Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by LaminatorX on Thursday March 13 2014, @12:53AM   Printer-friendly
from the better-living-through-solopsism dept.

Papas Fritas writes:

Michael Schulson writes that if you want to write about spiritually-motivated pseudoscience in America, you can drive hundreds of miles to the Creation Museum in Kentucky but that America's greatest shrine to pseudoscience, the Whole Foods Market, is only a 15-minute trip away from most American urbanites. For example the homeopathy section at Whole Foods has plenty of Latin words and mathematical terms, but many of its remedies are so diluted that, statistically speaking, they may not contain a single molecule of the substance they purport to deliver.

"You can buy chocolate with "a meld of rich goji berries and ashwagandha root to strengthen your immune system," and bottles of ChlorOxygen chlorophyll concentrate, which "builds better blood." There's cereal with the kind of ingredients that are "made in a kitchen-not in a lab," and tea designed to heal the human heart," writes Schulson. "Nearby are eight full shelves of probiotics-live bacteria intended to improve general health. I invited a biologist friend who studies human gut bacteria to come take a look with me. She read the healing claims printed on a handful of bottles and frowned. "This is bullshit," she said, and went off to buy some vegetables."

According to Schulson the total lack of outrage over Whole Foods' existence, and by the total saturation of outrage over the Creation Museum, makes it clear that strict scientific accuracy in the public sphere isn't quite as important to many of us as we might believe. "The moral is not that we should all boycott Whole Foods. It's that whenever we talk about science and society, it helps to keep two rather humbling premises in mind: very few of us are anywhere near rational. And pretty much all of us are hypocrites."

 
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 2, Interesting) by deego on Thursday March 13 2014, @06:27AM

    by deego (628) on Thursday March 13 2014, @06:27AM (#15740)

    >> I'm amazed that in civilized countries 'homoeopathic' remedies are legal. Shouldn't you need to have real science or at least a double-blind study or two before you can make *any* claims? Normally I'm not against extracting money from the gullible, but once public health money comes into the equation I get more interested.

    I am amazed that in civilized countries, do-gooders still try to dictate what others can and cannot do with their own bodies.

    Starting Score:    1  point
    Moderation   +1  
       Interesting=1, Total=1
    Extra 'Interesting' Modifier   0  

    Total Score:   2  
  • (Score: 5, Insightful) by pe1rxq on Thursday March 13 2014, @10:32AM

    by pe1rxq (844) on Thursday March 13 2014, @10:32AM (#15791) Homepage

    I don't want to prevent anyone from gulping down homeopathic shit...

    I do want to protect them from doing it because they were being lied to.

    In a civilized country lying about its effects should be illegal.
    You want to sell water? Fine, just don't claim it is magical because you diluted and shaked something.

    • (Score: 2) by Grishnakh on Thursday March 13 2014, @01:57PM

      by Grishnakh (2831) on Thursday March 13 2014, @01:57PM (#15859)

      If you go that route, then you have to ban religions too, because there's no way to prove that it's real. That's not going to go over very well, since every "civilized country" not only has a large contingent of religious citizens, they all purport to support freedom of religion (for the most part; some have banned obvious scams like Scientology).

      • (Score: 2) by metamonkey on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:11PM

        by metamonkey (3174) on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:11PM (#15871)

        No, religions would just need appropriate warning labels. "Warning: Adherence to this faith may or may not result in eternal salvation." Well, we'd need those labels for every religion except mine, of course.

        --
        Okay 3, 2, 1, let's jam.
      • (Score: 1) by SleazyRidr on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:44PM

        by SleazyRidr (882) on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:44PM (#15891)

        I'll bear that in mind next time I pick up a bottle of Islam from Whole Foods.

    • (Score: 2) by bucc5062 on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:37PM

      by bucc5062 (699) on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:37PM (#15885)

      Oh please, your comment is insightful?

      In the civilized country of the US of A companies lie *all the time* and seem to do it legally so please don't try to compare our wondrous first world morality to some third world and say it is better.

      Homeopathy is not shit, it is respected by the medical community, it is regulated by the FDA, and it has shown to be a viable alternative to manufactured chemicals that at times can do more harm to the body the some natural ingredient. Have you heard of Willow Bark. A natural pain reliever that is as effective, though slower in action then aspirin and less harmful to the stomach.

      As to your water example, A couple of years ago some company told the US market that they infused their water with extra oxygen to help make you feel better. A bold face lie that people bought in the millions; in a civilized country non the less. Now that is shit from a male cow.

      --
      The more things change, the more they look the same
      • (Score: 1) by pe1rxq on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:47PM

        by pe1rxq (844) on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:47PM (#15896) Homepage

        Homeopathy is NOT respected by the medical community. Just stop spreading nonsense.

        It is NOT a viable alternative to anything.

        And yes, I have heard of willow bark, I do know a little bit about the history of aspirin and it has NOTHING to do with homeopathy.

        And the guys selling 'oxygen' water are just as guilty as the homeopaths and both should be made accountable. All quackery should be threated equal.

        • (Score: 2) by bucc5062 on Thursday March 13 2014, @03:33PM

          by bucc5062 (699) on Thursday March 13 2014, @03:33PM (#15914)

          So I will walk a line here. I had been confused between what I understood to be homeopathy and what it is defined as by most articles (and their own text). I was defending the use of natural elements in caring for medical issues, not homeopathy its self. So in that regard I was incorrect in my thoughts.

          I still find your statement about "civilized countries" to be disingenuous and it did not enhance your viewpoint. Of course all quackery should have the light of day put upon it, but you made a position like civilized countries don't have quacks (that is how it read). I'm not moderating, but I did not see you point as insightful mainly because of that one statement. Since they all lie, there is no real "civilized" country on this planet. Only those that try to lie less in the interest of their population. Currently my country is looking less and less civilized then some others so homeopathy seems to fit in right along with "we're not spying on you" or "trust your money with us".

          --
          The more things change, the more they look the same
          • (Score: 2) by pe1rxq on Thursday March 13 2014, @04:43PM

            by pe1rxq (844) on Thursday March 13 2014, @04:43PM (#15967) Homepage

            Ah, that makes sense. Although it doesn't suprise me much, it is very easy to get confused what exactly the quackers are peddling, and that is the way they like it.

            I have no problems with using 'natural elements', as long as it is evidence based.
            There is a lot of evidence for e.g. willow bark. So much evidence that it led to the development of aspirin.
            For both there is a lot of evidence and with this evidence you can choose which one works best in your current situation.
            If your stomach is sensitive use one, do you need something really potent and pure, use the other.

            And my personal definition of a civilized country indeed is a bit of an utopia...

  • (Score: 1) by SleazyRidr on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:46PM

    by SleazyRidr (882) on Thursday March 13 2014, @02:46PM (#15895)

    I don't want to dictate what people can put into their own bodies. I do want to dictate what you can sell someone as "medicine" and more importantly what the health system spends its money on. I like the fact that some of my money is going to help people that need it. I don't like the fact that some of it is enriching these scammers.