SoylentNews

-- OriginalOwner_ [tinyurl.com] writes:

from the comparing-tools dept.

esr, author of "The Cathedral and the Bazaar", blogs [ibiblio.org] via Ibiblio

I wanted to like Rust. I really did. I've been investigating it for months, from the outside, as a C replacement with stronger correctness guarantees that we could use for NTPsec [a hardened implementation of Network Time Protocol].

[...]I was evaluating it in contrast with Go, which I learned in order to evaluate as a C replacement a couple of weeks back.

[...]In practice, I found Rust painful to the point of unusability. The learning curve was far worse than I expected; it took me those four days of struggling with inadequate documentation to write 67 lines of wrapper code for [a simple IRC] server.

Even things that should be dirt-simple, like string concatenation, are unreasonably difficult. The language demands a huge amount of fussy, obscure ritual before you can get anything done.

The contrast with Go is extreme. By four days in of exploring Go, I had mastered most of the language, had a working program and tests, and was adding features to taste.

The page took longer to load than I expected because it already has 175 comments.

Original Submission