Ian Bicking has confirmed that Mozilla has quietly shut down Mozilla Labs.
This development raises some interesting questions about the future of Mozilla and their products:
With Firefox's usage declining, with Firefox on Android seeing limited uptake, with Firefox not being available on iOS, with Thunderbird stagnating, with SeaMonkey remaining as irrelevant as ever, with Firefox OS suffering from poor reviews and little adoption, and now with a reduction in innovation due to the closure of Mozilla Labs, does Mozilla have any hope of remaining relevant as time goes on?
Will Mozilla be able to reignite the spark that originally allowed them to create products like Firefox and Thunderbird that were, at one time, wildly popular and innovative?
Is Mozilla still capable of innovating without Mozilla Labs, or will they slowly fade into irrelevance as the last remaining users of their products move on to other offerings from competitors?
(Score: 1) by drgibbon on Saturday September 20 2014, @08:28PM
<sarcasm>Yes! Don't forget it! I can't bear to use that old slow bloaty Mozilla Firefox! Opening a tab is like watching paint dry!</sarcasm> My goodness, it takes.. well ok, it doesn't take very long at all on any browser ;)
Certified Soylent Fresh!
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Saturday September 20 2014, @08:48PM
I still use an older laptop from time to time. I've got both Mozilla and Chrome installed on there, and the difference between the two is very noticeable. Opening a new tab in Firefox takes 3 to 5 seconds. Doing the same in Chrome takes much less than a second. I thought that was kind of weird, since Chrome uses separate processes and all that, while Firefox doesn't. Yet the difference is very obvious, and Chrome is a lot faster than Firefox is. Maybe it isn't as obvious on a faster computer, but it's very obvious on slower ones.
(Score: 1) by drgibbon on Saturday September 20 2014, @10:37PM
I know that Chrome/Chromium's interface feels faster [youtube.com]. If you're on a 486 and it really takes 5 seconds to open a tab, yeah sure, use whatever works. But on most people's computers, most of the time, there's hardly any difference.
Certified Soylent Fresh!
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday September 21 2014, @05:41AM
Cool, we'll all decide our browser choices based on the performance on your old laptop.
Sounds like a practical use case.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday September 21 2014, @12:33PM
You're obviously missing the point.
This fellow is proving that Firefox actually is slower than Chrome.
If on an older system it takes 5 seconds for Firefox to do something that takes Chrome 1 second, then it means on a faster computer it still takes Firefox 500 ms to do something that Chrome can do it 100 ms.
Just because it all happens faster on a modern computer, perhaps even fast enough that Firefox's slowness isn't immediately obvious, doesn't mean that Firefox is as fast as Chrome. It means that Firefox is still 5x slower than Chrome. On mobile devices like laptops and phones, this results in more battery usage. So it's still a serious problem.
(Score: 2) by Teckla on Sunday September 21 2014, @12:37PM
<sarcasm>Yes! Don't forget it! I can't bear to use that old slow bloaty Mozilla Firefox! Opening a tab is like watching paint dry! My goodness, it takes.. well ok, it doesn't take very long at all on any browser ;)
I use Firefox at work and Chrome at home (for various reasons). That is, I use both browsers heavily.
And I can assure you that Firefox regularly goes out to lunch, UI-wise (Not Responding). Firefox has UI issues, and I'm not talking about look and feel.
My guess is they need to prioritize moving to a multi-process model, like Chrome, so that the UI is never, ever unresponsive.
(Score: 1) by drgibbon on Sunday September 21 2014, @04:20PM
Yeah fair enough, I guess it doesn't work well for some people, but honestly I've had zero problems with Firefox's UI. That's on Mac, Windows, Linux; everything. Then again, I disable all plug-ins, don't install Flash, and although I do run a few add-ons (about 20) I have nothing weird that alters the UI.
Certified Soylent Fresh!
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday September 21 2014, @09:05PM
So you're clearly not a browser power user. Yeah, if you use only the smallest, most minimal functionality it offers then you are less likely to run into the sorts of problems that power users run into all of the time. That doesn't mean that the problems aren't there. They are, and they're very severe with Firefox these days.
(Score: 1) by drgibbon on Monday September 22 2014, @01:20AM
What is this "power user" you speak of? ;)
Certified Soylent Fresh!
(Score: 2) by urza9814 on Monday September 22 2014, @02:10PM
Funny. I just switched from Chrome to Firefox at work because Chrome has gotten into the habit of crashing any time I visit a site other than Soylent or Gmail. Literally anything. Click a link from my email? Crashed. Click a link to RTFA? Crashed. Click a Google search result? Crashed. Worst part is, it opens back up, restores the tabs...and immediately crashes again! Googled the symptoms and found a bunch of posts from people who never got it fixed.
Firefox's UI may be marginally less responsive but at least it works. Plus I find Chrome ironically sucks down more RAM on this system (and it's only got 2GB -- not much to spare!)
At home I use both though -- Chrome mostly for development, because my boss uses Safari so Chrome matches that better, plus the built-in debuggers are a bit nicer. Firefox I use for my daily browsing though. Much more stable, I often leave tabs open for weeks or months at a time, and I lose them far less often with Firefox. I really ought to just start using bookmarks though... :)