The Debian project has suffered from a long string of negative events recently, ranging from severe discontent over the inclusion of systemd, to talk of forking the project, to a grave bug affecting the important 'wine' package, to the resignation and reduced involvement of long time contributors.
The latest strife affecting Debian revolves around a request for a Debian package of the GPC-Slots 2 software. This request has been rejected with little more than an ad hominem attack against the software's author.
In response to the request, Stephen Gran wrote,
This is code by someone who routinely trolls Debian. I doubt we want any more poisonous upstreams in Debian, so I at least would prefer this never get packaged.
Jonathan Wiltshire proceeded to mark the request as 'wontfix', and closed it.
While Debian does strive to maintain high standards regarding the software it packages, the negative and personal nature of this rejection, without any apparent technical or licensing concerns, appears to conflict with Debian's own Code of Conduct. Such a personal attack could be seen as contradictory to the Code of Conduct's mandate that Debian participants "Be respectful", "Be collaborative", and most importantly, "Assume good faith".
Given its recent troubles as of late, many of them concerning the poor treatment of Debian developers and users alike, can Debian really afford to get embroiled in yet another negative incident?
(Score: 2) by moondrake on Sunday November 23 2014, @11:39PM
oh dear...you fell right into his trap by replying. He's probably the author if you had not figured...
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Sunday November 23 2014, @11:46PM
I'm seeing a lot of interesting discussion in this thread. It's a good back-and-forth exchange of ideas. And then you come along with your absurd conspiracy theories. Maybe you should just let people discuss this as they see fit. Nobody has fallen into a "trap" by discussing the incident the submission is about.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Monday November 24 2014, @07:00AM
And the trap is sprung!