SoylentNews

Freeman [soylentnews.org] writes:

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2023/08/isps-complain-that-listing-every-fee-is-too-hard-urge-fcc-to-scrap-new-rule/ [arstechnica.com]

The US broadband industry is united in opposition to a requirement that Internet service providers list all of their monthly fees. Five lobby groups representing cable companies, fiber and DSL providers, and mobile operators have repeatedly urged the Federal Communications Commission to eliminate the requirement before new broadband labeling rules take effect.

The trade associations petitioned the FCC [fcc.gov] in January to change the rules and renewed their call last week in a filing [fcc.gov] and in a meeting with FCC officials. The requirement that ISPs list all their monthly fees "would add unnecessary complexity and burdens to the label for consumers and providers and could result in some providers having to create many labels for any given plan," the groups said in the filing on Friday.
[...]
Comcast submitted its own filing urging the FCC to scrap the rules in June. The calls to weaken the FCC's truth-in-billing rules angered consumer advocates, as we wrote at the time [arstechnica.com]. "The label hasn't even reached consumers yet, but Comcast is already trying to create loopholes. This request would allow the big ISPs to continue hiding the true cost of service and frustrating customers with poor service," Joshua Stager, policy director at media advocacy group Free Press, told Ars.

Congress required the FCC to implement broadband labels with exact prices [arstechnica.com] for Internet service plans in a 2021 law [arstechnica.com], but gave the FCC some leeway in how to structure the rules. The FCC adopted specific [fcc.gov] label rules in November 2022.
[...]
Latino advocacy group ALLvanza also objected [fcc.gov] to the data-collection rule on privacy grounds, saying, "Many Latinos are already hesitant and/or unwilling to provide identifying information to companies or the government due to privacy concerns, fear of discrimination, potential immigration status issues, mistrust of institutions, and cultural preferences for privacy."

ISPs could avoid the requirement to collect identifying information from consumers in retail stores by providing hard copies of the label. The FCC defended the compliance plan in a submission to the OMB last month as part of the Paperwork Reduction Act review [reginfo.gov], saying it needs detailed information to ensure ISPs follow the rules.

Previously:
Comcast Complains to FCC That Listing All of its Monthly Fees is Too Hard [soylentnews.org] - 20230615

Original Submission