Teenagers are more likely to plead guilty to crimes they did not commit because they are less able to make mature decisions, new research shows.
Experts have called for major changes to the criminal justice system after finding innocent younger people are far more likely admit to offences, even when innocent, than adults.
Those who carried out the study say teenagers should not be allowed to make deals where they face a lesser charge in return for pleading guilty. The study suggests young people are more likely to be enticed by these deals, and take what they see as an advantageous offer even when they have done nothing wrong.
Most criminal convictions in the UK and the USA occur as the result of guilty pleas, rather than trial. This means the majority of convictions are the result of decisions made by people accused of crimes rather than jurors.
The research was carried out in the USA, where a system known as "plea bargaining" is utilised, but the academics say their discovery has implications for countries across the world that allow teenagers accused of crimes to receive a sentence or charge reduction by pleading guilty. Specifically, the researchers recommend restricting reductions that may entice innocent teenagers into pleading guilty and making it easier for teenagers to change pleas after they have been entered.
Other research has found adolescents are less able to perceive risk and resist the influence of peers because of developmental immaturity.
https://phys.org/news/2018-03-teenagers-guilty-crimes-didnt-commit.html
-- submitted from IRC
(Score: 3, Insightful) by Thexalon on Saturday March 17 2018, @05:58PM
That's part of it.
Another part of the story: Let's say you're a public defender who has 25 cases to work on that week (many are more overworked than that). Now consider the difference in your workload between going to trial and having your client plead guilty. Your salary is a joke, and you don't get paid extra or anything if you work your butt off to win your case. So the person who is supposed to be the advocate of the accused has every incentive to get them to plead guilty, even if they think that client is innocent.
"Think of how stupid the average person is. Then realize half of 'em are stupider than that." - George Carlin