Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 16 submissions in the queue.
posted by janrinok on Wednesday September 16 2015, @05:57AM   Printer-friendly
from the can-you-recruit-some-more-please? dept.

Uber poached around 50 scientists working on self-driving car technology at Carnegie Mellon University's National Robotics Engineering Center earlier this year. Uber had been partnering with CMU to research building its own autonomous vehicles. But then it pulled from a massive venture funding war chest to hire away a lot of CMU's talent for its Uber Advanced Technologies Center.

Now, Uber appears to be publicly trying to win back the good graces of the academic community by announcing a $5.5 million gift to CMU. The money will support hiring a new robotics faculty chair and three fellowships.

"Poached around 50 scientists." CMU scientists are like the King's Deer.


Original Submission

 
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.
Display Options Threshold/Breakthrough Mark All as Read Mark All as Unread
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
  • (Score: 3, Insightful) by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @08:38AM

    by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @08:38AM (#236900)

    I didn't even know that Carnegie Mellon owned those scientists. I thought slavery was history by now.

    Starting Score:    0  points
    Moderation   +3  
       Insightful=2, Touché=1, Total=3
    Extra 'Insightful' Modifier   0  

    Total Score:   3  
  • (Score: 4, Insightful) by TheRaven on Wednesday September 16 2015, @09:24AM

    by TheRaven (270) on Wednesday September 16 2015, @09:24AM (#236906) Journal

    The problem is that universities don't offer salaries that are competitive with industry. Fun fact: in the UK, to qualify for visa category that is used for high-skill employees, you must be coming to a job earning at least £35K/year. There is only one exemption for this rule: university postdocs. We have a very hard time hiring, because our undergraduates leave with multiple job offers earning about as much as a senior lecturer (very roughly equivalent to associate professor in the US), and people leave the PhD programme with job offers that match a professor's salary.

    It's a bit easier in the USA, because academic salaries can vary between fields to compensate for industry wages, but they're still quite a bit lower than the same person could get in industry. The usual compensation is that you get a lot more freedom in academia (that's why I'm still here!), but if a company comes a long and says 'we want you to work on the stuff that you're working on now, with no need to apply for grants, long-term funding, and a higher salary' then most people would probably leave.

    --
    sudo mod me up
    • (Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @10:06AM

      by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @10:06AM (#236912)

      That still doesn't make it stealing.

      • (Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @12:44PM

        by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @12:44PM (#236940)

        It still is figuratively. You partner with someone, then they decide to walk away and take all your resources, well yeah you just had your resources "stolen" and that harbors a feeling of ill will. Is it literally stealing? No, of course not. But good luck with them trying to partner with anyone else in the academic community, which is why they're trying to buy themselves back into their good graces.

        • (Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @01:17PM

          by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @01:17PM (#236955)

          The problem is that with this kind of "figurative" use they imply that they own those workers, while in reality there's only some amount of unwritten trust broken. This is a dishonest and manipulative way of rounding towards home.

    • (Score: 2) by mmcmonster on Wednesday September 16 2015, @12:49PM

      by mmcmonster (401) on Wednesday September 16 2015, @12:49PM (#236943)

      No, the problem is universities are generating a lot of PhDs. Too many to go into academia. So some of them get poached and the university recruits some others (or creates new ones) to fill the positions.

      It's the natural order of things. Supply and demand. If the supply was low, the universities would be paying enough so that they wouldn't be poached away.

      • (Score: 3, Interesting) by mmcmonster on Wednesday September 16 2015, @12:53PM

        by mmcmonster (401) on Wednesday September 16 2015, @12:53PM (#236945)

        (Replying to myself)

        ...But that still doesn't make what Uber did right. It's downright unsociable to hire away a whole programming team from a single place. If you want to take the head and a couple underlings, fine. Whatever. But 50 scientists from a single institution is a bit much.

      • (Score: 2) by TheRaven on Wednesday September 16 2015, @01:32PM

        by TheRaven (270) on Wednesday September 16 2015, @01:32PM (#236958) Journal

        No, the problem is universities are generating a lot of PhDs. Too many to go into academia.

        That may be true across all subjects, but it isn't in computer science. Getting people to stay in academia to do a PhD is hard, after the PhD is even harder. Our PhD students go on internships where they get salaries higher than their supervisor - it's pretty difficult to persuade them that staying is a good idea after that.

        --
        sudo mod me up
      • (Score: 2) by Thexalon on Wednesday September 16 2015, @02:45PM

        by Thexalon (636) on Wednesday September 16 2015, @02:45PM (#236984)

        No, the problem is universities are generating a lot of PhDs. Too many to go into academia.

        That's not the problem at all.

        The real problem is that funding for pure research has not kept pace with the ability of the educational system to churn out people capable of doing pure research. It's not like the resources don't exist to put these would-be scientists to work: the US current has the highest GDP and highest worker productivity of any nation that has ever existed in human history, and whether you're measuring in money or physical goods there's no major lack of the necessities of life like food, water, and housing on a national scale.

        Now, you might argue: "They would be getting all kinds of investor funding if there was an ROI!". But the thing is, pure research could very easily have no ROI at all for the foreseeable future, or could have an absolutely astounding ROI that nobody could have predicted. On average, it's a huge benefit to both the country and humanity as a whole, but because the risk of failure of individual projects is so high nobody really wants to take the risk and instead will focus solely on applying other people's pure research to turn them into products that will make big bucks.

        You might also argue: "But won't they just waste the money?" But the thing is, that's never been borne out in practice. The best way to generate scientific results, both historically and today, is to set up a place where you have a whole bunch of smart people working with little-to-no direction about what they do and access to the best equipment anyone can get their hands on. There are lots of different places like this that have existed historically: Library of Alexandria, Bayt al-Hikma, Oxford University, and Bell Labs to name a few.

        So in my humble opinion, what we're actually seeing is a massive mis-allocation of resources away from potentially revolutionary scientific discoveries in favor of a tiny number of rich people having the best yachts. We're making those would-be physicists work as paper-pushers or even sometimes broom-pushers when we'd all be much better off if they could work as physicists.

        --
        "Think of how stupid the average person is. Then realize half of 'em are stupider than that." - George Carlin
        • (Score: 1) by khallow on Wednesday September 16 2015, @11:52PM

          by khallow (3766) Subscriber Badge on Wednesday September 16 2015, @11:52PM (#237193) Journal

          The real problem is that funding for pure research has not kept pace with the ability of the educational system to churn out people capable of doing pure research. It's not like the resources don't exist to put these would-be scientists to work: the US current has the highest GDP and highest worker productivity of any nation that has ever existed in human history, and whether you're measuring in money or physical goods there's no major lack of the necessities of life like food, water, and housing on a national scale.

          Because we have better things to do with our society and resources than welfare for scientists.

          You might also argue: "But won't they just waste the money?" But the thing is, that's never been borne out in practice.

          Actually, it has. Consider the research boondoggles, like the International Space Station, ITER, or the SSC. There is no historic parallel to these sorts of programs. Thus, there is no historic analogue to the waste either.

          We're making those would-be physicists work as paper-pushers or even sometimes broom-pushers when we'd all be much better off if they could work as physicists.

          Well, we need paper pushers and broom-pushers too. You really should have a better argument than more money means more research.

          The best way to generate scientific results, both historically and today, is to set up a place where you have a whole bunch of smart people working with little-to-no direction about what they do and access to the best equipment anyone can get their hands on. There are lots of different places like this that have existed historically: Library of Alexandria, Bayt al-Hikma, Oxford University, and Bell Labs to name a few.

          This is the lack of accountability fantasy. If only we gave people a bunch of money to do research without any desire or effort to see that money used productively. My view is that scientific research is no different than any other human activity. It's subject to the same economic constraints and the same temptations.

          • (Score: 2) by Thexalon on Thursday September 17 2015, @05:04PM

            by Thexalon (636) on Thursday September 17 2015, @05:04PM (#237560)

            Because we have better things to do with our society and resources than welfare for scientists.

            Like what? Do you want more money for USAF planes that don't work like the F-35? Maybe luxury yachts or a higher price for Rembrandts?

            The basic argument here follows these steps:
            1. More scientists working as scientists means more scientific research happens.
            2. More scientific research means more information about how the universe works.
            3. More information about how the universe works means more technology to take advantage of that information.
            4. More technology means more wealth and health for everybody with access to that technology.

            Consider the research boondoggles, like the International Space Station

            What makes that a boondoggle? Last I checked, we've done all sorts of research up there about all sorts of subjects. I don't expect every single experiment they run to immediately turn into lots of wealth or anything, but they're definitely doing work that can't be done on Earth.

            Well, we need paper pushers and broom-pushers too.

            Absolutely. But there are plenty of people who aren't capable of being physicists that can do that work.

            My view is that scientific research is no different than any other human activity.

            My point is that the value of scientific research is basically impossible to quantify before you do it, and the timeline for a return on your investment may be decades or even centuries long. For example, genetics will likely take about 160 years to go from initial experiments to useful technology in the form of treatments for genetic disease - the value of those treatments will be far more than the time and money spent on genetics for the last 160 years, but nobody could have predicted that in 1865. Because private economic activity is looking for maximizing short-term return on investment, no private investor would have funded any of this until very recently.

            And the thing is, smart people just fooling around get some really good results. The most obvious example of this is a couple of guys fooling around trying to get a game running on an old computer lying around the lab - from that, we got Unix and C, both of which are far more valuable to humanity and industry than the cost of paying and supplying Dennis Ritchie et al.

            --
            "Think of how stupid the average person is. Then realize half of 'em are stupider than that." - George Carlin
            • (Score: 1) by khallow on Thursday September 17 2015, @11:28PM

              by khallow (3766) Subscriber Badge on Thursday September 17 2015, @11:28PM (#237710) Journal

              Like what? Do you want more money for USAF planes that don't work like the F-35? Maybe luxury yachts or a higher price for Rembrandts?

              So because we waste money, we should waste money on your special interests? How about we not do that? And it's worth noting here that most funding of scientific research is just status signalling like luxury yachts.

              What makes that a boondoggle? Last I checked, we've done all sorts of research up there about all sorts of subjects. I don't expect every single experiment they run to immediately turn into lots of wealth or anything, but they're definitely doing work that can't be done on Earth.

              $100 billion makes that a boondoggle. As I've said elsewhere, a key problem here is considerable economic ignorance. And I have a long standing offer, if you want science at any cost, then give me a huge pile of money and I'll make sure science gets done.

              Because private economic activity is looking for maximizing short-term return on investment, no private investor would have funded any of this until very recently.

              No, this is wrong. It's the presence of considerable public funds to minimize any long term risk which created this short-term ROI trend. If you reward people to think short-term, then don't be surprised when they do. The huge public funding of scientific research is a key part of this problem BTW. Why risk your own research when you can get someone, who doesn't care whether you do anything or not, to fund it for you? That's why so many private research institutions, particularly in the business world, have declined in the past half century.

  • (Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @10:32AM

    by Anonymous Coward on Wednesday September 16 2015, @10:32AM (#236917)

    Agreed, this inflation of s-word needs to be stopped. The definition of stealing or theft is not "anything that somehow violates someone's unwarranted expectations". It ought to be "unlawful transfer of real, legally protected, recognized property in such a manner that the original owner does not possess said property anymore".

    It goes particularly ridiculous when there's a word available that has even more negative connotations yet is also more accurate.