Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 16 submissions in the queue.
posted by LaminatorX on Friday June 13 2014, @03:09PM   Printer-friendly
from the Injustice-for-All dept.

In 2009, a National Academy of Sciences committee embarked on a long-overdue quest to study typical forensics analyses with an appropriate level of scientific scrutiny--and the results were deeply chilling. Aside from DNA analysis, not a single forensic practice held up to rigorous inspection.

Far from an infallible science, forensics is a decades-long experiment in which undertrained lab workers jettison the scientific method in favor of speedy results that fit prosecutors' hunches. No one knows exactly how many people have been wrongly imprisoned--or executed--due to flawed forensics. But the number, most experts agree, is horrifyingly high. A complete overhaul of our evidence analysis is desperately needed.

 
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 4, Interesting) by Anonymous Coward on Friday June 13 2014, @03:31PM

    by Anonymous Coward on Friday June 13 2014, @03:31PM (#55002)

    During trial prep for my sex offense case, the public defender hired a computer forensic examiner to look over my hard drive. Not only did the examiner make statements of opinion where he was only to be reporting on facts, but he reported and promptly dismissed multiple file time modifications (AOL IM buddy icons, System Restore change logs, Indexing Service files, and more) that proved the drive was tampered with after seizure as "an anomaly of the installation." They (at a minimum) booted the drive and had instant message conversations with people. This grossly taints the forensics and can render the evidence unusable in court, but the forensic examiner (obviously being tainted himself, as prosecutors regularly ask such examiners to help them "get this bad guy") did everything he could in his report to try to prevent such evidence from being useful to my attorney.

    Since I never actually got my day in court, I suppose we'll never know if that would have been taken into account.

    Starting Score:    0  points
    Moderation   +4  
       Interesting=4, Total=4
    Extra 'Interesting' Modifier   0  

    Total Score:   4  
  • (Score: 5, Insightful) by GreatAuntAnesthesia on Friday June 13 2014, @03:38PM

    by GreatAuntAnesthesia (3275) on Friday June 13 2014, @03:38PM (#55005) Journal

    Interesting.

    I read TFA but there was no mention of computer forensics, but it stands to reason that computer forensics would be on even shakier ground than the other kind. After all, most folk regard computers to be some kind of high wizardry, and will happily swallow whatever they are told by someone wearing the appropriate priestly robes.

  • (Score: 4, Insightful) by skullz on Friday June 13 2014, @03:39PM

    by skullz (2532) on Friday June 13 2014, @03:39PM (#55007)

    Well, if they didn't use a read-only cable or at least boot it up in read only mode and do all their "analysis" on an exact bit copy it was already tainted. What I've seen LEO's usually do is slap the original drive into an external HD case, plug that USB right on in and do their analysis under Windows with some COTS software. On a normally mounted NTFS partition. On Windows. NTFS ON WINDOWS, FOLKS. Might as well just boot it up and "hack" the Windows login.

    • (Score: 1) by linuxrocks123 on Saturday June 14 2014, @08:06AM

      by linuxrocks123 (2557) on Saturday June 14 2014, @08:06AM (#55239) Journal

      That's disturbing. I thought best practice in forensics cases was to bitcopy the drive while mounted read-only, store the original drive in an evidence locker, and do all forensics on the copy. What specific organizations are you aware of that do not use this standard?

  • (Score: 3, Insightful) by Alfred on Friday June 13 2014, @06:19PM

    by Alfred (4006) on Friday June 13 2014, @06:19PM (#55078) Journal

    The examiner was probably certain of your guilt and just looking for leads for his own "investigation." At the very least he did a geek squad grab all the media for later use.

  • (Score: 1) by linuxrocks123 on Saturday June 14 2014, @07:56AM

    by linuxrocks123 (2557) on Saturday June 14 2014, @07:56AM (#55235) Journal

    I hate it when posts like this are by AC. I'm not blaming you particularly, it's just really hard to know what to believe with posts like this. A competent examiner wouldn't have dismissed all that. An incompetent one I wouldn't expect to have even noticed. So I guess we're dealing with a malicious one? I don't know what to think.

    Why didn't you find a buddy who changed his buddy icon after the drive was seized? That would have proven tampering if the new buddy icon was on the drive.

    Of course, I'd be remiss if I didn't point out the solution here, as elsewhere, is full disk encryption. Only wholesale reformatting and planting of evidence could get around that. Of course, wholesale reformatting and planting of evidence could get around that, so I don't know. There's supposed to be a chain of custody, and everything I've heard before is the drive is imaged before being examined, to prevent tampering. It's difficult to know what to think when anonymous people on the Internet challenge what I've heard from other sources.

    • (Score: 1, Interesting) by Anonymous Coward on Saturday June 14 2014, @01:53PM

      by Anonymous Coward on Saturday June 14 2014, @01:53PM (#55295)

      I'm a sex offender and the last thing I want to do is perma-post "This Guy's Full Name is a felony sex offender!" all over the Internet, especially since I will eventually be eligible for removal from this useless paranoia-fueling government shit list.

      Regarding the buddy icon thing, it doesn't matter; AOL IM back in the early 2000s would only download a buddy icon from a buddy if there was a "conversation," as in someone sends one or more messages, the other buddy sends one or more messages, and the same someone sends yet another message. That triggers the "buddy icon download from the buddy" process *even if the buddy icon was already cached.* The fact that it happened about five months after the hard drive was taken away indicates someone booted my drive, used my saved password to get on my account, and talked to that particular buddy and said buddy talked back.

      The buddy's word isn't needed to prove this because that's just how the software does it. It ALWAYS downloads the icon. That's all the evidence one needs to challenge the forensics. There were a whole lot of other supremely fucked up things, one of which was the SBI agent flipping through the alleged child porn in front of me in a room in a big bound book they had made for the case...and I didn't see a single "child porn" image go by my eyes.

      I've learned a lot in the 14 or so years since all this and when I found out about the Kelly Hoose case I realized that a lot of kiddie porn possession cases could easily be bullshit. Kelly Hoose was charged with kiddie porn possession by the Feds for having company-watermarked pictures of "Melissa Ashley" from ALS Scan on his machine. ALS Scan had 18 USC 2257 records for her. She was something like 22 years old when she was photographed. It took him four years and having the actress flown in to testify herself to get the case dismissed. The same thing has happened with other young-looking porn stars such as "Little Lupe." Legal, watermarked, 2257-compliant images can be used to throw you in prison with a federal felony.

      I took a "sweet plea" and later learned that I made the best decision where there were no good decisions. Fuck me, right?

    • (Score: 1, Interesting) by Anonymous Coward on Saturday June 14 2014, @02:19PM

      by Anonymous Coward on Saturday June 14 2014, @02:19PM (#55297)

      As for the forensic examiner thing, an episode of Penn & Teller: Bullshit! covered the tainting of examiners by prosecutors (and the whole episode is really worth watching): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CmW3HzAyEB0 [youtube.com]