SoylentNews

canopic jug [soylentnews.org] writes:

Charlie Stross, a science fiction writer based in Scotland, has written a post about different possible approaches to space colonization [antipope.org]. He includes a discussion of several different models.

While the strong form of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis [wikipedia.org] is evidently invalid, a weaker version—that language influences thought—is much harder to argue against. When we talk about a spaceship, a portmanteau word derived from "[outer] space" and "ship", we bring along certain unstated assumptions about shipping that are at odds with the physical parameters of a human-friendly life support environment for traversing interplanetary distances. Ships, in the vernacular, have captains and a crew who obey the captain via a chain of command, they carry cargo or passengers, they travel between ports or to a well-defined destination, they may have a mission whether it be scientific research or military. And of these aspects, only the scientific research angle is remotely applicable to any actually existing interplanetary vehicle, be it a robot probe like Psyche [wikipedia.org] or one of the Apollo program [wikipedia.org] flights.

(Pedant's footnote: while the Apollo crews had a nominal commander, actual direction came from Mission Control back on Earth and the astronauts operated as a team, along lines very similar to those later formalized as Crew Resource Management [wikipedia.org] in commercial aviation.)

Anyway, a point I've already chewed over on this blog is that a spaceship is not like a sea-going vessel [antipope.org], can't be operated like a sea-going vessel, and the word "ship" in its name feeds into various cognitive biases that may be actively harmful to understanding what it is.

Which leads me to the similar term "space colony": the word colony drags in all sorts of historical baggage, and indeed invokes several models of how an off-Earth outpost might operate, all of which invoke very dangerous cognitive biases!

There are few more models which he missed.

Previously:
(2022) Moon Life 2030 [soylentnews.org]
(2022) Why Werner Herzog Thinks Human Space Colonization “Will Inevitably Fail” [soylentnews.org]
(2020) Elon Musk Will Run Into Trouble Setting Up a Martian Government, Lawyers Say [soylentnews.org]
(2018) Who Owns The Moon? A Space Lawyer Answers [soylentnews.org]
(2017) Stephen Hawking Urges Nations to Pursue Lunar Base and Mars Landing [soylentnews.org]
(2015) NASA Working on 3D Printers to Print Objects Using Martian Regolith [soylentnews.org]

Original Submission