Stories
Slash Boxes
Comments

SoylentNews is people

SoylentNews is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop. Only 15 submissions in the queue.

Submission Preview

Link to Story

The Mind of Money: Mental Accounting Theory Checks Out

Accepted submission by hubie at 2026-11-15 22:25:00
News

When it comes to money, humans are not always rational [columbia.edu]:

First introduced decades ago, the influential concept of mental accounting posits that consumers make decisions based on subjective accounts that diverge from objective financial values. For example, consumers perceive a $100 check for overtime work differently than a $100 tax refund. One is seen as earned, and the other as a discretionary bonus. A new study of 5,589 participants across 21 countries finds evidence that this concept still holds true.

[...] The researchers say they were uncertain whether the mental accounting concept would hold up in the current environment, in which technology has completely changed our relationship with money and how we spend it. For example, the norm now is to receive both overtime pay and tax rebates via direct deposit. "Considering major changes in how we receive and spend money, especially with the proliferation of automated digital payments, a large, robust study of the concept of mental accounting was not only appropriate, it was necessary," says Ruggeri.

[...] The researchers found that mental accounting effects were weaker in lower-income countries than in higher-income countries. This may be partly because researchers originally studied mental accounting in higher-income countries. However, more critically, it may indicate that individuals with less discretionary income are more sensitive to monetary values, regardless of context. In other words, people with lower incomes or fewer economic opportunities may treat financial amounts similarly, whether they are part of major or small purchases.

Demographic factors such as age, education, and household income were not associated with mental accounting, indicating that its effects are consistent across diverse consumer groups. The researchers also found that mental accounting effects vary by social context (individual vs. interactive decisions), decision perspective (deciding for self vs. other), and role in price determination (setting vs. evaluating prices).

Ruggeri offers an example of how mental accounting applies to health care spending related to Flexible Spending Accounts (FSAs). Early in the year, consumers avoid certain health-related choices (like buying glasses or purchasing medicines) even if the money is in the account. Closer to the end of the year, they see the money as already spent (i.e., "use it or lose it"), so we are more likely to make a purchase. Ruggeri says this is a problem. "If we need these glasses or medications in July, buying them in December is not optimal. Additionally, retailers know about this behavior and may charge a premium for FSA-eligible products as annual deadlines approach, meaning we might pay even more. So we see the same $10 early in the year as "savings I shouldn't touch," but later in the year as "money I have to use."

Journal Reference: Giulia Priolo, Federica Stablum, Martina Vacondio, et al., The Robustness of Mental Accounting Across 21 Countries, Journal of Consumer Research, 2026;, ucag022, https://doi.org/10.1093/jcr/ucag022 [doi.org]


Original Submission