Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 6 submissions in the queue.
posted by hubie on Thursday September 05 2024, @05:51AM   Printer-friendly

Study finds people are consistently and confidently wrong about those with opposing views:

Despite being highly confident that they can understand the minds of people with opposing viewpoints, the assumptions humans make about others are often wrong, according to new research from the Institute of Psychiatry, Psychology & Neuroscience (IoPPN) at King's College London, in partnership with the University of Oxford.

"Poorer representation of minds underpins less accurate mental state inference for out-groups" was published in Scientific Reports. The research explores the psychology behind why people come to the wrong conclusions about others, and suggests how society could start to change that.

In all, 256 participants were recruited from the U.S. and split evenly between those with left- and right-leaning political views. They were presented with various political statements (e.g. Immigrants are beneficial to society) and asked to rate on a 5-point scale how much they agreed with it (i.e. strongly agree to strongly disagree).

For each statement, the participant would then be presented with someone else's response to the same statement. If the two shared a similar opinion, they were deemed "in-group" to one another. If the two held different opinions, they were deemed "out-group" to each other.

The participant was then asked to predict the other person's response on a second statement (e.g. all women should have access to legal abortion), and to state their confidence in their answer, from "Not at all' to "Extremely."

Participants could then choose to receive up to five more of the other person's responses to different statements to help the participant build up a better idea—or "representation"—of the other person's mind. After receiving any further information, participants could update their initial prediction and reclarify their confidence on their final answer.

Analysis of the data found that, even though participants were prepared to seek out as much—and often more—information about someone they disagreed with, their predictions were consistently incorrect, even after receiving further information about them.

Participants demonstrated a high degree of confidence in their answers, suggesting that participants thought they had a good understanding of the people in their out-group, despite this not being the case. In comparison, participants could consistently make accurate predictions about those in their in-group with less information.

"Our study shows that people have a good understanding of people who are similar to themselves and their confidence in their understanding is well-placed. However, our understanding of people with different views to our own is demonstrably poor. The more confident we are that we can understand them, the more likely it is that we are wrong. People have poor awareness of their inability to understand people that differ from themselves," says Dr. Bryony Payne.

[...] Dr. Caroline Catmur, Reader in Cognitive Psychology at King's IoPPN and the study's senior author, said, "We live in an increasingly polarized society and many people are very confident in their understanding of those who don't share their beliefs. However, our research shows that people are willing to reconsider once they are made aware of their mistakes.

"While there is no quick fix in a real-world setting, if everyone interacted with a more diverse group of people, talked directly to them and got to know them, it's likely we would understand each other better. Conversations with people who hold different beliefs could help challenge our incorrect assumptions about each other."

Journal Reference:
Payne, Bryony, Bird, Geoffrey, Catmur, Caroline. Poorer representation of minds underpins less accurate mental state inference for out-groups [open], Scientific Reports (DOI: 10.1038/s41598-024-67311-3)


Original Submission

 
This discussion was created by hubie (1068) for logged-in users only, but now has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 1, Troll) by RedGreen on Thursday September 05 2024, @02:22PM (5 children)

    by RedGreen (888) on Thursday September 05 2024, @02:22PM (#1371373)

    More both sideism garbage these assholes use to justify the behavior of the racists, nazi, fascist right wing buddies. All in the name of supposedly giving both sides the benefit of the doubt. When I see the murdering right wing bastards express them views I am fully confident in my conclusion having observed these fucking scum gain more and more followers, for the last fifty years or more years since the last world war as they regroup, as they seek the power again to kill even more people with the garbage they spew. Yeah right people on the left are wrong in drawing these conclusion about them, tell that lie to someone who will believe it like a moron trump supporter.

    --
    "Cervantes definitely was prescient in describing a senile Don fighting against windmills." -- larryjoe on /.
    Starting Score:    1  point
    Moderation   0  
       Flamebait=1, Troll=2, Interesting=1, Funny=2, Total=6
    Extra 'Troll' Modifier   0  

    Total Score:   1  
  • (Score: -1, Troll) by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 05 2024, @03:00PM (3 children)

    by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 05 2024, @03:00PM (#1371384)

    That 'both sides' argument is more appropriate today than ever. You point at Trump and call him a moron, while assuming that neither Biden nor Harris are morons. You call the right racists, but refuse to acknowledge that Harris had racist policies while a prosecutor, and later as an AG, that literally enslaved young black men at disproportionate rates. Harris refused multiple court orders to free enslaved black labor, because the state she served was profiting from that enslavement.

    WTF don't we have more, and better choices than a racist wench trying to pass herself off as black, and an old has-been who is less racist than your candidate?

    • (Score: -1, Troll) by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 05 2024, @05:49PM

      by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 05 2024, @05:49PM (#1371404)

      Whossh....right over your head.

    • (Score: -1, Troll) by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 05 2024, @06:53PM

      by Anonymous Coward on Thursday September 05 2024, @06:53PM (#1371424)

      WTF don't we have more, and better choices than a racist wench trying to pass herself off as black, and an old has-been who is less racist than your candidate?

      maybe if shit like "tried to start an insurrection to keep himself on the throne" was an actual deal-breaker for a certain group of people...

    • (Score: 3, Insightful) by cmdrklarg on Thursday September 05 2024, @07:26PM

      by cmdrklarg (5048) Subscriber Badge on Thursday September 05 2024, @07:26PM (#1371431)

      "Both sides", uh huh. Keep right on handwaving away all the reprehensible shit that the "old has-been" has been doing his entire life, and then making shit up about the "wench" so that you can somehow make them equally bad. Cite your assertions or get lost.

      The Florida Orange Man may be an ignorant narcissistic asshole con man, but he ain't a "moron". He's smart enough to convince a bunch of credulous fools that's he's one of them and that he cares about them beyond getting their money and votes.

      Biden's not a "moron"; he's an old fart with a stutter. Harris is clearly not a "moron".

      WTF don't we have more, and better choices than a racist wench trying to pass herself off as black, and an old has-been who is less racist than your candidate?

      First of all: Harris is black (as well as South Asian). She doesn't need to "pass herself off". Second of all: your assertion of her being more racist than the Florida Orange Man has zero merit, and shall be summarily dismissed. Your dishonest attempt to somehow equate the two is laughable.

      Good day, sir.

      --
      The world is full of kings and queens who blind your eyes and steal your dreams.
  • (Score: 2, Touché) by khallow on Thursday September 05 2024, @11:53PM

    by khallow (3766) Subscriber Badge on Thursday September 05 2024, @11:53PM (#1371467) Journal

    More both sideism garbage these assholes use to justify the behavior of the racists, nazi, fascist right wing buddies.

    That's the most parsimonious solution here. Find the right label for the out-group and you never have to understand them at all.

    When I see the murdering right wing bastards express them views

    So... does that mean that they've murdered someone?