Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 6 submissions in the queue.
posted by jelizondo on Thursday July 23, @01:56AM   Printer-friendly
from the free-as-in-freedom dept.

The Free Software Foundation has a well-written overview of how the superset to Free Software, referred to collectively as Open Source, cannot save us from loss of liberty in the context of computing. A lead-in using conventional rhetoric is followed by a concise conclusion using logic.

The FSF and the OSI both spend their days talking about licenses, which makes them easy to mix up. Follow the money instead. The OSI runs on corporate sponsorship, and its sponsors are some of the largest companies on earth. The FSF runs on membership dues from individuals.

FSF est. 1983
• Campaigns for the freedom of computer users. That's the whole mission statement.
• Wrote the GPL, "designed specifically to protect freedom for all users of a program," and defends it.
• No corporate members. Funded by individual dues and limited donations that buy no vote and no seat.
• Says "freedom" in meetings, unprompted, since 1983.

OSI est. 1998
• Approves licenses. (§05 covers the quality control.)
• Maintains a definition that never grants you the right to run the program. (§04.)
• Founded to make free software palatable to business, with the ethics filed off.
• Corporate sponsors include: Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Meta, Cisco, Salesforce, Bloomberg, Intel. The famous grassroots.

Microsoft and Google do not sponsor things out of sentiment. Money at that scale steers, whatever the org chart says. The FSF is structurally incapable of being bought the same way: there is no corporate membership to buy. A company can donate, within limits, and what the donation purchases is nothing. One of these organizations exists to defend you from corporations. The other one sends corporations a welcome basket.

And when a license is actually violated, only one of them shows up. The FSF runs a licensing and compliance lab, answers license questions for free, and holds the copyrights that make enforcement possible. When Cisco shipped GPL code in Linksys routers without offering source, the FSF took them to federal court in 2008 and settled on its terms: source code published, a free-software compliance officer appointed, money paid. GPL violators can expect a courtroom. The OSI offers nothing comparable. It holds no copyrights, runs no compliance program, and has never enforced a license in its life; it stamps them and walks away. If anything, the institution leans the other way: its co-founder spent years arguing that open source "doesn't need the GPL anymore." Certifying dozens of alternatives to copyleft while defending none of them is not neutrality. It is a way of hobbling the one license built to fight back.

[...] Since F⊆OF⊆O is true and O⊆FO⊆F is false, by definition FF is a proper subset of OO:
F⊆O  ∧  F≠O

Even from the big launch of the term Open Source in 1998, the idea was only ever meant as a stepping stone to lead developers fully over to Free Software. Unfortunately some have gotten stuck along the way. And in the direction of software freedom, it is important to remember that software freedom is not the end goal in and of itself, it is merely the start of and prerequisite to greater things which only become possible from that foundation.

Previously:
(2025) Forty Years of Commitment to Software Freedom
(2024) Achieving Software Freedom in the Age of Platform Decay
(2023) The Four Freedoms and The One Obligation of Free Software
(2022) Conflicts of Interest in OSI Election
(2019) Has FOSS Traded its Shared Values for Success in the Marketplace?
... and many more.


Original Submission

 
This discussion was created by jelizondo (653) for logged-in users only, but now has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 5, Insightful) by pTamok on Thursday July 23, @09:34AM (6 children)

    by pTamok (3042) on Thursday July 23, @09:34AM (#1449072)

    There is an English saying: "Knowing the price of everything and the value of nothing."

    People who cannot tell the difference between price and value do not understand the saying, and regard it as senseless, and the attempted distinction as meaningless.

    Sic transit gloria mundi.

    Starting Score:    1  point
    Moderation   +4  
       Insightful=3, Touché=1, Total=4
    Extra 'Insightful' Modifier   0  

    Total Score:   5  
  • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Thursday July 23, @04:29PM (5 children)

    by JoeMerchant (3937) on Thursday July 23, @04:29PM (#1449099) Journal

    There is wonderful value of software "trapped in the commons" value that I benefit from every day.

    Unfortunately, it's not value that I can easily turn into food and shelter, so while I get what value I can from GPL/FOSS - I also need to get paid, and that happens under other licensing structures for me.

    --
    🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
    • (Score: 1) by pTamok on Thursday July 23, @05:44PM (2 children)

      by pTamok (3042) on Thursday July 23, @05:44PM (#1449113)

      I appreciate the problem.

      In principle, if you didn't need to get paid, the problem disappears: which is the theory behind socialism, that is to say "To each according to their needs, from each according to their abilities." Or an adequate UBI that removed the baseline driver for food and shelter.

      We live on a planet that has sufficient resources to provide an adequate quality of life for the human population, but those resources are distributed in highly unequal modes. The trouble is, no-one has come up with a better distribution system in practice than the 'free market', with all its inequalities. Planned economies simply don't work.

      • (Score: 4, Interesting) by JoeMerchant on Thursday July 23, @06:45PM (1 child)

        by JoeMerchant (3937) on Thursday July 23, @06:45PM (#1449121) Journal

        >Planned economies simply don't work.

        The problem with planned economies is: lack of benevolent selfless egalitarianism, not to mention diverse values, among the planners.

        The free market distributes decision making, but gives a per-dollar weight, and too many people are too free with their surplus dollars pursuing goals that are ultimitately detrimental for most people, not to mention meta-problems like people who mostly use their dollars to manipulate financial systems to get themselves more dollars.... The economy may be abundant, but our resource pool is finite and as our numbers continue to climb that finite resource pool is going to become more and more constraining.

        Modern communication and data processing technologies have radically altered what is possible in terms of transparency, democracy, decision making, distribution of resources and labor... but the old ways are slow to relinquish their hold on the power structures, quick to seize the new technologies in support of their own selfish aims, etc...

        With a global population of 8 billion, but a Dunbar number of 200 or less, people need to organize better so that they have more insight into what affects them and more of a voice in the decisions that affect themselves.

        Ideally, a "local group" might consist of 100 people, at most, who elect representatives into the next layer of decision making - maybe four representatives from the group (for continuity and responsibility sharing / division) who represent into the "first level of decision making" - that group of 100 people then represents 2500 people, and again, from within that group, 4 more people are elected to the next level up - 100 more people who then collectively represent 25 groups of 2500 people - 62500 people represented in the group of 100 people who discuss matters pertaining to the group of groups. And again, 4 from them up to the next layer, bringing 25 groups of 625000 together -> 1,562,500 @ 3, like a large city -> 39,062,500 @ 4, like a large state -> 976,562,500 @ 5, like the largest of countries, and 9 of those level 5 groups would cover the entire human population today, sending 36 representatives in total to the level 6 "top" decision making tier for global issues.

        Looking from the "top down" these level 6 representatives would be focused mostly on global level issues, while the 9 level 5 groups of 100 representatives will "lose" 4 of their members to the higher level issues, leaving 96 to actively decide the "level 5" issues, and so on down the layers, but each representative at their own level, could not only maintain some semblence of a "within their Dunbar number" social understanding and relationship with each and every member of their peers, they can also do the same with the group that elected them to represent at the next level. It would be more challenging, but not impossible, for even the highest level representatives to maintain meaningful dialogue and understanding with everyone from their small local neighborhood of 100 who first elected them to the small HOA level of representation, all the way up through their highest level of representation.

        Based on my limited experience with "small group" elections, I would think a 6 month term would be appropriate at the "grassroots" level, with eligibility for re-election up to 5 years unless promoted to higher levels. When elected to the "next level up" the term might double to a year, with a reprieve from the lower level election(s) while advanced - again with a maximum term of 5 years' total service time at that level unless promoted. Level 3 might run 2 years, level 4 might run 4 years, level 5 for 6 years, and level 6 for 8 years, with elections staggered such that 1/8th of the highest level office holders are up for (a maximum of 2) re-elections every year.

        Through modern communication technology, people could (though probably still won't) actively evaluate their choices for each election... of the 100 candidates, maybe only 25 (one from each lower level) are eligible to run for the current cycle - that's a big field, but not overwhelming, and it gives opprotunity for nuance that's missed in a 2 party 1 platform system.

        --
        🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
        • (Score: 1) by pTamok on Thursday July 23, @08:46PM

          by pTamok (3042) on Thursday July 23, @08:46PM (#1449128)

          Thank you for sharing your thinking.

    • (Score: 4, Interesting) by Thexalon on Friday July 24, @03:54AM (1 child)

      by Thexalon (636) on Friday July 24, @03:54AM (#1449183)

      So the Free Software types do have an answer to the "how do you get paid" problem: They point out that most professional developers make their living customizing stuff to match the needs of a particular business. So, for example, I don't need to build a database engine, I need to make sure that a particular company maintains its financial transaction records correctly, and a database engine would sure be useful for that, so I'm not really losing anything I would have been paid to build by grabbing a copy of Postgres or Mongo rather than paying somebody for a proprietary engine. Or maybe I'm building a website, and while an existing free software framework provides a good start, the money is in hooking the web front end into the 3 other tools they want to integrate with, and updating the look-and-feel to match with the company branding, and adding that weird feature that Marsha from marketing can't shut up about.

      How does the Free Software package get improved, then? Let's assume you have a package with a bug that's causing a problem for you, or is lacking the feature that would make it really useful. You have 3 options:
      1. Make your in-house developers do the work to fix or build it.
      2. Pay for somebody else to fix or build it.
      3. Switch back to the proprietary version and pay licensing fees forever.
      There's a decent chance that 1 or 2 are cheaper than 3 over the course of a long-enough time period.

      --
      "Think of how stupid the average person is. Then realize half of 'em are stupider than that." - George Carlin
      • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Friday July 24, @12:14PM

        by JoeMerchant (3937) on Friday July 24, @12:14PM (#1449218) Journal

        >There's a decent chance that 1 or 2 are cheaper than 3 over the course of a long-enough time period.

        And, from 2006 to 2026, I won that argument - professionally.

        We have a new project, and it's drifting back significantly further under the M$ cloud. My takehome pay, however, is higher than ever.

        --
        🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]