Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 6 submissions in the queue.
posted by jelizondo on Thursday July 23, @01:56AM   Printer-friendly
from the free-as-in-freedom dept.

The Free Software Foundation has a well-written overview of how the superset to Free Software, referred to collectively as Open Source, cannot save us from loss of liberty in the context of computing. A lead-in using conventional rhetoric is followed by a concise conclusion using logic.

The FSF and the OSI both spend their days talking about licenses, which makes them easy to mix up. Follow the money instead. The OSI runs on corporate sponsorship, and its sponsors are some of the largest companies on earth. The FSF runs on membership dues from individuals.

FSF est. 1983
• Campaigns for the freedom of computer users. That's the whole mission statement.
• Wrote the GPL, "designed specifically to protect freedom for all users of a program," and defends it.
• No corporate members. Funded by individual dues and limited donations that buy no vote and no seat.
• Says "freedom" in meetings, unprompted, since 1983.

OSI est. 1998
• Approves licenses. (§05 covers the quality control.)
• Maintains a definition that never grants you the right to run the program. (§04.)
• Founded to make free software palatable to business, with the ethics filed off.
• Corporate sponsors include: Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Meta, Cisco, Salesforce, Bloomberg, Intel. The famous grassroots.

Microsoft and Google do not sponsor things out of sentiment. Money at that scale steers, whatever the org chart says. The FSF is structurally incapable of being bought the same way: there is no corporate membership to buy. A company can donate, within limits, and what the donation purchases is nothing. One of these organizations exists to defend you from corporations. The other one sends corporations a welcome basket.

And when a license is actually violated, only one of them shows up. The FSF runs a licensing and compliance lab, answers license questions for free, and holds the copyrights that make enforcement possible. When Cisco shipped GPL code in Linksys routers without offering source, the FSF took them to federal court in 2008 and settled on its terms: source code published, a free-software compliance officer appointed, money paid. GPL violators can expect a courtroom. The OSI offers nothing comparable. It holds no copyrights, runs no compliance program, and has never enforced a license in its life; it stamps them and walks away. If anything, the institution leans the other way: its co-founder spent years arguing that open source "doesn't need the GPL anymore." Certifying dozens of alternatives to copyleft while defending none of them is not neutrality. It is a way of hobbling the one license built to fight back.

[...] Since F⊆OF⊆O is true and O⊆FO⊆F is false, by definition FF is a proper subset of OO:
F⊆O  ∧  F≠O

Even from the big launch of the term Open Source in 1998, the idea was only ever meant as a stepping stone to lead developers fully over to Free Software. Unfortunately some have gotten stuck along the way. And in the direction of software freedom, it is important to remember that software freedom is not the end goal in and of itself, it is merely the start of and prerequisite to greater things which only become possible from that foundation.

Previously:
(2025) Forty Years of Commitment to Software Freedom
(2024) Achieving Software Freedom in the Age of Platform Decay
(2023) The Four Freedoms and The One Obligation of Free Software
(2022) Conflicts of Interest in OSI Election
(2019) Has FOSS Traded its Shared Values for Success in the Marketplace?
... and many more.


Original Submission

 
This discussion was created by jelizondo (653) for logged-in users only, but now has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 2) by Bentonite on Friday July 24, @07:07AM (6 children)

    by Bentonite (56146) on Friday July 24, @07:07AM (#1449194)

    You're not being honest - there are plenty of jobs that will provide food and shelter that don't have anything to do with software.

    But it is true that for a limited number of companies, proprietary software is sometimes a way to get immense profit out of comparatively little work, just like how beating people up in the street and stealing their wallets, can net high profits (but the latter has much lower profits and you'll soon enough be arrested and appropriately punished for doing so, unlike the former, where the government comes along and does their best to make the citizens they're meant to be serving, empty their wallets at the company).

    As far as I can tell, that software you wrote back in 1997 was proprietary software, due to being published under proprietary terms (distributing exact copies allowed, but no modifications allowed, practically and legally I expect), but it's okay that such specific proprietary program didn't make you a fortune?

    I think you need to actually read the LGPLv2.1 and LGPLv3 - the requirements are mostly the same as the GPLv2 and GPLv3, it's just that there's an added exception to allow using the library in a proprietary program, as long as the library itself remains free.

    I am quite glad that such freedom "pisses off" the enemies of humanity - I'll license AGPLv3-or-later harder and enforce GNU licenses harder too.

    Starting Score:    1  point
    Karma-Bonus Modifier   +1  

    Total Score:   2  
  • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Friday July 24, @12:21PM (5 children)

    by JoeMerchant (3937) on Friday July 24, @12:21PM (#1449220) Journal

    >You're not being honest - there are plenty of jobs that will provide food and shelter that don't have anything to do with software.

    So, then, after spending 3 months out of work looking for my initial job out of University, I was supposed to pass over the one that involved software, because it was "the wrong kind of software"? In 1991?

    Then, after "the right kind of software" became available, I was supposed to forsake all employment that used "the wrong kind of software" - and take significant pay cuts and loss of benefits like health insurance, as well as spend longer searching for work to feed now not only myself but my family?

    As I just noted elsewhere, from 2006 through about 2019 I made significant strides steering my employers to use FOSS - to their financial benefit. However, only about 40% of my colleagues followed my lead and our most recent "product refresh" is taking a huge turn back to the M$ camp. I, and my FOSS acolytes, still get our paychecks - but if we're going to continue to be "team players" we're going to be doing a lot more under the M$ umbrella for the coming years.

    >I'll license AGPLv3-or-later harder and enforce GNU licenses harder too.

    I hope it brings you great joy and satisfaction in your life. I, personally, find none in fighting legal battles.

    --
    🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
    • (Score: 2) by Bentonite on Friday July 24, @02:38PM (4 children)

      by Bentonite (56146) on Friday July 24, @02:38PM (#1449233)

      It an incredibly ludicrous claim, that in spending 3 months looking for a job in 1991, you could only find a job writing proprietary software (considering that very few of such jobs has ever been available) - you were clearly seeking out such specific job for 3 months (clearly anyone who cares about making a lot of money, with moderate work, would be seeking out a spot in that sweet wallet theft ring) and after 3 months you found one.

      Considering that 99% of available jobs, do not consist of writing proprietary software and many employers that are not proprietary software companies, do offer health insurance (the USA is totally braindead in that health insurance from the employer is a thing, considering that that the US government puts enough money into the medical system to cover treatment costs of all current patients, but of course businesses instead steal the money, instead of delivering the treatments they were paid to deliver), it is clearly ludicrous to claim that your choice was between writing proprietary software and "significant pay cuts", "loss of benefits like health insurance" and "not being able to feed yourself and your family".

      This whole song and dance always frames it as being a matter of not being able to afford to eat, when it's a matter of otherwise not being able to easily afford a McMansion.

      I'm not surprised that it took 13 years of advice, for the company to make (some) competent business and financial decisions, but m$ is of course handcuffing themselves back on, via their unpaid agents and will send the business bankrupt in a decade or so (now if only m$ goes bankrupt too).

      • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Friday July 24, @03:52PM (3 children)

        by JoeMerchant (3937) on Friday July 24, @03:52PM (#1449241) Journal

        >It an incredibly ludicrous claim, that in spending 3 months looking for a job in 1991, you could only find a job writing proprietary software

        I categoically reject your assessment of the situation. Job searches were conducted in person, through snail mail letters (100 of which were sent, 95 of which were ignored - 2 offers to work in Nuclear power, no thank you, and an offer to spend another 3 years in Academia at 50% of market rate compensation, again no thank you.) First company I drove to had been shut down by the FDA two weeks prior to my visit, this wasn't in the news, this wasn't common knowledge, I learned of the situation by arriving in an empty parking lot and seeing chains and padlocks on the glass doors with no lights on inside. Three interviews a week was my average during those three months, most were cold calls. I did, actually, get an offer to work as a SCUBA diver counting brittle stars in the Florida Keys, but there the compensation was even more meager than the University - neither of which would have enabled me to pay for things like my own car insurance without cutting down on food expenses below my already frugal budget.

        So, sure, I had options: glow in the dark, slowly starve and be unable to afford to maintain my car, skin cancer from 8 hours a day of direct sun exposure, or continue searching for another 3 months on the chance that something better might come along - my savings was running out, I could have moved back in with Mom's new husband in the cats' bedroom, but she lived in a city with even fewer job prospects than the one I was in. And, can you even put your head in 1991? FOSS was barely a blip on the awareness of software engineers at the time.

        > the USA is totally braindead in that health insurance from the employer is a thing

        Oh, now the proposition is that I, a 22 year old with zero working experience, apply for an international work visa?

        > and will send the business bankrupt in a decade or so (now if only m$ goes bankrupt too).

        Highly unlikely, as the business has a USD 100 billion market cap and my little corner of it is only responsible for maybe 100 million of annual revenue tied to roughly 1000 Windows licenses sold per year. While Microsoft may stumble I do believe their political influence puts them in "too big to fail in my lifetime" territory.

        >when it's a matter of otherwise not being able to easily afford a McMansion.

        My McMansion after graduation with my Master's degree was an efficiency apartment, a luxurious 20 square meters rented from what I later found out was a family whose father was convicted of fencing stolen cars through his pawn shop. It was close to the University and 20% less expensive than anything else avaialble when our previous landlord kicked us out with 30 days' notice in the middle of the fall term (the neighbor's construction project wrapped up and apparently she was only renting the house to us while the noise next door was truly obnoxious.) I did pursue "the American Dream" which is not as easily attainable in most of the rest of the free healthcare world, and I purchased my McMansion after just under 2 years of having a "real job" in "evil proprietary software creation." That McMansion was 60 years old, 2 bed 1 bath 110 square meters. Ten years later, married with one child, we did "upgrade" to a bigger 3 bed 2 bath 150 square meter McMansion, which was quite a financial strain - so much so that when that first evil proprietary software employer had to lay off the entire staff, I spent the next 4 months looking for work and eventually had to move 1900km to support our lavish lifestyle with a 2nd baby on the way in our late 30s.

        Take your idealism and smoke it, I'm sure it will bring you great pleasure.

        --
        🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
        • (Score: 2) by Bentonite on Saturday July 25, @04:28AM (2 children)

          by Bentonite (56146) on Saturday July 25, @04:28AM (#1449308)

          2 offers to work in Nuclear power, no thank you

          So, prior to finding the convenient job, you did in fact have not one, but two prior reasonable offers to work in an extremely safe job, with acceptable terms, but you didn't accept either as you were worried about that scary nuclear radiation?

          As far as I can tell, you could have worked in that job for a few years, delivering clean and green power (likely lowering your chances of death from cancer) and then proceeded to find a better job, before the low, but higher than background, radiation exposure, marginally increased your cancer risk (it's hard to get a job if you're unemployed, but if you already have a job, then it's easy to get a job?).

          skin cancer from 8 hours a day of direct sun exposure

          While that job was clearly a bad offer, it isn't too difficult to ensure that you don't get skin cancer with only 8 hours a day sun exposure.

          And, can you even put your head in 1991? FOSS was barely a blip on the awareness of software engineers at the time.

          I didn't write anything about that - but considering 1991, the concept of "FOSS" didn't exist (some might have buzzworded that word, saying many words to mean nothing - but it seems that didn't happen until at least 1995) - while the GNU and the concept of free software did exist and custom software was certainly most software - but that is not relevant to the topic.

          Oh, now the proposition is that I, a 22 year old with zero working experience, apply for an international work visa?

          Please do not assume things that I did not write - I only mean what I write and nothing more.

          Pointing out how something is broken in the USA, does not imply that I propositioned leaving the country.

          Highly unlikely, as the business has a USD 100 billion market cap .. I do believe their political influence puts them in "too big to fail in my lifetime" territory.

          You underestimate the ability of CEO's and m$ to send businesses bankrupt, no matter how big, even with government interference - it's the core goal of proprietary software companies to send each other bankrupt - there's a reason there are https://companiesmarketcap.com/software/largest-software-companies-by-market-cap/

          purchased my McMansion after just under 2 years

          So you did indeed get enough money to purchase a (old but likely fine) house in under 2 years? You don't get paid that much for doing good.

          first evil proprietary software employer had to lay off the entire staff

          Your first employer was so incompetent at such a high margin business, that they effectively went bankrupt and had to lay off the entire staff and you needed to look for 4 months and move 1900km to find another proprietary software employer that hadn't gone bankrupt yet? Damn.

          The moral of this story is, even if all you care about is money, employment writing proprietary software, that nets the employer huge profits, is unlikely to get you much of that money, or even land you a secure job.

          • (Score: 3, Interesting) by Bentonite on Saturday July 25, @04:31AM

            by Bentonite (56146) on Saturday July 25, @04:31AM (#1449309)

            *there's a reason there are under 1000 proprietary software companies in the whole world and that number is set to shrink; https://companiesmarketcap.com/software/largest-software-companies-by-market-cap/ [companiesmarketcap.com]

          • (Score: 3, Interesting) by JoeMerchant on Saturday July 25, @12:04PM

            by JoeMerchant (3937) on Saturday July 25, @12:04PM (#1449330) Journal

            > but two prior reasonable offers to work in an extremely safe job

            Actually, I had 3 offers in Nuclear power:

            1) 2 years on a military submarine (with the military tendency to "oops" we're not going ashore for another several months, you'll just have to serve longer)

            2) Tech support on a reactor farm - a facility of shockingly open lies and/or incompetence. On the night after the interview I met a local whose "daddy did hot laundry out at the facility, they took real good care of momma after he passed." They preferred not to talk about what they made there, but when pressed they would say "submarine fuel' - they almost certainly also make weapons grade plutonium there. While on site, one of the interviewers bragged to me about how the "local college boys are always sampling the water in the streams leaving the plant, they never find anything." Well, 3 weeks after my interview and offer which I turned down, the facility did make the news with radioactive contamination leaving the 300+ square mile facility in a stream. You may have ideals about software licenses and legal structures, my ideals formed in the 1980s were more focused around nuclear non-proliferation and self preservation from said activities. And, besides, who wants a career in IT tech support?

            3) Safety inspector for the NRC (electrical generation facilities) - this one would have been safer, but the terms of the deal included: never living in the same location for more than 2 years (to avoid becoming too familiar with the plant). This also had the idiot/liar management problem... question to interviewer (in 1989): Given the political climate around nuclear power generation, what's the future advancement path for a safety inspector? Answer: (completely avoids the question of where a safety inspector can advance to) Oh, we've got all kinds of new much safer designs, they'll be building all kinds of new plants real soon now, there will be all kinds of new plants for safety inspectors to rotate around inspecting. Here we are, 37 years later, and exactly one site in the US has constructed a new facility since that interview. By now, I would have served tours at well over half of the generation facilities, and never had the kind of close contact with management that typically gets one noticed for advancement out of one's current role. Consider the fact that our current plant inspectors either: A) believed that line of bull, or B) never asked the question in the first place.

            The money was, in fact, good in nuclear - high end of the competitive range, but the prices were high.

            >then proceeded to find a better job

            See, that's some of the advice offered by the son of the dead "hot laundry worker"... he got a job out of school in foods: General Mills. His experience in the post-graduate working world was that he could easily switch companies to Tyson, or Kraft, or Mars, but after just 4 years in the food industry, he was basically locked for life in food, nobody else would consider him, not even as entry level. My experience in medical device development was identical - locked to the industry, others won't hire you even at lower pay because they assume you'll just find something better "in your field" and leave them. There are rare cases where people with connections successfully jump industries mid career, but that's nothing to count on when you're starting out. It's not like University where you can spend half your career figuring out what you actually want your degree to be in.

            > it isn't too difficult to ensure that you don't get skin cancer with only 8 hours a day sun exposure.

            Full face mask, gloves and booties with UV goggles? They actually make such garb today, in 1991 it was very uncommon and what was available was not too compatible with flipping over rocks at the bottom of Florida bay, or the boat ride to and from. Even the boat rides at the start and end of the day are excessive exposure by even the 1991 guidelines. Now... that would have been a job I probably could have done for 6 months then "switched carreers" but I got the software offer just a couple of days later.

            Yes, I was truly evil, 22 years old, walking into a medical device development lab to write software to run on IBM compatible PCs - I should have sought out the alternatives, I should have independently crusaded on welfare and food stamps until I made something good happen in the world of software, I should have started the movement. I was five years into that job before I ever heard of Linus or Slackware - my first exposure. And I really tried to like Slackware, but it was obviously far from anything we could get our customers to use in 1996. Hell, Windows 95 was barely useable by 1996 - our customers used DOS, and in reality DOS' big favor to us was to do as little as possible.

            Why didn't you change the world? Or, did you try with all your soul and still flop so miserably that we are in the state we are today?

            >Pointing out how something is broken in the USA, does not imply that I propositioned leaving the country.

            Wuss. Why wouldn't you leave a broken country? The ultimate form of protest.

            > You don't get paid that much for doing good.

            What an absolutely self-flagellating attitude. Now we must suffer in order to do good in the world? Those who choose not to suffer financially accrue to themselves the power to do good, as I have within my roles helping advance the adoption and use of FOSS within our products. Not 100% successfully, but far more than 0, which would have been my level of influence from an IT tech support hotline jockey.

            Separately, the point of the first home was that it was attainable in this "broken country" at a price of 2.7x my starting annual salary, 2.0x after my 1st promotion. Those were market rates, market prices. Small and old, we evil closed software employees don't all take the job so we can live in McMansions.

            >Your first employer was so incompetent at such a high margin business

            You assume too much.

            --
            🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]