SoylentNews is people
SoylentNews
Farmers need a right to repair:
The Software Freedom Conservancy (SFC) has called upon farm equipment maker John Deere to comply with its obligations under the General Public License (GPL), which requires users of such software to share source code.
In a blog post published on Thursday, SFC director of compliance Denver Gingerich argues that farmers' ability to repair their tools is now in jeopardy because the makers of those tools have used GPL-covered software and have failed to live up to licensing commitments.
"Sadly, farm equipment manufacturers, who benefit immensely from the readily-available software that they can provide as part of the farming tools (tractors, combines, etc.) they sell to farmers, are not complying with the right to repair licenses of the software they have chosen to use in these farming tools," said Gingerich.
"As a result, farmers are cut off from their livelihood if the farm equipment manufacturer does not wish to repair their farming tools when they inevitably fail, even when the farmer could easily perform the repairs on their own, or with the help of someone else they know."
Gingerich singled out Moline, Illinois-based John Deere as a particularly egregious offender. He said that for years the SFC has attempted to work with John Deere to resolve the company's non-compliance, but the agricultural equipment maker has failed to cooperate.
"When Deere does reply (we have heard from others that their legitimate requests for source code have been met with silence), they have always failed to include the 'scripts used to control compilation and installation of the executable,' per GPLv2," Gingerich told The Register.
"And even when we were already engaged with them, and asked for source for an additional product, it took more than 10 months for them to send us the first (again, incomplete) package, which makes their offer for source hollow."
[...] Facing multiple lawsuits from farmers, who now have the support of the Justice Department and the White House, John Deere in January struck a deal [PDF] with the American Farm Bureau Federation to provide farmers with greater access to the internal workings of company's equipment.
While repair advocates considered the deal a win, they remain cautious because the company struck a similar bargain in 2018 that proved insufficient – that deal did not provide access to tools for resetting security and immobilizer locks.
As the SFC sees it, the right to repair can be best served through John Deere's compliance with the GPL.
(Score: 3, Interesting) by fliptop on Tuesday March 21, @11:44AM (2 children)
Is it possible to go back and start using simple, "analog" equipment to farm? Yes it is [youtube.com], but your yields will definitely be lower.
To be oneself, and unafraid whether right or wrong, is more admirable than the easy cowardice of surrender to conformity
(Score: 3, Interesting) by RS3 on Tuesday March 21, @05:28PM (1 child)
For anyone who doesn't fully understand the Amish and what they actually believe and do, this whole thing is an example of why they seem to shun technology. It's mostly about: they don't want to be dependent on big companies, big government, "the English" (everyone who is not Amish).
You'll see them working and talking on a cell phone. I've passed their farms where there are no power wires going to their homes or barns, but there will be solar panels. Kind of a gray area- I'm not sure what they're powering- maybe cell phone charging? Point is, they're not dependent on it for life's essentials.
To answer your question: horses, mules, water, solar, wind power. And children- lots of strong children, who, from what I've seen, are as happy as any anywhere.
(Score: 3, Insightful) by Reziac on Monday March 27, @01:47AM
It's the spiritual disconnection from "the world" that's important, more than the technology. And what's acceptable is all over the place, from Schwartzentruber Amish who live like it's 1830 and don't even use buttons on their clothes (but might use a diesel engine to power a table saw), to Beachy Amish who live in beautiful modern houses with their own power sources, and have nothing against using cell phones for business.
You can get the yield just as high as with modern equipment... provided you have enough fertilizer, and enough strong backs to do the same work in a timely manner. If you gotta pay and house that many farmhands, well, bushel for bushel, tractors and combines are cheaper. China still grows rice with hand labor.
And there is no Alkibiades to come back and save us from ourselves.