Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 14 submissions in the queue.
posted by cmn32480 on Tuesday December 20 2016, @08:37AM   Printer-friendly
from the my-floppy-drive-still-works dept.

Our office recently updated to a new version of the Office Suite, and it still has an icon in the upper-left corner to perform the 'Save' function. Floppy drives have not been in use for years, and many children would not recognize a 3.5 inch floppy disk on sight. Programs have used this icon for years, because we have yet to find a suitable replacement. The CD/DVD can no longer represent saving, because they have come and gone. Even moving to the more abstract Piggy Bank icon would not work, because they are seldom used in the modern age. A USB Key icon may represent saving in some form, but the may not be around much longer if another medium gains favor. Does this mean that the venerable 3.5 inch Floppy will represent saving information to future generations, or should it be replaced by a different symbol?


Original Submission

 
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 4, Insightful) by xorsyst on Tuesday December 20 2016, @12:39PM

    by xorsyst (1372) on Tuesday December 20 2016, @12:39PM (#443724)

    Why is anyone clicking save any more? What we really want is the application to auto save all the time, including saving the undo history. There should be no need for an explicit "save" action at all!

    Starting Score:    1  point
    Moderation   +2  
       Flamebait=1, Insightful=2, Interesting=1, Disagree=1, Total=5
    Extra 'Insightful' Modifier   0  
    Karma-Bonus Modifier   +1  

    Total Score:   4  
  • (Score: 3, Interesting) by Lemming on Tuesday December 20 2016, @05:38PM

    by Lemming (1053) on Tuesday December 20 2016, @05:38PM (#443913)

    Indeed. This is the philosophy Apple follows since some time. If you close an application like a word processor, and open it again, it looks exactly like when you closed it, including all the documents you had open. When you close a document it is saved automatically. You won't get a dialog asking you to save. The only time you are prompted is when you close a new document which has no file name yet. Even closing the app with new documents open won't give you a prompt, the next time you open it your "Untitled" documents will still be there.

    And they extended their Time Machine interface to work inside applications, so you can go back to previous versions of a document. You can even copy/paste parts of an old version into the current one.

  • (Score: 2) by Pino P on Tuesday December 20 2016, @06:00PM

    by Pino P (4721) on Tuesday December 20 2016, @06:00PM (#443932) Journal

    What we really want is the application to auto save all the time, including saving the undo history.

    Then let me rephrase: What should the icon for "make a copy of the file without any embarrassments that may be present in the undo history" look like?

    And in a lot of cases, "what we really want" is impractical on the hardware we have today, such as limited SSD space or HDD write delays or lag from having to deeply copy the undo history to a new thread for serialization after every brush stroke or every word you type.

    • (Score: 2) by xorsyst on Wednesday December 21 2016, @09:24AM

      by xorsyst (1372) on Wednesday December 21 2016, @09:24AM (#444267)

      What we really want is the application to auto save all the time, including saving the undo history.

      Then let me rephrase: What should the icon for "make a copy of the file without any embarrassments that may be present in the undo history" look like?

      You mean 'publish' or 'export'. Good question, I don't think there tends to be a standard for that. But it's definitely not "save" - as anyone who has ever received word documents by email will attest to.

      And in a lot of cases, "what we really want" is impractical on the hardware we have today, such as limited SSD space or HDD write delays or lag from having to deeply copy the undo history to a new thread for serialization after every brush stroke or every word you type.

      I don't believe this argument for a minute on anything other than massive video editing.

      • (Score: 2) by Pino P on Wednesday December 21 2016, @02:09PM

        by Pino P (4721) on Wednesday December 21 2016, @02:09PM (#444310) Journal

        So I take it that for any media type anything other than video, all desktop, laptop, tablet, and smartphone devices sold in the past few years have the CPU speed, the storage speed, and the storage capacity to store the entire edit history of a document, drawing, or painting from blank page to the present in enough detail to recreate a movie of its creation, and saving this history in real time up to the second as it is being edited will introduce zero lag to editing. Is this your claim? Have you made or even used a free application for a free operating system that offers this functionality, and if so, which?

        If so, operating systems will need to make the "publish" action automatic because as I understand it, version control systems such as Git expect to see the published version.

  • (Score: 2) by jbWolf on Thursday December 22 2016, @04:31AM

    by jbWolf (2774) <jbNO@SPAMjb-wolf.com> on Thursday December 22 2016, @04:31AM (#444624) Homepage

    I don't mind the option for others, but I personally don't want it. Why?

    For privacy reasons, I would not want my undo history saved on all files.

    Also, I have the unusual approach to actively work on documents for more than a decade. (Now approaching two decades for some.) I don't want all the baggage from that long ago cluttering up my file uselessly. If I do it, I'm not the only one.

    And it would be insane to have permanent undo that cannot be turned off in Photoshop or video editing software.

    Also, corruption. Microsoft Word can't handle anything with more than a hundred pages without corruption. Even LibreOffice bogs down at a hundred pages. Undo will just make those problems worse.

    So, there are reasons.

    --
    www.jb-wolf.com [jb-wolf.com]