AudioGuy writes "A Guardian reporter, Rebecca MacKinnon, has some interesting insights on how Chinese censorship may be inadvertently leaking into Micosoft's Bing Search engine.
"After conducting my own research, running my own tests, and drawing upon nearly a decade of experience studying Chinese Internet censorship, I have concluded that what several activists and journalists have described as censorship on Bing is actually what one might call "second hand censorship". Basically, Microsoft failed to consider the consequences of blindly applying apolitical mathematical algorithms to politically manipulated and censored web content. The algorithm deployed by Bing may be mathematically sound, but it fails to protect online freedom of expression. Bing failed to take into account the political reality of Chinese government censorship and its broader impact on the shape of the Chinese Internet. Without adjustments to how simplified Chinese websites based outside of mainland China are "weighted," exiled and dissident online voices inevitably lose out. Put it another way: an apolitical mathematical formula automatically amplifies Chinese government censorship to all people searching for simplified Chinese content anywhere in the world, not just in China."
Apparently Google had the same problem, but has managed to write code to prevent these side effects."
(Score: 3, Interesting) by TheSage on Monday February 17 2014, @12:42PM
I'm trying an EE metaphor:
The typical Page Rank algorithm works like an amplifier - giving you the main signal and ignoring the noise. The problem is, when there is an additional signal which is not as strong as the main signal. In the unmodified algorithm it gets discarded as if it were noise. This is basically the error Bing is making. Google, on the other hand, has modified the algorithm to allow for two or more signals to emerge.
Hope that makes sense
(Score: 1) by clone141166 on Monday February 17 2014, @12:48PM
That is a very nice analogy, if I hadn't posted a comment on this story already I would mod you up :)
(Score: 1) by tangomargarine on Monday February 17 2014, @05:40PM
-1 Needs More Cars ;)
"Is that really true?" "I just spent the last hour telling you to think for yourself! Didn't you hear anything I said?"