Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

posted by jelizondo on Monday November 02, @10:02PM   Printer-friendly

https://arstechnica.com/health/2026/10/unethical-vaccine-trial-on-babies-backed-by-rfk-jr-is-formally-canceled/

Government officials in Guinea-Bissau have formally rejected a clinical trial that would be run by Danish researchers and funded by the US to look for alleged nonspecific harms from the newborn dose of the hepatitis B vaccine. The vaccine dose is currently recommended globally for all newborns and has been used safely and effectively for decades.

In an email to Ars Technica, one of the trial's lead researchers, Christine Stabell Benn of Bandim Health Project and the University of Southern Denmark, said that Guinea-Bissau's Council of Ministers "formally reaffirmed its non-acceptance of the study on 16 October."

The revelation that the study was formally rejected last week comes after news on Monday that judicial police in Guinea-Bissau raided Bandim Health's offices and seized vaccines. Stabell Benn highlighted that the police search came after the trial was rejected.

Of the trial's rejection, Stabell Benn wrote: "We regret the decision because we considered the study scientifically and ethically justified, but we respect the government's authority to decide whether research may proceed in the country."

The World Health Organization and many outside experts have sharply disagreed with Stabell Benn and her colleagues on the trial's justifications and design. It has been widely decried as "unethical" because it would withhold the newborn dose of hepatitis B vaccine from half of the participants.

With the country's high rates of chronic hepatitis B infections, this would put thousands of babies at risk of developing a lifelong infection that can lead to liver cirrhosis, cancer, and premature death. Experts have further said that there is no scientific justification for the study, given the vaccine's long use and strong safety record. The WHO wrote in February that the trial "posits hypothetical safety outcomes without sufficient credible evidence" to justify putting newborns at risk.

Outrage erupted over the trial after the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention announced in December that it had awarded an unsolicited grant of $1.6 million to Bandim Health, which Stabell Benn runs with her husband Peter Aaby. The researchers are known for pursuing studies on nonspecific harms from vaccines and have been lauded by anti-vaccine advocates, including US Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy. But Aaby and Stabell Benn's scientific peers have been critical of the quality of their work; the researchers are currently under investigation by Danish authorities for alleged scientific misconduct in their previous studies.

Their hepatitis B vaccine trial was reportedly halted in January by Guinea-Bissau authorities. But outcry erupted again after a report that the US CDC, under Kennedy, had once set another $1.6 million aside to fund the trial and intended to move forward with it.

Stabell Benn and colleagues have publicly lamented their tie to Kennedy [website in Danish.--Ed]. They have also consistently argued that their hepatitis B study is not unethical because Guinea-Bissau does not currently offer routine hepatitis B vaccine doses to newborns. Therefore, newborns not given the vaccine in the trial wouldn't have received it outside the trial anyway. The country—which experienced a coup in November 2025—plans to introduce a birth dose in 2028, but it lacks the resources and infrastructure to do so now.

Outside experts, including the WHO, point to ethical guidelines, such as the Declaration of Helsinki, which require trials to provide the "best proven intervention" to participants, regardless of the current standard in the location where the trial is conducted. For hepatitis B prevention, the best proven prevention would be the newborn dose of the vaccine, which is globally recommended to be given within the first 24 hours of life. As the WHO wrote explicitly: "Resource constraints cannot be used to justify withholding proven care in a research study involving people."

Stabell Benn and colleagues appear impervious to this point. In a LinkedIn post Wednesday, Frederik Schaltz-Buchholzer, a Bandim Health researcher involved in the trial, blamed the backlash on the "Anglophone media" that "framed [the trial] as dangerous because there would be a control group that would have followed the current vaccine schedule" in Guinea-Bissau.

Schaltz-Buchholzer's post went on to claim that the media controversy has led to distrust of the hepatitis B vaccine in Guinea-Bissau and fears that the vaccine would pose a danger to newborns vaccinated in the trial, which he referred to as the intervention group, writing:

In the Bissau-Guinean context, it was widely understood that this trial was dangerous for the intervention group. For instance, rumours spread on social media with an omnipresent desconfiança (mistrust) that this was actually a novel vaccine to be tested by the Americans. Based on the Anglophone media coverage framing the trial as dangerous, Bissau-Guinean influencers speculated that the reason to test the hepatitis B vaccine in Guinea-Bissau was that the vaccine is dangerous, and that Bissau-Guinean newborns are disposable.

In her email to Ars Technica, Stabell Benn declined to say what reasons Guinea-Bissau officials gave for why the trial was rejected or why their office was searched and vaccine doses were seized. Ars Technica could not immediately reach Guinea-Bissau officials for comment.

But local distrust of the researchers could have played a role in the rejection and police operation. Stabell Benn said police were directed to investigate the vaccine doses directly, saying:

In its communiqué, the Council of Ministers instructed the competent authorities to investigate the origin, acquisition, transport, storage and traceability of vaccines intended for the proposed study. The Judicial Police subsequently searched the Bandim Health Project premises on 19 October and sealed the fridge containing a batch of hepatitis B vaccines. The vaccines were intended for the proposed study. The study had not begun, and none of the vaccines had been administered. We cooperated with the authorities.

Stabell Benn said the trial will not proceed and that Bandim has no plans to move it to a different location. "The underlying scientific question remains important," she said. "But any future proposal would have to arise from an appropriate local context and partnership and undergo all required scientific, ethical, and governmental reviews."


Original Submission

 
This discussion was created by jelizondo (653) for logged-in users only. Log in and try again!
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 2, Insightful) by Anonymous Coward on Tuesday November 03, @04:59AM (7 children)

    by Anonymous Coward on Tuesday November 03, @04:59AM (#1458418)

    Trials for vaccines are far more strict than those for other medical interventions because they're given to otherwise healthy people. There are (or used to be anyway) extensive monitoring systems in place that look for vaccine side effects post-approval as well, not just VAERS but the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), and several others. They never found anything more serious than what has been published. These systems were working well enough, before RFKJr and the regime gutted the CDC. Of course, if you're hell-bent on believing that all of these vaccine scientists are lying to you, there's no help for that.

    Starting Score:    0  points
    Moderation   +2  
       Insightful=1, Informative=1, Total=2
    Extra 'Insightful' Modifier   0  

    Total Score:   2  
  • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday November 03, @05:02PM (6 children)

    by JoeMerchant (3937) on Tuesday November 03, @05:02PM (#1458456) Journal

    > They never found anything more serious than what has been published.

    My question is: how seriously were they looking.

    Who wants to be the next Andrew Wakefield target of career assassination for standing up and saying something contrary to the party line? Yes, they have successfully painted him as a charlatain con-artist fraud by now. Early responses to his papers were a howling shriek and plastering of even worse science than he published as "evidence" that he was wrong. I don't believe Wakefield's results outweigh the preponderance of the evidence, but the response to his publication evoked that line from Shakespeare: "Me thinks they doth protest too loudly."

    If anything, backing of the current study by the current US administration makes it all the more suspect, but in the vein of "even a blind squirrel finds a nut once in awhile" - I don't think that shutting down investigations is the way toward better understanding.

    --
    🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
    • (Score: 1) by whibla on Tuesday November 03, @07:02PM (1 child)

      by whibla (2352) on Tuesday November 03, @07:02PM (#1458468)

      Who wants to be the next Andrew Wakefield target of career assassination for standing up and saying something contrary to the party line? Yes, they have successfully painted him as a charlatain con-artist fraud by now. Early responses to his papers were a howling shriek and plastering of even worse science than he published as "evidence" that he was wrong. I don't believe Wakefield's results outweigh the preponderance of the evidence, but the response to his publication evoked that line from Shakespeare: "Me thinks they doth protest too loudly."

      After that paper was published, over the following 8 years vaccination rates fell, in the UK at least, from ~92% to ~80%, with some areas, such as London, falling to below 60%. Measles cases rose from dozens per year to thousands per year, with a concomitant increase in deaths. In 2008 measles was once more declared endemic in the UK.

      So, if you're wondering why there might have been such a response to his paper, by medical professionals concerned about the welfare of young children, and indeed the knock-on, long term, effects upon wider society, you don't 'need' to go looking very far...

      As an aside, as a child living in the States (DC to be more specific) I myself experienced an extreme fever. Rather unsurprisingly, I do not attribute it to any vaccination(s) I had at that age - infections happen. Ironically, infections are often acquired at medical facilities - something to do with all the sick people or the doctors and nurses who, while maybe not symptomatic, having been in close proximity to all those sick people may themselves be carriers. And where do vaccinations happen? Ah, yes, medical facilities...

      • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday November 03, @07:47PM

        by JoeMerchant (3937) on Tuesday November 03, @07:47PM (#1458480) Journal

        > And where do vaccinations happen? Ah, yes, medical facilities...

        And you, yourself, have just hit on a shortcoming in the actual practice of pediatrics - exposure of the very young to a concentration of disease for the sake of vaccination. While some pediatricians' offices pay lip-service to this with a "sick waiting room" and a "well waiting room" - there is always room to do more/better. Now: are we tracking the actual harms of this incidental infection rate? Or do we all line up like cattle to go receive our "mandated jabs" and ignore the negative aspects of that procedural behavior?

        > After that paper was published, over the following 8 years vaccination rates fell, in the UK at least, from ~92% to ~80%, with some areas, such as London, falling to below 60%.

        Much like the Scopes monkey trial, an ex-Playboy bunny (J McCarthy) is a much more effective spokesperson to reach the public and influence their behavior than a bunch of un-relatable scientists going apopleptic about how idiotically wrong she and her misguided research MD are. Instead of entrenching like the US Democratic party in their perches of intellectually superior pontification, if the scientists want to get serious about public health, they need to take a cue from the current US Presidential cabinet packed with successful entertainment and public relations magnates. Of course, it's a primary goal of that administration to dismantle what little remaining power science has in the world, so... challenging times ahead.

        I believe most vaccines are net-good - maybe even all of the approved ones when viewed from a population level assessment, certainly some of the mandated vaccines are hugely beneficial with few if any negative aspects (beyond the above mentioned incidental exposure to disease pits and similar: exposure to risk during transit, etc.)

        However, I also believe that the extablishment actively, and mostly passively/structurally, suppresses information that might make their precious vaccines look less than perfect. The Wakefield fiasco did nothing to lessen that belief. That Wakefield-McCarthy were speaking directly to our in-progress personal train wrecks doesn't make what they said any more, or less, true - it was a weak case presented by a pretty face. The response it elicited from the establishment was far more damaging than the spot on Oprah, IMO.

        One regret I have regarding following medical advice came with our firstborn - his pediatrician wanted to give him the (optional, but oh so very great and wonderful) Prevnar vaccine, in short suppy you know, you're lucky I have some, but, oh, bummer, he has a slight fever - just enough to contraindicate administration - probably a mild ear infection or something - here's a script for some broad spectrum antibiotics, that should help get the fever down by your next appointment make sure you give him the whole series and we'll get him that Prevnar next time. Looking at the giant glass bottle of chalky white liquid I almost didn't give it to our little boy, the fever was very mild, he was completely asymptomatic from my perspective, but we followed the advice, gave him the full course of antibiotics - which started him having diarrhea for the next 2 years straight - and got that Prevnar jab. Woo-f-ing-hoo, now he's a bit more protected against pneumonia - quite the concern in Miami you know! His massive autism regression episode happened 4 months later.

        --
        🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
    • (Score: 2) by cmdrklarg on Tuesday November 03, @09:24PM (3 children)

      by cmdrklarg (5048) Subscriber Badge on Tuesday November 03, @09:24PM (#1458490)

      Who wants to be the next Andrew Wakefield target of career assassination for standing up and saying something contrary to the party line? Yes, they have successfully painted him as a charlatain con-artist fraud by now.

      That is because he IS a charlatan con man fraud. He put out his "study" to drum up business for himself. He should have been thrown in prison for life for the amount of harm his fraud has caused.

      --
      The world is full of kings and queens who blind your eyes and steal your dreams.
      • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday November 03, @09:55PM (2 children)

        by JoeMerchant (3937) on Tuesday November 03, @09:55PM (#1458493) Journal

        >That is because he IS a charlatan con man fraud.

        So, I do believe that he likely is, but... do you know him personally? Have you been involved in his business dealings? Or are you just parroting what you've heard? About his motivations, and intents and other inherently unknowable things...

        Was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Midgley_Jr. [wikipedia.org] evil incarnate? A heartless monster hell-bent on causing as much pain, suffering and damage to humanity and the Earth as possible? Thoughtless, clueless, and criminally negligent? Or just a pretty bright chemist doing what his bosses and industry asked of him and producing significant inventions that achieved the goals he was tasked with achieving? I don't actually know, and whatever I read is likely to be heavily biased.

        --
        🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]
        • (Score: 2) by cmdrklarg on Tuesday November 03, @10:23PM (1 child)

          by cmdrklarg (5048) Subscriber Badge on Tuesday November 03, @10:23PM (#1458495)

          I do not, and would not engage in business with him if it ever came up. He proved that he was willing to defraud others for financial gain, and as a result millions of lives have been affected negatively. Fuck him and those like him.

          RE - Midgley: I'm going to go with bright but thoughtless and criminally negligent. He badly underestimated the detrimental effects of lead (which had been known for a long time), and as a result the environment was poisoned with lead. As for heartless monsters you can assign that to his employers, especially after it became known that their product was harmful.

          --
          The world is full of kings and queens who blind your eyes and steal your dreams.
          • (Score: 2) by JoeMerchant on Tuesday November 03, @11:37PM

            by JoeMerchant (3937) on Tuesday November 03, @11:37PM (#1458498) Journal

            Likewise:

            I do not know Wakefield, and likely would not engage in business with him if it ever came up.

            He proved nothing. If the situation ever arose I would proceed with extreme caution, eyes wide open - this guy has targets full of holes all over his body, but... shortly after his retirement from Congress I met Mr. Newt Gingrich, he came to visit our hippie company with the long hair and crazy medical devices - and Mr. Ultra Conservative Red-In-The-Face beating on his lectern screaming in Congress (for the cameras) was calm, cool, considerate, and not only seemed to understand us and what we were doing, but also connected us with the money behind Home Depot as potential investors - and those guys did their due dilligence and visited us and considered the potential investment I'm sure mostly because of Newt's referral. We couldn't reach mutually agreeable terms, but at least we got the shot - because of this man who appeared for all the world to despise people like us for the previous 10 years on TV.

            So, I wouldn't say never, I would say that getting to know Wakefield in person would likely reveal a very different picture, one with many significant aspects that have never made the mainstream press.

            --
            🌻🌻🌻🌻✌️ [google.com]