Judge Noël Wise denies motion to dismiss DRAM supply conspiracy suit [wccftech.com]:
Samsung, SK hynix, and Micron were already in the crosshairs of a U.S. federal class-action lawsuit that claimed the big-three DRAM manufacturers were involved in collusion to artificially limit memory supply [wccftech.com] and enjoy heaps of profits. Unfortunately for these technology giants, wiggling their way out of this situation isn't an option, as a federal judge in California has cleared the way for the antitrust lawsuit. Assuming a court order not only fines the memory makers but makes it mandatory for supply to keep pace with demand, there's potential for this crisis to end, resulting in DRAM prices finally stabilizing.
[...] While the defendants argued that their calculated moves were reactionary to the booming AI demand and mirrored a previously dismissed 2018 lawsuit, Judge Wise disagreed, stating, "The Court finds that it is not." Addressing the companies' defense that competitors in concentrated markets naturally watch one another closely, she wrote, "But Plaintiffs' allegations go beyond hawks watching each other; their contentions are more akin to hawks flying in formation, an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do."
According to the complaint, the three manufacturers began cutting conventional memory production in late 2022 and redirected wafer capacity toward High Bandwidth Memory (HBM) in 2023. This allocation shift drove conventional DRAM prices up by an eye-popping 697 percent over just an 18-month span without any of the companies expanding output. Since HBM requires three to four times more silicon wafer area per GB than standard DDR5 memory, the shift severely tightened consumer and PC supply, creating clouds of misery for the entire industry.
Judge Wise did find that there were several coordinated actions executed beyond ordinary market behavior that would be difficult to reverse without a prior understanding. More specifically, Samsung and SK hynix refused long-term contracts (LTAs) with major conventional DRAM buyers, while also delaying or halting new DRAM fabrication plants. Furthermore, the three firms wound down DDR4 production in the same quarter of 2025, along with Micron's December 3, 2025 announcement that it would be shutting down Crucial, its 30-year-old consumer memory brand.
A copy of the legal document can be found at https://litnews.ai/opinions/cand/5-26-cv-06345/ecf-68.pdf [litnews.ai].