuesday February 18 2014, @03:18AM
you're an idiot
Why do you say?
(Score: 2, Insightful) by Anonymous Coward on Monday February 17 2014, @09:29PM
*sigh* You're one of those aren't you? You know who I mean, the guy who hates things if they dont appeal to him, for no other reason then to hate them.
If you dont like the news that is posted, either post your own, or don't read the article. In fact you can even pretend the news you aren't interested isn't even here. It would be just like if there was no news.
The rest of us on the other hand don't have a problem with this article.
(Score: 2, Interesting) by Nkwe on Monday February 17 2014, @07:44PM
It might be newsworthy if the summary or discussion talks about how vulnerabilities in critical services impact our lives. Discussions on why the loss of one power plant can impact customers (and why there isn't redundancy). The summary suggests it might be deliberate. How about discussion on protection of technology against deliberate attack? Lots of things that could be relevant to the audience.
(Score: 3, Informative) by crutchy on Monday February 17 2014, @08:50PM
i can tell you from first hand experience that the air quality in the nearby cities of Morwell and Traralgon is terrible
http://www.epa.vic.gov.au/our-work/monitoring-the- environment/air-quality-bulletins/24-hour-air-qual ity-summary [vic.gov.au]
sometimes if i go outside i can feel my eyes begin to sting after a short while. a few days ago there was an overpowering smell of burning rubber in the air (i was walking my kids to school... contemplated turning around and keeping them home inside)
there have been warnings from the health department to stay indoors (we use a FireReady app (http://www.cfa.vic.gov.au/plan-prepare/fireready- app/) to receive up to date info, as well as listen to radio for emergency warnings, but there isn't much else on TV about it, but it's hard to just stay indoors when this fire has been going on for a week and is projected to go on for at least another fortnight.
firefighters have been treated for carbon monoxide poisoning (http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/firefighters-fa lling-ill-at-coal-mine-fire-20140216-32u0r.html).. . this was actually something that did get a little attention from the media... mainly trying to blame fire authorities for not caring about safety, though i'm sure if the power station was more impacted the media wouldn't give a shit about firefighters.
the national highway (highway 1, named the princes highway) runs right alongside the fire, and there's a stretch of about 5km of the highway where we have to slow down from 110 km/hr to 80 km/hr whilst travelling through thick smoke (eyes get very stingy) that requires headlights in the daytime
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Tuesday February 18 2014, @03:36AM
Naw, I don't think so.
(Score: 0, Flamebait) by crutchy on Monday February 17 2014, @08:34PM
oh, i'm sorry... it isn't google or fox doing the censorship and it isn't in the united states... *slaps self*
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Tuesday February 18 2014, @03:31AM
oh, i'm sorry... it isn't google or fox doing the censorship and it isn't in the united states... *slaps self*
No, lemme make this clear:
I don't give a shit what fox does or does not say. Not ever. And certainly not here. While I may at some level give a shit about coal fires, I certainly don't want to see news about it HERE. Same thing goes for possible arson.
(Score: 1) by Gaaark on Tuesday February 18 2014, @04:51AM
Please submit the kind of story YOU want to see: there are probably a lot of people who would also like to see it!
The 'problem' is, we are all different. That said, a lot of different things grab my interest: I might want to read what you might want to submit.
Not being trolly... I just need my machine to be fed and may find your type of story interesting.
--- Please remind me if I haven't been civil to you: I'm channeling MDC. ---Gaaark 2.0 ---
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Tuesday February 18 2014, @05:13AM
The 'problem' is, we are all different. That said, a lot of different things grab my interest: I might want to read what you might want to submit.
Sure, that's true. And that's part of the reason I'm hoping to see some kind of goal/subject statement for the site. If this is to replace slashdot (and, one hopes, improve), then I'd like to never see this kind of story, here.
If this site is going to cover TSA incidents, car fires, and arbitrary topics like this, then I should bail.
My hope is that this will cover technology news. Which this is not. My hope is that you will find news about coal fires that may have been caused by arson on an eco news site or some other site that talks about possible arson.
(Score: 2) by mattie_p on Tuesday February 18 2014, @06:25AM
kwerle, since this article was posted, we've released articles on auperconductivity research, Google buying (yet) another tech company, a Tesla story (or not, but gotta love those flamewars!), discussion on DRM within HTML5, Java 8 release candidate, and DNS snooping. If we are not meeting your needs here, please let us know what articles you ARE looking for. Unfortunately I am not a mind reader, nor are the other editors.
The best way for you to tell us what you want to see is to submit a story yourself! [soylentnews.org] I really have the same goal in mind as you, and I hope that as a site we will be able to articulate the vision we have and meet the needs that you want.
Thanks for reading!
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Tuesday February 18 2014, @04:12PM
Yeah, that's a Tesla story. It is NOT a news item.
The best way for you to tell us what you want to see is to submit a story yourself! I really have the same goal in mind as you, and I hope that as a site we will be able to articulate the vision we have and meet the needs that you want.
Again: I'm telling you what I do NOT want to see because that's more important to me than what I do want to see. The tech news you mentioned is all great stuff (again, the Tesla story is not news). That's never been the problem with /. The problem has ever been the signal to noise ratio because the editors failed to reject trash stories.
(Score: 1) by crutchy on Tuesday February 18 2014, @06:32AM
so... apple sues google, google sues apple, apple sues microsoft, microsoft buys motorola, linux 3.X released, nvidia support for linux is shit, steam... bitcoin...
maybe you should go back to slashdot
i brought up this story not only for its environmental impacts, but also the possible/apparent mainstream media censorship issue
it's fine if you don't think it's newsworthy... but please don't assume that nobody thinks it's newsworthy
i doubt you will find any newssite in the world that only publishes articles/stories that all of its readership enjoys
it is also early days for solent... if nobody contributes anything out of fear of backlash there isn't going to be much to read and comment on
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Tuesday February 18 2014, @04:00PM
so... apple sues google, google sues apple, apple sues microsoft, microsoft buys motorola, linux 3.X released, nvidia support for linux is shit, steam... bitcoin...
maybe you should go back to slashdot
Maybe.
My point is that /. carries too many articles like this (non tech articles), and too many non news articles (a car caught fire). Frankly, I'm not very interested when companies sue each other - I'm far more interested in when suits are settled and something actually happened.
My hope is that the focus of this site be narrower than what /. has become. Not that there be more articles - but that there be fewer of better quality.
Again, a goal statement would perhaps be helpful.
(Score: 0) by crutchy on Tuesday February 18 2014, @08:51PM
how is that newsworthy? usually it merely consists of a handshake and a non-disclosure agreement
also, if you're seriously comparing the coal mine in TFA to a car fire, i encourage you to look into it more (even though there isn't much in the mainstream media). the mine is huge and even the fire is about 3 km long. fire authorities are still trying to figure out how to put the thing out after more than a week. i have a feeling this fire will eventually appear in the mainstream media, but by then it will be too late.
(Score: 1) by kwerle on Tuesday February 18 2014, @09:02PM
how is that newsworthy? usually it merely consists of a handshake and a non-disclosure agreement
It probably isn't. And by extension, the announcement that a suit is *starting* certainly is not.
also, if you're seriously comparing the coal mine in TFA to a car fire, i encourage you to look into it more
From a technology standpoint, they're about identical. Nothing [interesting] to do with tech. The fact that the coal fire is big doesn't make it more technologically interesting. If they use some interesting tech to put it out, then I'd love to hear about it. Until then, it's a coal mine fire. And if it was arson, then it was a crime. Neither of those give it a reason to be on this site (I hope).
(Score: 1) by crutchy on Tuesday February 18 2014, @09:14PM
the fact that it is threatening a power station might be... a lot of tech doesn't work well without them :-P
there is some interesting tech being used from what i hear. it's unfortunate that the media hasn't reported on it, but there aren't hundreds of firefighters lined up with conventional hoses trying to put this thing out. from what i hear there are some fairly specialized high volume firefighting appliances being used. i haven't seen any pics, so unfortunately this is just third-hand info. you don't put a coal fire out by hammering it with a water jet because it kinda acts like oil in some ways (it just spreads). i would think that's whatever the equipment actually is looks like, the water being pumped onto the fire is probably low pressure but high volume; so very large pipes with water flowing over the batters from the top maybe.
the aspect that i originally thought might be interesting to soylent readers was the apparent media/corporate cover up (the mine and power station is owned by GDF Suez). it's something that is talked about a lot around here (in my engineering circle) anyway.