SoylentNews

Freeman [soylentnews.org] writes:

https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2024/02/emulation-community-expresses-defiance-in-wake-of-nintendos-yuzu-lawsuit/ [arstechnica.com]

Nintendo's recent lawsuit against Switch emulator maker Yuzu [scribd.com] seems written like it was designed to strike fear into the heart of the entire emulation community. But despite legal arguments [arstechnica.com] that sometimes cut at the very idea of emulation itself, members of the emulation development community [reddit.com] I talked to didn't seem very worried about coming under a Yuzu-style legal threat from Nintendo or other console makers. Indeed, those developers told me they've long taken numerous precautions against that very outcome and said they feel they have good reasons to believe they can avoid Yuzu's fate.
[...]
"This lawsuit is not introducing any new element that people in the emulation community have not known of for a long time," said Parsifal, a hobbyist developer who has written emulators for the Apple II, Space Invaders, and the CHIP-8 virtual machine [github.io]. "Emulation is fine as long as you don't infringe on copyright and trademarks."
[...]
And others feel operating internationally protects them from the worst of the DMCA and other US copyright laws. "I have written an NES emulator and I am working on a Game Boy emulator... anyway I'm not a US citizen and Nintendo can kiss my ass," said emulator developer ZJoyKiller, who didn't provide his specific country of residence.
[...]
Chief among those differences is the fact that Yuzu emulates a Switch console that is still actively selling millions of hardware and software units every year [arstechnica.com]. Most current emulator development focuses on older, discontinued consoles that the developers I talked to seemed convinced were much less liable to draw legal fire.

"There is a difference between emulating a 30-year-old system vs. a current one that's actively making money," Parsifal said.
[...]
Many emulator makers also largely agreed with Nintendo's arguments that Yuzu developers were too explicit about guiding users on how to play copyrighted games through channels like their Quick Start Guide and Discord channel. "I think Yuzu definitely crossed some line when they started explaining how to actually pirate games," one anonymous emulator developer told Ars.

"I've personally experienced how strict most emulator communities/discord servers/forums are regarding copyright and piracy, so it's really weird to me that Yuzu devs wouldn't be like that," Lycoder added.
[...]
Emulator developers I talked to also pointed out the fact that the Yuzu development team currently makes upward of $30,000 every month [patreon.com] through a Patreon campaign. That could imply "that their goal is profit-making and not educational," ZJoyKiller said, which is at the very least a suspect look in parts of the community.

"The fact that they are making money is a big no-no, definitely how you can get on the [legal] radar," Parsifal said.
[...]
Among the developers I talked to, it doesn't seem like Nintendo's new lawsuit has had much of a chilling effect on the work they're continuing to do on a wide array of emulation projects. "It’s more of a reminder to keep up best practices that I already try to follow," one anonymous developer told me. "It's not going to stop me from making emulators," StrikerX3 added.
[...]
For the most part, though, a healthy fear of Nintendo's litigiousness [arstechnica.com] seems to have been baked in well before this week's legal developments. "From a personal standpoint, it just reinforces that if I were to write a Nintendo emulator, even of an old system, I'd probably keep my repo completely private," ZJoyKiller said. "Or if public, I'd do so under a different account. But I've always thought this anyway. So... no, this ruling doesn't change much on how I see this."

[At time of submitting this article, I have fixed the first link in the submitted article. The first link on the arstechnica site is/was going to some weird go.skimresources.com site.]

Related Stories on SoylentNews:
Convicted Console Hacker Says He Paid Nintendo $25 a Month From Prison [soylentnews.org] - 20240205
Denuvo Promises to Kill Nintendo Switch Emulator Piracy With New Protection [soylentnews.org] - 20220828
‘Randomizers’ Are Breathing New Life Into Old Games [soylentnews.org] - 20191207
Collector Unearths Long-lost 8-bit Konami Games, Dumps Them for Emulation [soylentnews.org] - 20190904
Orbital: QEMU-Based Playstation 4 Emulator [soylentnews.org] - 20190607
HD Emulation Mod Makes “Mode 7” SNES Games Look Like New [soylentnews.org] - 20190417
Nintendo Wins Lawsuit Against ROM Sites, Defendants Agree to Pay $12.23 Million [soylentnews.org] - 20181114
EmuParadise Removes ROMs After Nintendo Sued Other ROM Sites [soylentnews.org] - 20180809

Original Submission