Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by hubie on Thursday September 05 2024, @05:51AM   Printer-friendly

Study finds people are consistently and confidently wrong about those with opposing views:

Despite being highly confident that they can understand the minds of people with opposing viewpoints, the assumptions humans make about others are often wrong, according to new research from the Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience (IoPPN) at King's College London, in partnership with the University of Oxford.

"Poorer representation of minds underpins less accurate mental state inference for out-groups" was published in Scientific Reports. The research explores the psychology behind why people come to the wrong conclusions about others, and suggests how society could start to change that.

In all, 256 participants were recruited from the U.S. and split evenly between those with left- and right-leaning political views. They were presented with various political statements (e.g. Immigrants are beneficial to society) and asked to rate on a 5-point scale how much they agreed with it (i.e. strongly agree to strongly disagree).

For each statement, the participant would then be presented with someone else's response to the same statement. If the two shared a similar opinion, they were deemed "in-group" to one another. If the two held different opinions, they were deemed "out-group" to each other.

The participant was then asked to predict the other person's response on a second statement (e.g. all women should have access to legal abortion), and to state their confidence in their answer, from "Not at all' to "Extremely."

Participants could then choose to receive up to five more of the other person's responses to different statements to help the participant build up a better idea—or "representation"—of the other person's mind. After receiving any further information, participants could update their initial prediction and reclarify their confidence on their final answer.

Analysis of the data found that, even though participants were prepared to seek out as much—and often more—information about someone they disagreed with, their predictions were consistently incorrect, even after receiving further information about them.

Participants demonstrated a high degree of confidence in their answers, suggesting that participants thought they had a good understanding of the people in their out-group, despite this not being the case. In comparison, participants could consistently make accurate predictions about those in their in-group with less information.

"Our study shows that people have a good understanding of people who are similar to themselves and their confidence in their understanding is well-placed. However, our understanding of people with different views to our own is demonstrably poor. The more confident we are that we can understand them, the more likely it is that we are wrong. People have poor awareness of their inability to understand people that differ from themselves," says Dr. Bryony Payne.

[...] Dr. Caroline Catmur, Reader in Cognitive Psychology at King's IoPPN and the study's senior author, said, "We live in an increasingly polarized society and many people are very confident in their understanding of those who don't share their beliefs. However, our research shows that people are willing to reconsider once they are made aware of their mistakes.

"While there is no quick fix in a real-world setting, if everyone interacted with a more diverse group of people, talked directly to them and got to know them, it's likely we would understand each other better. Conversations with people who hold different beliefs could help challenge our incorrect assumptions about each other."

Journal Reference:
Payne, Bryony, Bird, Geoffrey, Catmur, Caroline. Poorer representation of minds underpins less accurate mental state inference for out-groups [open], Scientific Reports (DOI: 10.1038/s41598-024-67311-3)


Original Submission

 
This discussion was created by hubie (1068) for logged-in users only, but now has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 5, Insightful) by Rosco P. Coltrane on Thursday September 05 2024, @10:04AM (9 children)

    by Rosco P. Coltrane (4757) on Thursday September 05 2024, @10:04AM (#1371340)

    I learned that many years ago: I had just moved to Toronto, and at my new job, one of my new workmate - clearly of middle Eastern descent - was dressed in full Arabian regalia, with the white thawb and everything. I asked him where he was from:

    "Windsor, Ontario" he replied.
    "No I mean, where are you from?"
    "Well, Windsor, Ontario."
    "I mean, what country do you come from originally?"
    "Canada..."

    And then I realized, I subconsciously made assumptions about him solely based on his looks and my complete ignorance of the cosmopolitan nature of Toronto. The man and his family had been in Canada for several generations. It's just that it's totally okay to dress however your culture dictates in Toronto if that's your thing.

    And so my brain was working on completely incorrect premises and as a result, he didn't understand the true meaning of my question and I didn't understand the true meaning of his reply. It's the first time I felt utterly disconnected with reality despite my best efforts to be as open I could be: my brain instantly turned me into an involuntary racist. It was actually a bit scary.

    Anyway, it stuck with me and now I always double-check what I think I know before saying or concluding anything. But even knowing about my inevitable biases, I still regularly fall victim to them.

    Starting Score:    1  point
    Moderation   +3  
       Insightful=2, Interesting=1, Total=3
    Extra 'Insightful' Modifier   0  
    Karma-Bonus Modifier   +1  

    Total Score:   5  
  • (Score: 3, Insightful) by Gaaark on Thursday September 05 2024, @11:53AM

    by Gaaark (41) on Thursday September 05 2024, @11:53AM (#1371350) Journal

    At least you're intelligent enough to see your racial prejudice and try to change your thoughts. Too many people can't change.

    --
    --- Please remind me if I haven't been civil to you: I'm channeling MDC. I have always been here. ---Gaaark 2.0 --
  • (Score: 5, Funny) by JoeMerchant on Thursday September 05 2024, @12:26PM (3 children)

    by JoeMerchant (3937) on Thursday September 05 2024, @12:26PM (#1371358) Journal

    Correct question: what's your cultural background that leads you to dress funny?

    --
    🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
    • (Score: 3, Insightful) by HiThere on Thursday September 05 2024, @01:25PM

      by HiThere (866) on Thursday September 05 2024, @01:25PM (#1371365) Journal

      But that's not what he meant.

      --
      Javascript is what you use to allow unknown third parties to run software you have no idea about on your computer.
    • (Score: 3, Touché) by Thexalon on Thursday September 05 2024, @02:38PM (1 child)

      by Thexalon (636) on Thursday September 05 2024, @02:38PM (#1371379)

      Funny? What's funny about it?

      Arab dress is quite practical in very warm environments. On a hot sunny day, you'd probably be much happier in that outfit than in a coat and tie, plus no restricting blood flow to the brain

      --
      "Think of how stupid the average person is. Then realize half of 'em are stupider than that." - George Carlin
      • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Thursday September 05 2024, @07:33PM

        by JoeMerchant (3937) on Thursday September 05 2024, @07:33PM (#1371433) Journal

        Not funny "ha ha" but funny: small minority, not usually seen, unusual.

        Unusual can be cool, particularly when it's desert wear in Toronto.

        >tie ... restricting blood flow to the brain

        Yeah, I call that "funny, ha ha - self destructive conformity in the hopes of currying favor with other self-destructive conformists."

        --
        🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
  • (Score: 4, Insightful) by Weasley on Thursday September 05 2024, @02:44PM (3 children)

    by Weasley (6421) on Thursday September 05 2024, @02:44PM (#1371380)

    That's not racism. North America is primarily peopled by European immigrants, and his dress was obviously not of European origin. You asked a question because you wanted to know his cultural origin, but asked in way that you've been told is racist and insensitive by idiots who wish to divide up the electorate as racists and non-racists for political purposes. And so, in order to ask these questions we have to put out so many disclaimers to signal the appropriate virtue and avert the inevitable racist accusation, that it's almost not even worth discussing it. The reality is, your question wasn't racist, it would have worked better in the past because non-European immigration was more uncommon. Today, a much larger proportion of people who are visibly non-European are going to be native born so you just adjust the question. Maybe, where's your family from? What's your families cultural origin? Why do you dress funny? I don't know. Most of the people of the Americas descend (full or partially) from elsewhere. It's not racist to ask someone from where that is.

    • (Score: 2) by Whoever on Thursday September 05 2024, @06:48PM (2 children)

      by Whoever (4524) on Thursday September 05 2024, @06:48PM (#1371423) Journal

      That's not racism. North America is primarily peopled by European immigrants, and his dress was obviously not of European origin. You asked a question because you wanted to know his cultural origin, but asked in way that you've been told is racist and insensitive by idiots who wish to divide up the electorate as racists and non-racists for political purposes

      He saw the dress and other racial cues and assumed that the person was not born in Canada. He assumed something (which was wrong) about someone solely on the basis of their appearance. How is that not racist?

      This should make it clear that he was asking about more than ethic background:

      "I mean, what country do you come from originally?"

      • (Score: 5, Touché) by Mykl on Thursday September 05 2024, @11:26PM

        by Mykl (1112) on Thursday September 05 2024, @11:26PM (#1371463)

        Racism or broader discrimination isn't making inferences based on current observations and previous experience. Racism is treating people unfairly because of those assumptions.

        If I see someone standing on the street holding a map upside down and looking confused then I am going to assume they are a tourist and will ask them if they need assistance
        If I see a "person who presents as elderly" who is stooped over and appearing to have trouble with mobility then I am going to offer them my seat on the train
        If I see a person who is wearing a necklace with a religious symbol on it then I am going to assume they are somewhat religious (probably incorrectly sometimes!)

        Never assuming anything about anyone is a silly way to go about life and would waste so much time. Imagine living in an English speaking country and starting every single conversation with a stranger with "excuse me, do you speak English?"

      • (Score: 3, Insightful) by khallow on Friday September 06 2024, @01:44AM

        by khallow (3766) Subscriber Badge on Friday September 06 2024, @01:44AM (#1371477) Journal

        He saw the dress and other racial cues and assumed that the person was not born in Canada. He assumed something (which was wrong) about someone solely on the basis of their appearance. How is that not racist?

        What makes it racist? Appearance isn't race, right? With makeup and dress, most people can look like a wide range of ethnicities without actually being those ethnicities. So judging on appearance isn't enough to be racist - that is, discriminating on the basis of ethnicity.