Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 18 submissions in the queue.

Submission Preview

Link to Story

New Hampshire Court: First Amendment Says You Can Call A Patent Troll A Patent Troll

Accepted submission by -- OriginalOwner_ http://tinyurl.com/OriginalOwner at 2018-04-14 00:05:31 from the calling-a-spade-a-spade dept.
Digital Liberty

TechDirt reports [techdirt.com]

A New Hampshire state court has dismissed a defamation suit filed by a patent owner unhappy that it had been called a "patent troll". The court ruled [PDF [eff.org]] that the phrase "patent troll" and other rhetorical characterizations are not the type of factual statements that can be the basis of a defamation claim. While this is a fairly routine application of defamation law and the First Amendment, it is an important reminder that patent assertion entities--or "trolls"--are not shielded from criticism. Regardless of your view about the patent system, this is a victory for freedom of expression.

[...]The court went on to explain that "patent troll" is a term without a precise meaning that "doesn't enable the reader or hearer to know whether the label is true or false". The court notes that the term could encompass a broad range of activity (which some might see as beneficial, while others see it as harmful).

The court also ruled that challenged statements such as "shakedown" and comparisons to "blackmail" were non-actionable "rhetorical hyperbole". This is consistent with a long [google.com] line [google.com] of cases [google.com] finding such language to be protected. Indeed, this is why John Oliver can call [hollywoodreporter.com] coal magnate Robert Murray a "geriatric Dr. Evil" and tell him [techdirt.com] to "eat shit". As the ACLU has put it [hollywoodreporter.com], you can't sue people for being mean to you. Strongly expressed opinions, whether you find them childish or hilariously apt (or both), are part of living in a free society.


Original Submission