In a horrifying twist, the NSA may still be working on an artificial intelligence codenamed MonsterMind. Reminds me of the beast/666 computer rumors.
In a recent Wired interview Edward Snowden revealed among other things that the NSA was (and may still be) working on a project codenamed MonsterMind. The autonomous AI would monitor all data traffic entering the U.S. from anywhere in the world looking for potential cyber-attacks. It would then shut down the attack and could launch automated counter-attacks.
Of course, this would require analyzing all network traffic in order to design an algorithm that distinguishes normal traffic flow from malicious traffic.
And as Snowden told WIRED’s James Bamford, "That means violating the Fourth Amendment, seizing private communications without a warrant, without probable cause or even a suspicion of wrongdoing. For everyone, all the time."
(Score: 3, Insightful) by khallow on Monday August 18 2014, @09:01AM
Or some routers with a software bug.
So they will need to have considerable restraint built into the systems - especially given that most of the attacks won't be obvious both in who's doing it and that they actually are attacking.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Monday August 18 2014, @12:18PM
Or an error in MonsterMind itself, causing it to misinterpret a completely normal traffic spike.
(Score: 2) by khallow on Monday August 18 2014, @10:42PM
Or, I suppose, a completely imaginary event as well. And should MonsterMind ever get coopted by an attacker (which is a worry you don't really have with nuclear weapons unless you hook them up to SkyNet), then that could be an impressive mess since deliberately using such a system for the most destructive ends you can come up with probably is a lot worse than any accidents you could think up.
Basically, the problem is that any oversight is by its nature going to be top secret. They can't say what safeguards, if any, they have in place or what triggering threshold MonsterMind will have. The only indication that MonsterMind isn't working correctly will be when it goes off and attacks someone. Even then, we might not realize (outside of the minders of the Mind) that it was MonsterMind that did that damage.
Given the abusable access to internet traffic it will require (the NSA is basically pinky swearing that it'll only use that access for MonsterMind activities), that's another huge source of trouble that won't be readily obvious until it bites us years down the road.