Welcome, new trolls! We're pleased as punch to have you aboard, unfortunately as you may have noticed our moderators are unable to give you the moderations you've been working so hard for. Since we can't really do much about people not moderating more, we're going to be giving out more points so that the ones that do can give you the attention you so desperately crave.
Moderators: Starting a little after midnight UTC tonight, everyone will be getting ten points a day instead of five. The threshold for a mod-bomb, however, is going to remain at five. This change is not so you can pursue an agenda against registered users more effectively but so we can collectively handle the rather large uptick in anonymous trolling recently while still being able to have points remaining for upmodding quality comments. This is not an invitation to go wild downmodding; it's helping you to be able to stick to the "concentrate more on upmodding than downmodding" bit of the guidelines.
Also, this is not a heavily thought-out or permanent change. It is a quick, dirty adjustment that will be reviewed, tweaked, and likely changed before year's end. Questions? Comments?
(Score: 2) by lentilla on Saturday August 26 2017, @11:32AM (11 children)
I've been considering something like this - let me outline my version.
There is a two-fold aim:
Implementation:
As for encouraging people to log in... I prefer reading posts by named authors. I don't care what the name is - after all, I'm using an anonymous handle here. I perceive two impediments to people posting as themselves:
There are enough people that lurk on SoylentNews to make this a tenable strategy. If the message has any credibility, it will quickly achieve a score of 0, especially if there is zero cost in the moderation. The best part is two-fold: firstly the crap never gets a chance to rise out of the bucket, and secondly, A.C. users are encouraged to post using an account.
(Score: 2) by Reziac on Saturday August 26 2017, @02:31PM (9 children)
My objection to that comes from two places:
I find that AC posts are generally of the same quality as named-posts; yeah, there's an idiot contingent but there are idiots among the named posters too. So I'm not much bothered by the fact that ACs aren't named. I suppose a hash-name could be assigned chan-style but sometimes the point of being AC is that you want to speak differently and not get dogpiled for it, and a hash-name really isn't functionally different from a nym. Anonymity matters in a free society, and I think it does to our community as well. Not to every community, but to ours, it does.
I cruise at 0 since I find that lets me see pretty much everything, but by the time I get here the genuine dross has already sunk to -1 and bothers me not -- but they're still visible inline and can be clicked on (sometimes worthwhile depending on how the discussion is going), and occasionally I do find a worthy post languishing at -1. A default below zero and now I've got to swim in the muck to see a good many posts that I now see by default. At which point I stop bothering. I can't be alone in that. The net effect would be that a good chunk of what is now a different viewpoint would be lost.
I think your system might be really good in a single-topic forum where hard facts and hard experience are the goal (eg. engineering), where informative matters far more than opinion. But here a lot of the goal IS opinion, and its cousin insight, and that needs to make a default of visible, rather than invisible.
In any event, those who don't want to see unmodded ACs can always set their comment threshold above 0.
And there is no Alkibiades to come back and save us from ourselves.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Saturday August 26 2017, @10:28PM (8 children)
None of the AC posters are as bad as Aristarchus, Buzzy or jmorris. And for the most part browsing at 0 filters out nearly all of ones not contributing anything of value.
(Score: 2) by The Mighty Buzzard on Sunday August 27 2017, @12:38AM (7 children)
You just have no appreciation for fine trolling.
My rights don't end where your fear begins.
(Score: 2) by Azuma Hazuki on Sunday August 27 2017, @07:12AM (6 children)
We can all appreciate a fine troll. You, my fine friend, are not it. Much too much emotion behind them. You shouldn't post stuff you're serious about and then go "haha only trolling" when you get your beak blasted 90 degrees off the side of your head, Daffy Duck style. Eth does it better.
I am "that girl" your mother warned you about...
(Score: 3, Touché) by The Mighty Buzzard on Sunday August 27 2017, @10:38AM (5 children)
I think you need to learn the difference between trolling and mocking you with the truth.
My rights don't end where your fear begins.
(Score: 2) by Azuma Hazuki on Monday August 28 2017, @12:22AM (4 children)
I think you need to learn the difference between truth and wishful thinking :) If your overall post history is any indication, you're just slightly less qualified to talk politics than, say, the average limpet is to teach skydiving...
I am "that girl" your mother warned you about...
(Score: 2) by The Mighty Buzzard on Monday August 28 2017, @01:48AM (3 children)
Since you seem utterly unable to distinguish between someone trolling and someone disagreeing with you, there really isn't any point in continuing this. I've tried numerous times to educate you, it just never sticks. The only conclusion left at this point is that you're just not the sharpest bowling ball in the shed.
My rights don't end where your fear begins.
(Score: 2) by Azuma Hazuki on Monday August 28 2017, @05:33AM (2 children)
We've been over this before: accusing someone else of that which you yourself are guilty does not magically absolve your of your sins. Especially when you're wrong about THAT, too. A few months ago you reached critical mass in terms of "how many people can tell Uzzard's fulla beans?" and there's no going back. Stick to what you're good at (coding, sysadmin stuff).
I am "that girl" your mother warned you about...
(Score: 2) by The Mighty Buzzard on Monday August 28 2017, @10:16AM (1 child)
I can't believe you really just replied with "No, you are!".
My rights don't end where your fear begins.
(Score: 2) by Azuma Hazuki on Monday August 28 2017, @06:26PM
Except I didn't. So your lack of belief is warranted, but like just about every time you say something not to do with technology, you're right for the wrong reasons :) Man, aren't your tailfeathers sore yet? Or do you actually *like* pain?
I am "that girl" your mother warned you about...
(Score: 3, Interesting) by urza9814 on Monday August 28 2017, @12:34PM
First off, I don't think there's any real need to punish ACs specifically. A lot of great comments come from ACs, and a lot of spam comes from logged in users. It's not like it's difficult to create a new account as you pointed out yourself.
Secondly, I've posted AC myself a few times, and I'm sure other users have as well. For example, suppose you want to post something which you aren't really supposed to be discussing due to legal/contractual obligations. There can be no free speech without anonymity.
And finally...from what I've seen of the various social networks, even forcing people to post under their actual legal identity still doesn't do a damn thing to block spam. You need to filter the content, not the users.