SoylentNews is people
SoylentNews
posted by
mrpg
on Monday June 07 2021, @04:27AM
from the poisonous-pesticides-plague-the-pasture dept.
from the poisonous-pesticides-plague-the-pasture dept.
Swiss mired in poisonous row over pesticides:
[...] The Swiss will vote on Jun 13 on a proposal which, if it passes, would make Switzerland the first country in the world to ban synthetic pesticides.
Proponents seek to ban pesticides with non-naturally occurring chemicals - and not only for agriculture but also for public green spaces, private gardens, and even for killing the weeds on railway tracks.
The initiative, entitled "For a Switzerland free from synthetic pesticides", would also ban the import of foodstuffs produced with synthetic pesticides, so as not to put Swiss farmers at a disadvantage.
This discussion has been archived.
No new comments can be posted.
Swiss Mired in Poisonous Row Over Pesticides
|
Log In/Create an Account
| Top
| 39 comments
| Search Discussion
The Fine Print: The following comments are owned by whoever posted them. We are not responsible for them in any way.
Keep your laws off my body!
(Score: 5, Insightful) by VLM on Monday June 07 2021, @12:50PM (26 children)
Usually there's a lot of corruption about this.
In CA if you can distill it out of crude oil then you can spray it on an organic farm. Also generally speaking any copper compound is "organic" even if its runoff is very toxic to fish.
Note that pyrethrins are neurotoxic and super toxic to bees. Nicotine based organic farming bug killers kill a couple farmers per year, quite toxic.
Its interesting that "most" natural pesticides are broader spectrum than artificial pesticides; the swiss are essentially deciding to wipe out honeybees in their country. I can see how beekeepers would be pissed in the short term, but in the long run wiping out honeybees is not going to help the plant farmers either.
It would be interesting to see a social movement and ban on pesticides that were the most dangerous to humans and/or the environment. Unfortunately that does not seem to be the case for simplistic natural vs artificial pesticides as many of the natural ones are more dangerous than some of the artificial ones.
(Score: 4, Insightful) by esperto123 on Monday June 07 2021, @01:48PM (18 children)
That's the fallacy of natural, pesticides are a hot topic for people who still think (by innocence or malice) that anything synthetic is by itself worse than natural compounds, and this is very misleading, there are bad stuff on both sides of the fence but usually the synthetic stuff, as you said, were developed to be more targeted and to have less side effects to the environment.
(Score: 1, Interesting) by Anonymous Coward on Monday June 07 2021, @02:40PM (3 children)
We have people who are ignorant of the world they depend on and a press that functions relentlessly to increase their ignorance. When is the last time you learned anything from the mainstream press? Common people exist to be manipulated.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Monday June 07 2021, @04:03PM (2 children)
The enlightened former president warned us all about teh fake news. Don't listen to them, listen to him. /bleach
(Score: 0, Troll) by Anonymous Coward on Monday June 07 2021, @04:16PM (1 child)
You're proving his point... This [statesman.com] includes the quotation of Trump's comments regarding "bleach":
Media: "Trump said drink bleach. He literally killed people. Vote Biden or you're voting for a murderer!"
(Score: 0, Troll) by js290 on Monday June 07 2021, @09:00PM
Offtopic: between Fauci funding GOF and Birx not knowing about the history of UV irradiation, Orange Man was only sane & reasonable person up there re:'rona...
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Monday June 07 2021, @04:15PM (2 children)
Remember talking to a major potsmoker who was insisting that it was totally harmless because it's "natural, man!".
So I told him that if natural things are harmless, he should load up on totally natural cobra venom. Harmless, because it's natural!
I haven't seen a pothead so angry ever before.
(Score: 2) by DannyB on Monday June 07 2021, @06:24PM
Socrates last statement: "I drank what? . . ."
Scissors come in consumer packaging that cannot be opened without scissors.
(Score: 1) by khallow on Tuesday June 08 2021, @04:31AM
(Score: 2) by Socrastotle on Monday June 07 2021, @04:23PM (4 children)
I think most people who espouse for natural things don't even really understand why it is that natural is often preferable.
The reason is because natural things are things that have been used in many cases for thousands of years, and so unforeseen consequences can be mostly discounted. By contrast today even things as benign as paracetomol/tylenol continue to have a multitude of new micro-level effects discovered and it's effectively impossible to determine whether there are any macro-level effects simply because they've become so ubiquitous that there's really no such thing as a control sample anymore.
Of course the bastardization of this is when we are able to classify various new compounds as "natural" owing to the inability to create accurate legal definitions for such things that often have a rather hand-wavey yet still well understood connotation.
(Score: 1) by js290 on Monday June 07 2021, @04:46PM (1 child)
Naturalistic fallacy applies to ethics, not risk. The Precautionary Principle... within the statistical and probabilistic structure of “ruin” problems. [fooledbyrandomness.com]
(Score: 1) by khallow on Tuesday June 08 2021, @04:33AM
Eat your own dogfood - and choke on it.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Monday June 07 2021, @05:49PM (1 child)
> things as benign as paracetomol/tylenol
Poor example. That stuff _is_ poison. Even using the recommended daily dose for too long a consecutive period can cause liver damage. The LD50 (median lethal dose) and effective dose are way too similar. Amazing it is sold over-the-counter nearly everywhere in the world.
(Score: 2) by Socrastotle on Monday June 07 2021, @06:17PM
Yeah, very fair point. Terrible word choice on my part. I suppose by benign, I should say 'normalized' or something. Because it definitely is not benign.
(Score: 1) by js290 on Monday June 07 2021, @04:48PM (5 children)
"Name one ecosystem that is better off for having [monocrop] agriculture moved into it?" Toby Hemenway [bit.ly]
Mark Shepard on Restoration Agriculture - Abundance of Ohio River Valley during Jefferson administration [bit.ly]
(Score: 1) by khallow on Tuesday June 08 2021, @04:46AM (4 children)
(Score: 1) by js290 on Tuesday June 08 2021, @02:56PM (3 children)
"Every culture that has depended on annual plants for their staple food crops has collapsed." [bit.ly]
(Score: 1) by khallow on Tuesday June 08 2021, @04:01PM (2 children)
So has every culture that didn't depend on annual plants. And both have collapsed so multiple times. We'll need to look elsewhere for our measures of social stability.
(Score: 1) by js290 on Wednesday June 09 2021, @02:29AM (1 child)
Cataclysm vs unsustainable, un-ecological model...
Redesigning Civilization Toby Hemenway Clash of cultures HG vs agriculture "There are structural problems with a civilization built on agriculture... Sitting Bull and his people had no use for these laws... There was nothing the US govt or agriculture could offer them. They really were the freest people in the world... so [US govt] exterminated them." [bit.ly]
HG most likely to survive cataclysm @joerogan @Graham__Hancock #RandallCarlson [bit.ly]
(Score: 1) by khallow on Wednesday June 09 2021, @04:37AM
(Score: 1) by js290 on Monday June 07 2021, @04:42PM (5 children)
Mark Shepard on Restoration Agriculture - "Annual agriculture is all about living through our concepts... our idea we've imposed on reality & when reality doesn't behave according to our idea, what do we do? We input... we can never input enough to make our false concept correct." [bit.ly]
(Score: 0, Disagree) by Anonymous Coward on Monday June 07 2021, @08:32PM (4 children)
Pretty sure this guy is spamming. The links look very suspicious, anybody wanna check? I ain't doin' it!
(Score: 1) by js290 on Monday June 07 2021, @08:58PM (3 children)
Wittgenstein’s Ruler (McCarthy's Maxim): "Most of the time, people’s observations about something else reveal more about the observer than what’s being observed." [bit.ly]
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Monday June 07 2021, @09:37PM (2 children)
You could not hide your links with bitly, but I guess complaining is more your kind of speed.
(Score: 1) by js290 on Tuesday June 08 2021, @02:14AM (1 child)
An AC accusing someone of hiding, that's rich... The yt vids are bookmarked with bitly, anonymous idiot.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Tuesday June 08 2021, @02:59AM
Just cough up the real link, and you might get some respect. That "bitly" shit looks like goatse spam.
(Score: 0) by Anonymous Coward on Monday June 07 2021, @09:11PM
One of the big issues with organic is that most people have no idea about the pesticides that are allowable under the regulations. People also don't realize how dangerous naturally occurring substances can be. For example, cyanide is completely natural. Organic also includes a bunch of stuff that's really not that important while still allowing the use of pesticides that many people wouldn't expect.