Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

Submission Preview

Link to Story

High Court Finds Media Outlets are Responsible for Facebook Comments in Dylan Voller Defamation Case

Accepted submission by upstart at 2021-09-08 00:58:39
News

upstart [soylentnews.org] writes:

████ # This file was generated bot-o-matically! Edit at your own risk. ████

High Court finds media outlets are responsible for Facebook comments in Dylan Voller defamation case - ABC News [abc.net.au]:

The High Court has dismissed an appeal by some of Australia's biggest media outlets including The Sydney Morning Herald and The Australian, finding they are the publishers of third-party comments on their Facebook pages.

Key points:

  • Dylan Voller's defamation case centred on comments made by third parties on Facebook in response to news articles
  • The High Court rules media outlets are considered the publishers of the comments and therefore responsible for any defamatory content
  • The case could have far-reaching implications for how the media manages social media platforms

Former Northern Territory detainee Dylan Voller wants to sue the companies over alleged defamatory comments on their Facebook pages in the New South Wales Supreme Court.

But the case had been stalled by the dispute over whether the outlets were the publishers of the material.

The High Court todayfound that, by running the Facebook pages, the media groups participated in communicating any defamatory material posted by third parties and are therefore responsible for the comments.

Media companies argued they weren't the publishers of comments

Mr Voller's defamation case had been progressing through the courts until questions arose over whether the outlets were considered the publishers of the Facebook comments, which were posted in reply to articles written between July 2016 and June 2017.

The question was sent to the High Court [abc.net.au], and at the core of the case was the definition of publishing.

Lawyers for the media groups told the High Court they might have facilitated the process, but they were not the publishers of the material.

But lawyers for Mr Voller told the High Court that, under the law, communication of a defamatory comment did not have to be done intentionally.

"Any degree of participation in that process of communication, however minor, makes the participant a publisher," the lawyers' submissions said.

One of the difficulties for the media groups at the time was that Facebook did not allow them to turn off the comments function.

That has now changed.

Mr Voller had not suggested any of the media outlets failed to remove the comments once they became aware of them.

More to come.

More to come.

More to come.

Posted , updated Wed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amShare

Media giants say they are not the publishers of readers' Facebook comments. Today that claim will be tested [abc.net.au] Bad online reviews can cost businesses hundreds of thousands of dollars — now they want to make you pay [abc.net.au] Media giants say they are not the publishers of readers' Facebook comments. Today that claim will be tested [abc.net.au] Bad online reviews can cost businesses hundreds of thousands of dollars — now they want to make you pay [abc.net.au] More on:

The High Court has dismissed an appeal by some of Australia's biggest media outlets including The Sydney Morning Herald and The Australian, finding they are the publishers of third-party comments on their Facebook pages.

Key points:

  • Dylan Voller's defamation case centred on comments made by third parties on Facebook in response to news articles
  • The High Court rules media outlets are considered the publishers of the comments and therefore responsible for any defamatory content
  • The case could have far-reaching implications for how the media manages social media platforms

Former Northern Territory detainee Dylan Voller wants to sue the companies over alleged defamatory comments on their Facebook pages in the New South Wales Supreme Court.

But the case had been stalled by the dispute over whether the outlets were the publishers of the material.

The High Court todayfound that, by running the Facebook pages, the media groups participated in communicating any defamatory material posted by third parties and are therefore responsible for the comments.

Media companies argued they weren't the publishers of comments

Mr Voller's defamation case had been progressing through the courts until questions arose over whether the outlets were considered the publishers of the Facebook comments, which were posted in reply to articles written between July 2016 and June 2017.

The question was sent to the High Court [abc.net.au], and at the core of the case was the definition of publishing.

Lawyers for the media groups told the High Court they might have facilitated the process, but they were not the publishers of the material.

But lawyers for Mr Voller told the High Court that, under the law, communication of a defamatory comment did not have to be done intentionally.

"Any degree of participation in that process of communication, however minor, makes the participant a publisher," the lawyers' submissions said.

One of the difficulties for the media groups at the time was that Facebook did not allow them to turn off the comments function.

That has now changed.

Mr Voller had not suggested any of the media outlets failed to remove the comments once they became aware of them.

More to come.

More to come.

More to come.

Posted , updated Wed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amWed 8 Sep 2021 at 12:44amShare

Media giants say they are not the publishers of readers' Facebook comments. Today that claim will be tested [abc.net.au] Bad online reviews can cost businesses hundreds of thousands of dollars — now they want to make you pay [abc.net.au] Media giants say they are not the publishers of readers' Facebook comments. Today that claim will be tested [abc.net.au] Bad online reviews can cost businesses hundreds of thousands of dollars — now they want to make you pay [abc.net.au] More on:

News in Language Listen to the news in Warlpiri, Yolngu Matha and Kriol [abc.net.au]Top Stories

Popular Now

  1. 1.Live: Australians to get international vaccine passports from October [abc.net.au]
  2. 2.Victoria records 221 COVID-19 cases as state edges closer to vaccination target [abc.net.au]
  3. 3.Anyone can get severe illness from COVID. But these are the underlying conditions that increase your risk [abc.net.au]
  4. 4.Alex's Bible classes took over his life. Then he discovered who was pulling the strings [abc.net.au]
  5. 5.Queensland sets new vaccination record as no new COVID-19 cases detected [abc.net.au]
  6. 6.Masks here to stay and major events a long way off, new research says [abc.net.au]

Victoria records 221 COVID-19 cases as state edges closer to vaccination target [abc.net.au]Alex's Bible classes took over his life. Then he discovered who was pulling the strings [abc.net.au]Live: Australians to get international vaccine passports from October [abc.net.au]Britney Spears's father gives up conservatorship of singer [abc.net.au]Masks here to stay and major events a long way off, new research says [abc.net.au]Queensland sets new vaccination record as no new COVID-19 cases detected [abc.net.au]I get dirty looks in the supermarket — but don't be so quick to judge [abc.net.au]When a pizza store became a COVID hotspot, its owner and his young family had to go into hiding [abc.net.au]Is there any hope of getting the family together this Christmas? [abc.net.au]Victoria records 221 COVID-19 cases as state edges closer to vaccination target [abc.net.au]Alex's Bible classes took over his life. Then he discovered who was pulling the strings [abc.net.au]Live: Australians to get international vaccine passports from October [abc.net.au]Britney Spears's father gives up conservatorship of singer [abc.net.au]Masks here to stay and major events a long way off, new research says [abc.net.au]Queensland sets new vaccination record as no new COVID-19 cases detected [abc.net.au]I get dirty looks in the supermarket — but don't be so quick to judge [abc.net.au]When a pizza store became a COVID hotspot, its owner and his young family had to go into hiding [abc.net.au]Is there any hope of getting the family together this Christmas? [abc.net.au]

More Just In [abc.net.au]More Just In [abc.net.au]Back to top

Original Submission