It's my understanding that the vote was taken by a small subcommittee that didn't rightfully have the power to make the decision, but doing it the right (legal? constitutional?) way would have taken over a year, and there was a push to release Jessie with systemd in place.
-- Javascript is what you use to allow unknown third parties to run software you have no idea about on your computer.
The TC has the "right" to make interpretations about technical standards.
99% of them are excruciatingly boring yet important. This decision is only interesting because everybody hates systemd but the paid astroturfers and the "desktop people".
Most of the decisions are like a recent-ish one along the lines of can a package in main "recommend" (or something like that) several packages, one of which is in non-free, while not getting kicked into the contrib ghetto for mentioning non-free but not depending on it.
Systemd was rammed down our unwilling throats as a "technical decision" which is kind of stretching the definition.
You are correct, in that its a non-dogfood eating desktop coup, which should have gone to vote.
(Score: 2) by HiThere on Saturday November 08 2014, @11:54PM
It's my understanding that the vote was taken by a small subcommittee that didn't rightfully have the power to make the decision, but doing it the right (legal? constitutional?) way would have taken over a year, and there was a push to release Jessie with systemd in place.
Javascript is what you use to allow unknown third parties to run software you have no idea about on your computer.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday November 09 2014, @04:53AM
If I didn't know you were talking about Debian, you pretty much summed up how the Pluto being demoted as a planet by the IAU "vote" went down.
(Score: 2) by VLM on Sunday November 09 2014, @12:34PM
The TC has the "right" to make interpretations about technical standards.
99% of them are excruciatingly boring yet important. This decision is only interesting because everybody hates systemd but the paid astroturfers and the "desktop people".
Most of the decisions are like a recent-ish one along the lines of can a package in main "recommend" (or something like that) several packages, one of which is in non-free, while not getting kicked into the contrib ghetto for mentioning non-free but not depending on it.
Systemd was rammed down our unwilling throats as a "technical decision" which is kind of stretching the definition.
You are correct, in that its a non-dogfood eating desktop coup, which should have gone to vote.