Ian Bicking has confirmed that Mozilla has quietly shut down Mozilla Labs.
This development raises some interesting questions about the future of Mozilla and their products:
With Firefox's usage declining, with Firefox on Android seeing limited uptake, with Firefox not being available on iOS, with Thunderbird stagnating, with SeaMonkey remaining as irrelevant as ever, with Firefox OS suffering from poor reviews and little adoption, and now with a reduction in innovation due to the closure of Mozilla Labs, does Mozilla have any hope of remaining relevant as time goes on?
Will Mozilla be able to reignite the spark that originally allowed them to create products like Firefox and Thunderbird that were, at one time, wildly popular and innovative?
Is Mozilla still capable of innovating without Mozilla Labs, or will they slowly fade into irrelevance as the last remaining users of their products move on to other offerings from competitors?
(Score: 2, Insightful) by Anonymous Coward on Saturday September 20 2014, @01:23PM
How is Google eliminating Mozilla when it's pretty much only Google that's keeping Mozilla financially viable?
Google is throwing millions upon millions of dollars at Mozilla each year, yet Mozilla keeps squandering it on stupid shit like Firefox OS while at the same time alienating the few remaining Firefox and Thunderbird users who still remain.
It's mind-boggling to think that Google is somehow at fault here. They're doing more to enable competition than anyone else is.
(Score: 2) by kaszz on Saturday September 20 2014, @02:07PM
By reduction of finances?
(Score: 5, Insightful) by Horse With Stripes on Saturday September 20 2014, @02:16PM
If Mozilla's primary (or is it only now?) benefactor is Google then Mozilla should be doing more to get more financial support/sponsorship from other large companies. Mozilla needs to ask itself if "trying to compete directly with Google's Android hurt, or is hurting, our financial support from Google?"
Mozilla can't be, and shouldn't try to be, the whole enchilada. Not if they can't self finance. I realize they are selling advertising spots on the blank/new tab pages. Based on their weasel words they are intending to, or already are, selling user data. Neither of those solutions benefit the user, and both will drive away those who chose Firefox for FOSS or privacy reasons.
I don't pretend to know what Mozilla's business model should be, but trying to compete with your benefactors and driving away the very users whose information you plan to sell isn't it.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Saturday September 20 2014, @03:07PM
If Mozilla's primary (or is it only now?) benefactor is Google then Mozilla should be doing more to get more financial support/sponsorship from other large companies.
They are. [thenextweb.com]
People are not happy about it.
(Score: 2, Interesting) by Anonymous Coward on Saturday September 20 2014, @06:41PM
People are not happy because it's yet another really goddamn stupid idea from Mozilla.
Come on, some of the most popular Firefox extensions exist solely to block ads and tracking. How the hell could Mozilla possibly think that it would be a good idea to add in advertisements like that, when so many Firefox users obviously hate ads to begin with?
If Mozilla had straight-out asked me for money, and provided me some guarantees about how it would be used, I would gladly have considered contributing. I would have considered contributing to efforts to undo Australis, and to restore the Firefox 3.5-era UI. I would have considered contributing if they killed off Firefox OS, so the money wouldn't be wasted on that stupidity. But, no, they just go ahead and do one of the stupidest things they could possibly do. I'm done with them now.
(Score: 3, Insightful) by zafiro17 on Saturday September 20 2014, @09:13PM
I totally agree with the AC above. Was 'sponsored tiles' one of the genius ideas that came out of Mozilla's now-defunct lab? Or did they just rip it off of Opera (another browser in the throes of a change in management intent on destroying the few remaining users of my favorite browser)? Because sponsored tiles is a terrible idea. If they charged $20 for each major release, and listened to what users wanted, maybe they'd have some money. It wouldn't support the huge, bloated bureaucracy they've developed, but some of those extras would have to be sloughed off, and Mozilla would have to go back to being a small, technically-led project again. Not a bad thing - getting away from that culture is half of what led them to this.
I don't mind paying for software - I've bought lots of programs that were useful to me or that I wanted to support. But Mozilla is doing its best to piss me/us off. I'm glad they closed the Labs: it's not clear anything useful was coming out of it. Their recent 'innovations' have mostly worsened a product I liked.
Dad always thought laughter was the best medicine, which I guess is why several of us died of tuberculosis - Jack Handey
(Score: 1) by Ethanol-fueled on Sunday September 21 2014, @04:27AM
Mozilla made it big with FireFox only because Firefox was a faster and safer alternative to Internet Exploder. Seems they forgot their most important lesson, one which allowed them to rise to dominance in the first place. Kinda like Ubuntu.
(Score: 1, Informative) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday September 21 2014, @02:15PM
> If they charged $20 for each major release, and listened to what users wanted, maybe they'd have some money
Because that worked out sooo well for all those other browsers that tried to charge money up front.
Much more likely they would lose marketshare 10x faster than they have been and become a niche browser with barely even one percent of the users. And being a niche browser would make it impossible for them to fullfill their core mission of promoting openness on the web because without the clout of a being a big browser nobody else would listen to them. I don't want to see a world where Apple, Microsoft and Google are the only ones who have a say in how the web should work.
> I don't mind paying for software
Get your head out of your ass. You are not even close to the common case. Not. Even. Close.